Theatre reviews roundup: The Cherry Orchard with Kristin Scott Thomas

Kristin Scott Thomas & Stephen Mangan shine in Chekhov’s tragi-comedy

Harold Pinter Theatre
Kristin Scott Thomas in The Cherry Orchard. Photo: Johan Persson

All eyes were on this production after the previously successful Chekhov productions from the same artists- The Seagull starring by an Olivier Awrad winning Kristin Scott Thomas, and Uncle Vanya directed by Ian Rickson and adapted by Conor Mcpherson. For most of the critics, The Cherry Orchard didn’t quite match the glories of those productions, but it was still much appreciated: ‘Ian Rickson’s elegantly directed production uses a plain-speaking new adaptation by Conor McPherson’ (Guardian). Kristin Scott Thomas was highly praised (‘luminous’ CityAM) as the down-at-heel aristocrat. So was Stephen Mangan as her would-be rich working class would-be saviour (‘a serio-comic masterclass’ Standard). All the cast were complimented for their portrayals of the motley collection of characters unable to come to terms with change.

[Links to full reviews are included but a number are behind paywalls and therefore may not be accessible]

4 stars ⭑⭑⭑⭑

Dave Fargnoli of The Stage was impressed: ‘Sweeping through the familiar passages of Chekhov’s tender tragicomedy like a crisp autumn breeze, this faithful new adaptation from celebrated playwright Conor McPherson is refreshing, clear and unfussy. McPherson’s lucid take on the story of fading aristocracy glitters with moments of disarming vulnerability and deadpan humour that honours Chekhov’s play while illuminating subtext, developing the dramatic potential of some relationships and alighting on unexpected interpretations of others. Director Ian Rickson paces it decorously, allowing each scene plenty of time to breathe, but never letting the pace flag, wringing out laughs with physical comedy and wry, rapid-fire punchlines. The atmosphere that develops is at once ghostly, fragile as cobwebs, and unexpectedly warm-hearted, full of bittersweet yearning.’

CityAM‘s Adam Bloodworth thought: ‘Luminous Kristin Scott Thomas is the perfect choice for eccentric, blinkered stateswoman Lyubov Ranevskaya in Anton Chekhov’s The Cherry Orchard, a mound of gesticulating passion and nostalgic delusion as the broke matriarch being slowly and painfully dethroned from her Russian country pile.’ He pointed out: ‘Conor McPherson and Ian Rickson’s new adaptation leans into the script’s farcical elements. In particular, Rickson exploits Mangan’s comedic nose; at times his performance nears slapstick, but he carries a general effeteness and lightness of touch that makes him an interesting provocateur opposite (Scott Thomas’s) airily out of touch matriarch.’

The Telegraph‘s Dominic Cavendish dwelt on the quality of the cast: ‘displaying her gift for clenched emotion… the star stamps her mark on the superficially carefree, inwardly agonised heroine, Ranevskaya (…) The low-born local businessman Lopakhin, brilliantly played by Stephen Mangan with sheepish charm and evident inner conflict’. There are, he said: ‘glorious performances across the board and the generations: mention should be made of Vinette Robinson as her long-suffering adopted daughter Varya; Shubham Saraf as the accident-prone, lovelorn Yepikhodov; and Jeff Rawle as the dotty, hard-up landowner Pishchik. Karl Johnson, simply superb throughout, supplies the requisite pathos as the scatty old retainer Firs, left to his own devices in a final, presumably fatal act of abandonment that tallies the cost of the others’ self-absorption.’

Alun Hood of WhatsOnStage declared: ‘Rickson’s direction is masterful, alive to every nuance, confidently embracing the dualities in Chekhov’s text: these people are deeply unhappy yet uproariously funny, and the sense of lives about to change forever is keenly felt. McPherson’s script is salty and smart and, most laudably, never sounds like a translation. Not everything about the update works, but that’s a small quibble about an emotionally intelligent production that renders a classic play alive and accessible, while still satisfying the most exacting of Chekhov enthusiasts, and boasting one of the greatest ensemble casts on any current London stage.’

Marianka Swain for LondonTheatre noted: ‘When Kristin Scott Thomas’s Ranevskaya returns home to this place full of ghosts, she describes it as a “crossroads”, and that sense of a liminal space – between past and future, one world and the next – pervades both Conor McPherson’s evocative new translation of Chekhov’s masterpiece and Ian Rickson’s gorgeous, elegiac production.’

The Independent‘s Alice Saville remarked: ‘What really does shine is Rickson’s mastery of Chekhov’s humour, in a production that never feels drawn-out or stodgy. This play is very, very funny, until it’s not – until you realise that this estate has stolen untold lives for centuries, and these unlucky, lingering, lovable few must pay the price.’

The Standard‘s Nick Curtis described the stars’ performances: ‘Scott Thomas gives a twitchy, strained, rictus-smiling central performance as Ranevskaya, the adored but terminally feckless landowner who seemingly can’t bear to be in a room with herself. She’s always slipping out of embraces and tricky situations, squirreling secretive drinks. Mangan delivers a serio-comic masterclass in timing and fretful awkwardness as the peasant turned businessman Lopakhin, and the supporting cast is impressive. The whole thing is a little rough around the edges but … also thrilling and refreshing.’

Time Out‘s Andrzej Lukowski pointed out: ‘Adapting playwright Conor McPherson cranks up both the bitter and the sweet as he massages the plot and dialogue for some big laughs … More importantly, there (is) an absolutely storming performance – dare I say career best – from the perennially underestimated Stephen Mangan as Yermolai Lopakhin. A self-made man of humble origins, his relationship with the lofty but impoverished household of Lyubov Ranevska (Kristin Scott Thomas) is the complicated heart of play.’ He concluded: ‘it’s the more painful emotions that linger in the splendid central turns from Scott Thomas and Mangan, the sense of people too in love with a perfect past to ever truly embrace an imperfect future.’

3 stars ⭑⭑⭑

Tim Bano for The Financial Times had mixed feelings about the mixed moods: ‘McPherson’s adaptation … clearly relishes the tonal shifts in Chekhov: they both enjoy weaving their plays with threads of daft humour as much as with anxiety and grief. That makes things difficult for the actors. Kristin Scott Thomas sticks very much to the serious side as once-wealthy landowner Ranevskaya … you get the sense of someone resentful of being the all-powerful matriarch, and so putting on an act of inertia and helplessness. It’s almost like she wants the coming reckoning. But it’s an uneven performance, as she underplays some moments and overcooks others. Though Mangan brings that expert comedy depth, even more thrilling is when he plays the tragedy, too. When his Lopakhin returns from the auction of the estate to reveal he’s bought it himself, the way he mutates nervousness into glee into disappointment is remarkable to watch.’

Gary Naylor for BroadwayWorld wasn’t convinced: ‘The Cherry Orchard is a state of the nation play – any time, any place – but it’s also a monument of literature, making the heart soar and dip as you see these fragile men and women make mistakes and take their chances. But Ian Rickson’s production doesn’t quite catch all the heights and depths of the emotions, the technical efficiency rather limiting the stakes. Do we really feel Madame’s despair as the orchard is cut down in plain sight as she stands next to her luggage, never to return? Do we really feel Lopakhin’s insensitive triumph, guilty but holding back a smirk? Do we really feel Firs’ isolation in a new world come to crush him at last?’

The Times’ Clive Davis observed: ‘all eyes are on Scott Thomas as her character wraps herself in illusions. There is sometimes an emptiness to her eyes that is quite chilling, as if she is living her real life inside her head. When she is not at the centre of things, though, the evening falters.’

The Guardian‘s Arifa Akbar thought: ‘Kristin Scott Thomas … brings a hard-edged modernity that you believe in. She feels of our time, despite the references to dachas and peasants, and could be an upper-middle-class Chelsea mother or minister’s wife, stewing in regret and an unfulfilled life. Ian Rickson’s elegantly directed production uses a plain-speaking new adaptation by Conor McPherson. (…) (it) is handsome and engaging, the crumbling drawing room of Chloe Lamford’s set design bearing damp patches and a faded grandeur.’ However, she felt: ‘some of the edges are softened, such as the fire of student and would-be revolutionary Trofimov (Jack Riddiford). You don’t feel much pathos for the set as a whole, and the drama never quite enters dark or tragic territory.’

2 stars ⭑⭑

The Daily Mail’s Patrick Marmion didn’t like the anachronistic adaptation: ‘The Cherry Orchard is a subtle study of tragic self-delusion from a time when Russian society was falling apart before the first revolution of 1905. Yet in Conor McPherson’s hollowed-out ‘reimagining’ of the play, any sense of place or class struggle has all but vanished. Instead, the action looks like it’s been transferred to the 1980s – a peculiar move, at odds with continued references to the end of serfdom in 1861.’ He ended his diatribe: ‘it’s like watching a herd of cats purposelessly gathered on Chloe Lamford’s damp-riddled set. A few desultory artefacts, including a shrine of religious icons, are largely ignored – just like the play’s historical moment.’

Critics’ average rating 3.5⭑

Value rating 37 (Combination of average rating and typical ticket price)

The Cherry Orchard can be seen at the Harold Pinter Theatre until 9 January 2027. Buy tickets from haroldpintertheatre.co.uk

Read Paul Seven’s review of The Cherry Orchard here

If you’ve seen this production of The Cherry Orchard, please leave your review and rating below

Theatre reviews roundup: Rent

New production does Rent’s score justice

Tom Stoppard Theatre
The cast of Rent at the Tom Stoppard Theatre. Photo: Pamela Raith

Luke Sheppard, perhaps best known for Paddington The Musical, has directed an in-the-round production of Jonathan Larson‘s 1990s musical about love, creativity in the shadow of AIDS. The critics mostly felt it did justice to the score but some found the storyline was drowned by the fabulous songs. Stranger Things’ Gaten Matarazzo acquitted himself well.

5 stars ⭑⭑⭑⭑⭑

Marianka Swain for LondonTheatre said: ‘under Luke Sheppard’s electrifying direction, it … packs an almighty punch. It honours the soul of the original, while making it feel thrillingly fresh’. She clearly loved this musical: ‘its passion is undeniable, especially the oft-cited line “No day but today”, which is both wrenchingly sad and a call to action. As Mark puts it: “The opposite of war isn’t peace – it’s creation”. RENT is a soul-stirring act of creation, and so too is this exhilarating revival.’

4 stars ⭑⭑⭑⭑

‘this is a thrilling musical, both perfectly of its time and still relevant today’ declared WhatsOnStage’s Sarah Crompton. She explained: ‘The in-the-round staging has been preserved for this larger and more splashy West End revival and it helps to lend great spirit and energy to a piece that is baggy and episodic but always engaging.’ She went on: ‘Sheppard’s direction is also cleverly paced, letting big scenes – Maureen’s “arty” performance to demand proper housing for the homeless, the meeting at the Life Café – unfold with panache, while keeping the focus on the individual stories that are being told. The actors are all are terrific.’

The Times’ Clive Davis described how ‘With cast members seated in a semicircle around the stage (some audience members are up there too), David Woodhead and Tom Jackson Greaves, the designer and choreographer …  generate a rock club-style sense of community (…)  Katy Richardson’s band, half-concealed on a raised platform at the rear of the stage, is suitably loud and loose-limbed.’

The Financial Times‘ Sarah Hemming was also impressed that ‘The Tom Stoppard Theatre (formerly the Duke of York’s) has been reconfigured to embrace a portion of the audience onstage, with the cast weaving through them and sometimes sitting among them before rising to sing. It’s a change that wraps the spectators in “la vie bohème”, as it’s depicted here, emphasising the communality at the musical’s heart and giving a rough, impromptu feel to the production that contrasts with the blazing professionalism of its execution. It just adds to the soaring emotion of this pulsating staging.’ She had reservations: ‘the storylines tend to crowd each other out (…) And the episodic, propulsive nature of the piece undercuts the weight of the issues. The ravages of both Aids and heroin addiction are framed a little too aesthetically.’ But ‘Flaws aside, this is still an exhilarating show, superbly delivered, its central message about making the best of your brief time on earth powering across loud and clear.’

The Telegraph‘s Dominic Cavendish this rousing, felt this ‘faithful revival by Paddington director Luke Sheppard more than earns its keep. It boasts a strong West End debut, too, for Gaten Matarazzo.’ He complimented all the cast: ‘Every leading player gets the opportunity to shine, with particularly fine performances from Travis Ross as the brooding Roger, always plugging away in the hope of writing one last belter; Alexa Lopez as Mimi, sexually cavorting and howling like a wolf in the love-hungry Out Tonight; and Jeevan Braich, flamboyant and defiant as Angel.’ He noted: ‘as the show has become more distinctly of its time, it paradoxically looks more durable – it captures a vanished New York but its relentless spirit seems undimmed.’

Louis Chilton for The Independent concluded: ‘At the end of the day, the big question facing a revival like this is whether it can fundamentally justify its own existence. Rent manages that, and then some.’

Aliya Al-Hassan of BroadwayWorld declared: ‘(Larson’s) lyrics hit as hard as ever, even though the duration (two hours, 45 minutes) may be a little too long for some. This version of Rent deserves the hype it has been receiving and is a fitting tribute to the monumental legacy of a musician and creative genius that we lost far too young.’

3 stars ⭑⭑⭑

Tom Wicker for The Stage pronounced: ‘There’s a fierce, sincere anger in the book and lyrics at the heartless gentrification of New York (now pretty much complete) and power in its centring of queer characters. But its earnestness, however on the money, feels heavy-handed.’

Time Out’s Andrzej Lukowski (3 stars assumed) was more critical of the production: ‘The concert-like production is based around an ensemble of hot androgynes and self-consciously beautiful misfits, dressed like a more-stylish-than-it-sounds collision of Dickensian urchinwear and early Pearl Jam chic. Sheppard has put a large amount of additional audience seating on the stage, which hems the action into a small performance space with minimal sets (…) It would be a great staged concert but I’m not sure how well it works as a theatre show. Sheppard’s aesthetic choices seem to override his interest in storytelling (…) A formidable vehicle for Larson’s songs, but a less impressive one for his story.’

David Jays for The Guardian wasn’t sure about the strength of the book (‘keeping eight principal characters in play is tricky’) but ‘The glory of the show is its songs – the bolshie ensembles and scared solos. Larson threw everything into Rent, from wrenching anthems and witty tango to strutting pop. He must have hoped to have more musicals ahead of him, but wrote like he was running out of time – that desperate sense to write the songs, love the love and live the life is the urgent heart of the show.’

Adam Bloodworth for CityAM was critical: ‘by today’s standards, taking something so horrific as AIDS, which took the lives of 20,000 Brits alone, and putting it as a backdrop to a central story about people getting kicked out of their flats (which is dealt with with far more emotion) feels strange and tone deaf.’ He opined: ‘the story line (is) often there to service the arrival of the next song rather than advancing the plot’.

Critics’ average rating 3.8⭑

Value Rating 38 (combination of average rating and typical ticket price)

Rent can be seen at the Tom Stoppard Theatre until 29 May 2027. Buy tickets from the theatre tomstoppardtheatre.com

If you’ve seen Rent at the Tom Stoppard Theatre, please leave your review and rating below

Theatre reviews roundup: Affluenza

The worst play of 2026?

Riverside Studios
Noah Schnapp in Affluenza. Photo: Danny Kaan

Affluenza , written and directed by Andy Sandberg, is a candidate for the worst play of the year according to the critics. Why? ‘It’s not deep nor funny, it lacks pace and determination, and it’s ultimately an atrocious watch’ (BroadwayWorld). The stage debut of Noah Schnapp didn’t save it: ‘Schnapp is the main draw but doesn’t have much to do in either of his thinly-sketched roles beyond swear and strop around’ (WhatsOnStage).

[Links to full reviews are included but a number are behind paywalls and therefore may not be accessible]

2 stars ⭑⭑

Aliya Al-Hassan for LondonTheatre suggested: ‘A dramaturg is urgently needed to add structure to a production that goes off on bizarre and unnecessary tangents’. She described it as ‘a missed opportunity to say anything thoughtful at all.’

Holly O’Mahony for The Stage found: ‘it grows increasingly directionless and leaves you unsure of exactly what it is you have just watched.’

The Standard‘s Nick Curtis reported: ‘For the record, Schnapp is fine, and Manrara isn’t bad, but there’s no real depth to anyone or anything here.’

1 star ⭑

The Guardian’s Arifa Akbar was puzzled that ‘Both (Schapp’s) characters are supporting parts, taking up so little oxygen on stage that you wonder why anyone would cast a big name and then tuck it away in two bit-parts?’ Similarly, ‘Janette Manrara is acting rather than foxtrotting here, but again plays a host of tiny roles’. In fact, she was mystified by the whole play: ‘It is hard to decipher what we are watching here – comedy, drama or a theatrical car crash in slow motion.’

Theo Bosanquet for WhatsOnStage declared: ‘it goes on one of the most head-scratchingly befuddling narrative trajectories I’ve ever seen on stage.’ He notedf: ‘Schnapp is the main draw but doesn’t have much to do in either of his thinly-sketched roles beyond swear and strop around, while Young is convincing as the lawyer but woefully miscast as the adult Noah’.

Cindy Marcolina let rip in her BroadwayWorld review: ‘not even a lavish set by Charlie Corcoran can hide the fact that this is a tasteless, aimless, pointless piece of theatre.’ She continued: ‘It’s almost unimportant to talk about the performances, as none of them make a difference…Schnapp is merely adequate, but the script wouldn’t allow him to be anything else. The rest of the cast amble between wooden, overdramatic, underachieving, and eager to see the curtain drop. It’s understandable: AFFLUENZA doesn’t add anything to the landscape. It’s not deep nor funny, it lacks pace and determination, and it’s ultimately an atrocious watch. ‘

Louise Penn for Plays International complained: ‘Affluenza is a victim of its own self-importance, and by the end it has collapsed into a ridiculous turn of events blighted by pizza boxes, shouting, and a plot which is impossible to follow. When so little of a play makes sense, it is hard to recommend it on any level.’

‘Unfortunately there’s not an ounce of subtlety in the script or Sandberg’s direction’ said The Times’ Clive Davis.

Critics’ average rating 1.4⭑

Affluenza can be seen at Riverside Studios until 28 November 2026. Buy tickets from riversidestudios.co.uk

If you’ve seen Affluenza, please leave your review and rating below

 

Theatre reviews roundup: TRU with Jesse Tyler Ferguson

5 star acting, 3 star play

Menier Chocolate Factory
Jesse Tyler Ferguson in TRU. Photo:Johan Persson

The critics lavished praise on Jesse Tyler Ferguson‘s portrayal of Truman Capote (‘captivating’ LondonTheatre) but were disappointed by Jay Presson Allen‘s play (‘shapeless’ Telegraph). They loved Paul Farnsworth‘s set which changed the whole auditorium into a replica of Capote’s apartment.

4 stars ⭑⭑⭑⭑

The Guardian‘s Mark Lawson made the point: ‘Here is a particularly frustrating example of an at least five-star performance of an at best three-star script. I’ve split the difference while wishing Tyler Ferguson a different text. A new play about Capote would require him to offer a stronger defence about treacherous use of others’ lives than a Broadway museum piece that sounds oddly light about addiction and betrayal.’

Aliya Al-Hassan reviewing for LondonTheatre praised the star: ‘Ferguson is captivating in the role: camp, catty, and totally unapologetic. Capote is a distinctly unlikable character in many ways, categorising his friends into ‘A’ or ‘B’ lists in a conversation with his florist and name-dropping at every opportunity. But Ferguson also elicits a huge amount of sympathy for this damaged man who struggles with alcoholism, narcissism, and, ultimately, acute loneliness. It would be easy to tip into parody of Capote’s unique vocal pitch and intonations, but Ferguson strikes a considered balance.’ And the set: ‘It’s unlikely you will see a more detailed and thoughtfully contructed set: Paul Farnsworth’s utterly immersive design transforms the whole space into Capote’s New York residence, complete with handwritten notes, his collection of paperweights, crammed bookcases, and framed photos on every surface. It feels like a deeply personal space into which we are invited. Seating is dotted around on sofas, armchairs and stools so audiences feel they are an active and valuable part of the production.’

Clementine Scott for BroadwayWorld commented: ‘This Capote gains sympathy for his lonely melancholy after a lifetime of social climbing, but loses it with his ruthless callousness towards his friends (…) This version of Capote meanders from his childhood, to his alcoholism and suicidal ideation, and back to celebrity namedropping, without ever dwelling too much on any one theme. The effect is gossipy and alluring, but Presson Allen sometimes strays dangerously far from the point.’

Writing for WhatsOnStage, Sonny Waheed said: ‘Tru delivers a beautifully realised evening in the company of one of the great wits of the last century, led by an understatedly magnetic Ferguson and housed in a remarkable set that puts you right inside Capote’s apartment. Despite the story never quite building to anything substantial, it is rarely less than great fun and every so often it catches you with something much sadder. Well worth pulling up a chair for.’

3 stars ⭑⭑⭑

The Times’ Dominic Maxwell exhorted: ‘If you want to see a really fine performance, go see Jesse Tyler Ferguson as Truman Capote inTru.’ He continued: ‘And if you want to see — or be in — a really fine set, come and be wowed by how the designer Paul Farnsworth has turned the Menier Chocolate Factory in London Bridge into an outsized reimagining of Capote’s brown-and-burgundy New York living room.’ There had to be a catch: ‘If you want to see a really fine play… well, two out of three ain’t bad.’ He concluded: ‘It’s a beguiling novelty for a while, yet it’s interesting rather than really dramatic.’

The Stage’s Sam Marlowe found: ‘for all Tyler Ferguson’s magnetism, Tru is too brittle, bitchy and self-interested to care much about. He’s mildly diverting company, for a while; but that’s not enough, unfortunately, to sustain the play.’

Time Out‘s Andrzej Lukowski loved the set that turns the Menier into Capote’s apartment: ‘The actual play can’t really live up to the magnificence of the setting. That’s not the fault of performer Jesse Tyler Ferguson, who offers a funny, often very poignant channeling of the Alabama-raised author and socialite. That distinctive voice could so easily fall into parody – it was half a parody already. But Ferguson brings Capote to life’. He noted: ‘Ferguson’s lugubrious tone and charismatic performance – witty, self-pitying, caustic, irrepressible – does a hell of a good job of persuading us that this is one continuous coherent train of thought. But the fact is it’s not, as inevitably he moves from subject to subject without an entirely satisfying structure.’

The Standard‘s Nick Curtis talked about the set: ‘Come for Modern Family star Jesse Tyler Ferguson’s waspish performance as Truman Capote, stay for Paul Farnsworth’s magnificent, immersive set. In Rob Ashford’s staging of Jay Presson Allen’s almost-monologue, the audience is seated around a sumptuous evocation of the writer and social gadfly’s overstuffed New York apartment.’

2 stars ⭑⭑

Claire Allfree for the Telegraph didn’t like it: ‘The problem is not Ferguson, who captures not only Capote’s needling combination of self-loathing and hubris but also his curious physical tics, while managing to make him both intriguingly complex and interestingly unlikeable. No, the difficulty is Allen’s shapeless monologue, which never finds a convincing dramatic framework: to whom Capote thinks he is talking when he acknowledges the audience directly is a question not so much left unresolved as barely even considered.’ She summed up: ‘In the end, watching Tru is a bit like attending a party full of strangers and spending the whole evening wondering exactly why one bothered.’

Critics’ average rating 3.3⭑

TRU can be seen at The Menier Chocolate Factory until 14 November 2026. Buy tickets from the theatre 

If you’ve seen Tru starring Jesse Tyler Ferguson, please leave a review and rating below 

Theatre reviews roundup: Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf?

Gillian Anderson & Billy Crudup in the play of the year

@sohoplace
Gillian Andersen & Billy Crudup in Who’s Afraidn of Virginia Woolf? Photo: Johan Persson

The critics loved this production of Edward Albee’s classic play about a drunken couple taking out their pain and disappointment on each other. Praise was showered 5-star reviews on Gillian Anderson (‘a performance of masterful control’ Telegraph) and Billy Crudup (‘phenomenal’ Time Out). They also loved the intimacy of the in-the-round production directed by Marianne Elliott (‘so close to its players that you end up feeling skin-crawlingly guilty by association’ Independent) and Miriam Buether’s set (‘a slowly revolving gladiatorial arena’ Standard).

[Links to full reviews are included but a number are behind paywalls and therefore may not be accessible]

5 stars ⭑⭑⭑⭑⭑

WhatsOnStage‘s Sarah Crompton praised the play, saying it ‘sizzles with energy and power. In a production as good as this one, starring Gillian Anderson and Billy Crudup as Martha and George, the couple whose drunken sparrings stretch over a long night’s journey into day, pulling their house guests, ambitious academic Nick (Josh Dylan) and his frail wife Honey (Phoebe Horn), into their emotional maelstrom, it has the capacity to hold an audience spellbound.’ She concluded: ‘There’s something magnificent about seeing one of the great American plays so clearly realised and rethought. There are no gimmicks here, just clarity and respect. It is a great night at the theatre.’

Claire Allfree for the Telegraph declared: ‘Albee isn’t simply exposing the disappointments at the heart of marriage but the fictions we construct to shield ourselves from the uncertain future of a civilisation in irredeemable decline. What a play. What a production.’  She described how ‘Anderson, in a performance of masterful control, slowly strips herself back to reveal the desolation beneath. Crudup’s superficial affability gradually curdles into a desperate, bleak self-loathing. They emerge less as two irreparably damaged people locked in a marital cage fight than as equal players in a perverse love story.’

Time Out’s Andrzej Lukowski liked it: ‘Marianne Elliott’s in-the-round production is so intimate – not to mention intense – that after a while the thrill of Anderson and her co-star Billy Crudup being a couple of metres away is replaced by a sort of horror, a sense that we are not simply watching events from a distance, but are physically in the room for the madness.’ He noted: ‘If Anderson is good, Crudup is phenomenal … he is tremendous as the at first urbane, likeable George, who seems like the milder, more sophisticated partner to the coarser, angrier Martha. Squint and he’s the victim in the marriage. But as the night wears on, there’s something sinister about his self-containment and his inability to match Martha’s outbursts: his restraint becomes ominous and nakedly manipulative (…) Crudup is a model of restraint and nuance and that just makes his George all the more sinister – a virus quietly infecting everyone else’s brains.’

For Olivia Rook of LondonTheatre: ‘Crudup’s pedantic George is a revelation. He is bristling with resentment towards his lot in life (…) He wears a mask, lightly passing cruel judgements, asking intrusive questions, and malevolently pursuing his guests like prey, but even he has flashes of vulnerability: shattering a bottle, wrapping his hand around Martha’s neck, and growling like a caged animal when he hears her sounds of lovemaking with another man.’ She went on: ‘Anderson matches his vitriol, endlessly badgering George and name-calling, thrusting her finger in his face as she leaves the stage, determined to have the final word. Her nasal twang grates appropriately, as she repeatedly rips into her husband, abusing their shared history to tap into all his weak spots.’ She was gripped: ‘The audience’s horror is mirrored in their eyes during the desperate, devastating final act — named “The Exorcism” — when Martha and George peel away the layers of viciousness to reveal the achingly empty core of their relationship. There is to be no more pretending — and that final punch lands hard.’

The Independent‘s Alice Saville enthused: ‘Marianne Elliott’s blistering @sohoplace production comes as a shock, putting the audience so close to its players that you end up feeling skin-crawlingly guilty by association. Gillian Anderson and Billy Crudup prowl about a round stage like wounded lions, endlessly battling for dominance – only instead of ripping each other’s flesh, they do something far worse, expertly tearing into ancient grudges, secrets, and shared delusions. If you want to be deeply, profoundly disturbed by a night at the theatre, there’s no finer way to do it than this.’

The Financial Times’ Sarah Hemming found the two stars ‘so scintillatingly good are they that you check yourself for bruises as you stagger out (…) It’s a joy to watch Anderson and Crudup go at Albee’s text, mining every glittering dark gem out of the intricately layered dialogue and bringing exquisite timing to their verbal duels (…) Together they track the couple’s long night’s journey through to dawn, switch-backing from flirtation through dangerous hostility to a quietly moving catharsis. But it’s their skilled delivery of the emotional subtext that really counts. When Anderson’s Martha lets her guard down, you suddenly glimpse the despair that threatens to overwhelm her.’ She tells us: ‘Albee’s withering critique of the American dream, of postwar materialism and of a dog-eat-dog system comes across loud and clear.’

Neil Dowden for Plays International described how ‘Elliott … gives us a compelling theatrical experience throughout the three hours’ stage time – there is no let-up in either the awkwardly funny barbs or the rising feeling of the characters being trapped in an alcohol-fuelled nightmare.’

4 stars ⭑⭑⭑⭑

Dave Fargnoli of The Stage said: ‘this lively revival from director Marianne Elliott is fast paced and unabashedly entertaining. Elliott gives the piece a heightened intensity, and at its best, the vicious repartee absolutely crackles.’ About the stars he noted: ‘Anderson’s Martha is brilliantly crude, wielding her power like a sledgehammer, whether relentlessly haranguing or crudely flirting. She spits and snarls in a broad New England accent, and crawls around the stage in drunken despair. At her most vulnerable, she becomes a point of stillness, voice dropping away to a husky, pleading whisper, tears glinting in her eyes. As her equal and opposite George, Crudup initially appears entirely ineffectual, squirmingly uncomfortable in his own skin. Slowly, he reveals a sly, incisive power, his surgically precise verbal eviscerations breaking down everyone around him.’

The Standard‘s Nick Curtis declared: ‘Gillian Anderson and Billy Crudup give towering performances in Edward Albee’s intense 1962 drama, about a middle-aged couple engaged in vicious, liquored-up psychological games to hide the core sadness of their marriage. Marianne Elliot’s production turns a mid-century modern living room (by the ever-excellent Miriam Buether) into a slowly revolving gladiatorial arena, perfect for this in-the-round venue. At three hours and 20 minutes it doesn’t stint on the methodical savagery. The shifting dynamics and brutally funny repartee of the central couple are immaculately mapped. Anderson is as good as you’d hope and expect as the bleary, destructive Martha, but Crudup is a revelation as George, wounded but quick-witted and nimble, like a greying mongoose battling a striking snake.’ However: ‘the central revelation – when it comes – seems too weak to support the torrid psychodrama.’

Alexander Cohen of BroadwayWorld concluded: ‘Who’s Afraid of Virgina Woolf?’s gleeful assassination of American family dynamics would have shocked its audiences more in 1962 than today. The barbarism remains perversely entertaining, but what lies beneath for an audience to get its teeth into? Perhaps the anxiety of relationships, which in the age of social media loneliness and situationships weighs heavier. But maybe best not to overthink it. Come for Anderson and Crudup going toe to toe. Stay for the ensuing blood, sweat, and tears.’

3 stars ⭑⭑⭑

For The Guardian‘s Arifa Akbar: ‘The play, while exquisitely written and structured, feels tortuously long at over three hours, and though this is the point – to watch how two people destroy each other yet love each other – it still feels like a punishment. Staged in the round, it leaves little room for hiding. There is a revolve, slow for the most part, which shows their marriage up close, from every angle. For all the comedy and nervous laughs, this couple does combust and the end is devastating. Martha stops her high-pitched attack and becomes vulnerable. George lets go of his emotional cruelty. They have finally stopped the power games and play-acting of their marriage. Or have they?’

Dominic Maxwell of The Times got a bit bored: ‘for the first 90 minutes at least we are excitingly close to the back-and-forth between Crudup’s faded history lecturer and Anderson as his frustrated, high-born wife. Yes, they’re a good-looking pair of disputatious duds (…) if there’s anything lacking in the delectable set-up it’s that George and Martha’s sozzled sniping all essentially play as “banter” (…) There’s so much to admire here, but too little range. This Woolf needs sharper fangs to avoid feeling a good half hour too long.’

Critics’ average rating 4.4⭑

Who’s Afraid Of Virginia Woolf can be seen at @sohoplace until 19 December 2026. Buy tickets from the theatre sohoplace.org

If you’ve seen this production of Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf please leave your review and rating below

Theatre reviews roundup: Hay Fever with Christine Baranski & Richard E Grant

Christine Baranski & Richard E Grant get mixed reception

Wyndham’s Theatre
Richard E Grant & Christine Baranski in Hay Fever. Photo: Marc Brenner

First produced in 1924, Noël Coward‘s Hay Fever  has delighted audiences for a hundred years with its description of a ghastly fading film star Judith Bliss, her bad-tempered husband and their obnoxious son and daughter, who invite unexpected guests to a squirm-inducing get-together. The critics all felt the play and the production were old fashioned fun. Whether ‘a meringue of nothingness’ (WhatsOnStage) is worth the money was only considered by The Telegraph’s Dominic Cavendish: ‘Burns’s production won’t enter the annals. Nor does it justify a top price of £250.’ The star attractions got a mixed reception. Hollywood actor Christine Baranski was generally found to be amusing if not hilarious (‘She commands the stage’ FT;  A few commented unfavourably on her acquired English accent (‘mumbles’ Independent). For many, Richard E Grant seemed the bigger attraction. His insouciant poshness was both a blessing and a curse for the critics: ‘perfect’ CityAM; ‘only okay … no fireworks‘ Time Out. The supporting cast, which included Lucy Karczewski, Nancy Carroll and Charles Edwards, received the highest praise. Emily Burns‘ direction of the farce elements and Frankie Bradshaw’s grand set design were appreciated.

4 stars ⭑⭑⭑⭑

What’sOnStage’s Sarah Crompton began by reminding us: ‘Noël Coward’s Hay Fever is a meringue of nothingness. Or rather, as his biographer Oliver Soden points out, it is “not so much artificial, as a commentary on artifice.”’ She pointed out at the end of her review: ‘Meringues aren’t exactly filling, but they are fun to eat.’ Baranski, she said, ‘retains instinctive comic timing and an ability to convey, with a raised eyebrow or a disappointed frown, her sense of life passing her by.’

CityAM’s Adam Bloodworth was a fan: ‘Burns’ conventional but sparkling production proves Coward is still an absolute king of farce.’ He liked the two stars: ‘Richard E Grant is obviously perfect for the feverishly privileged, short tempered David, who, like so many poshos, is magnetic to watch self-destruct (…) Baranski grips equally, flipping in milliseconds between sensual and ballistic’.

3 stars ⭑⭑⭑

The Telegraph’s Dominic Cavendish reported : ‘Grant is in his element as the scatty patriarch, combining Tiggerish zest with flashes of truculence. He’s not on stage much, though; Judith is the play’s real motor, yet Baranski’s performance stutters (…) he character should be entertainingly ghastly, yet where we need to see lavish layers of ingrained theatricality – with professed sincerity blurring, alarmingly, into affectation – we get one too many beady stares, and moments of televisual restraint.’ He was pointed in his conclusion: ‘It’s all enjoyable enough, and there are laughs to be had, but Burns’s production won’t enter the annals. Nor does it justify a top price of £250.’

Dominic Maxwell of The Times liked the supporting cast: ‘Coward’s prodigious dialogue calls for robust precision. Carroll leads a cavalry of light-comic supporting turns who know what’s needed. Charles Edwards is sublimely stiff in his tailored suits as the diplomat Richard. Lucy Karczewski is a quiet joy as a 1920s shy girl you could mistake for a socially anxious Gen Zer.’ He decided: ‘Emily Burns’s production gets more reliably spritzy as it goes along. The second act in particular has some relishable set pieces. Frankie Bradshaw’s grand set design mirrors the blues, beiges and gold trim of this theatre. It’s all still pretty pointless — but always handsomely, often amusingly pointless.‘

Tim Bano for The Financial Times thought: ‘Mostly … it chugs along in a pleasant and satisfying way, better than your local amateur effort but no great revelatory production to tug Coward into the 21st century. Grant is entertaining enough to watch, with nutty professor hair quivering on his head, and a childish giddiness at the games his family plays.’ He acknowledged: ‘Mostly, though, it’s Baranski’s show. She commands the stage like Judith does her household. From low imperious hoots, her voice flies up several octaves every few words. It’s cleverly done, this performance by a good actor playing a bad actor who thinks she’s good.’ He concluded: ‘This production is happy enough to be a diverting night at the theatre, but seems afraid of peering behind the performance. Despite a good cast and elegant set, it remains as shallow as its characters.’

‘It’s glossy comfort theatre.’ declared Time Out’s Andrzej Lukowski. He thought the cast almost saved it: ‘Christine Baranski brings a pleasingly doleful turn to reluctantly retired actress matriarch Judith Bliss’. However: ‘the play …  just doesn’t have enough fizz left in it after a century to feel entirely justified without some sort of superstar performance to lead it. And the problem lies with big star Grant … (his) performance is only okay: he offers workmanlike support but no fireworks.’

Regarding Baranski, Emma John for The Guardian thought ‘a technically sound RP oddly constrains her. Judith’s combination of pretend languor and genuine vagueness mean that jokes go begging and some lines land too earnestly’. She pointed out: ‘Director Emily Burns’s CV majors in farce and she stages some lovely bits of business, including a scene when a servant silently lays a breakfast table to a swellingly romantic soundtrack and a Gone With the Wind-crimson backdrop.’

BroadwayWorld‘s Aliya Al-Hassan agreed about Christine Baranski’s accent:  ‘(her) muddled accent of an odd mixture of RP and Atlantic twang impacts some of her delivery. But when she gets into her stride she leans into the acute and comedic melodrama of the role with gusto, sweeping from low imperious tones to much higher octaves. Richard E. Grant’s David has little to do in the first half, but emerges like a beacon in the second as the utterly self-absorbed writer. He is perfectly suited to the role of very well-spoken toff, which he does with ease, exploding into the vehement arguments with beautifully fluid delivery.’ She concluded: ‘Burns is not attempting to rewrite history here and there is nothing radical or new to be seen. The Bliss family are so bored with their lives and themselves that they have to create drama to pass the time, but we never get to peep below the surface of these motivations. A comfortable and comforting night at the theatre – just don’t expect fireworks.’

When it came to the leads, The Independent’s Alice Saville was damning: ‘Christine Baranski mumbles her way through the central role of flamboyant actress Judith Bliss, while Richard E Grant fades unexpectedly into the scenery as her grumpy husband David. Instead, the biggest joy of the evening are this couple’s bewildered house guests, whose politeness imprisons them in an oh-so-genteel form of hell.’

Critics’ average rating 3.2⭑

Value rating 32 (Average rating combined with typical ticket price)

Hay Fever can be seen at Wyndhams Theatre until 12 December 2026. Buy directly from the theatre

If you’ve seen this production of Hay Fever, please leave your review and rating below

Theatre reviews roundup: The Standard of Living

‘Entertainment value’ or ‘a colossal yawn’

Theatre Royal Haymarket
Rory Kinnear in The Standard of Living. Photo: Manuel Harlan

There was a striking divide between critics who loved James Graham‘s new play about John Maynard Keynes, and those who merely admired it. The majority found Mr Graham’s attempt to corral Keynes’ role in the country’s economy, his complex love life and his passion for the arts into one coherent whole didn’t quite come off. All applauded James Graham’s writing but there was a contrast between those who embraced his wide-ranging subject matter and those who thought it ranged too wide (‘there is too much ground to cover in the space of the play’ BroadwayWorld; ‘a colossal yawn’ The Stage) but some were more than happy (‘combines entertainment value … with a stimulating survey of the Cambridge economist’s life, times and interventionist ideas’ Telegraph; ‘The entire production is a plea for the value … of lives that are full of something more than the day-to-day grind’ WhatsOnStage ). Rory Kinnear as the multi-faceted Keynes was a hit for most critics (‘excels’ The Times). Bob Crowley‘s set was praised (‘ravishing’ Guardian) but there were mixed reactions to Nicholas Hytner‘s direction which included dance (‘slick, stylish’ LondonTheatre; ‘stolid and sterile’ The Stage). Other actors, particularly Royal Ballet principal Natalia Osipova making her stage acting debut (‘wit and charm’ FT), were praised.

[Links to full reviews are included but a number are behind paywalls and therefore may not be accessible]

4 stars ⭑⭑⭑⭑

The Telegraph’s Dominic Cavendish was enthusiastic, saying it: ‘combines entertainment value (for starters, gags about how you pronounce his name) with a stimulating survey of the Cambridge economist’s life, times and interventionist ideas. With slick direction from Nicholas Hytner, a winningly clipped but charismatic star turn from Rory Kinnear as the suited and sainted “father of macroeconomics”, and an entrancing “straight” debut from Royal Ballet principal Natalia Osipova as Keynes’s Russian ballerina wife, Lydia Lopokova, it’s incredibly timely, inviting us to ponder Keynes’s legacy as we face a fiscal black hole.’

WhatsOnStage’s Sarah Crompton was enraptured: ‘Graham clearly loves and admires Keynes, and Kinnear creates an unforgettable portrait of a man who bestrode his times with a gentle modesty that belied his cleverness. But the play’s lesson for today isn’t only economic. The entire production is a plea for the value of beauty, of art, of dance, of lives that are full of something more than the day-to-day grind. That was Keynes’ greatest lesson: it is important to know how to live as well as how to spend. This is art about the importance of art and is both uplifting and hopeful.’

Marianka Swain reviewing for LondonTheatre enjoyed her evening: ‘Keynes’s ideas are best expressed dramatically when he has an opponent, the Austrian economic Friedrich Hayek. They don’t quite enter into Hamilton-esque rap battles, but one of their duels is dynamically staged as a tango (choreographed by James Cousins). Nicholas Hytner’s slick, stylish production also makes clever use of sliding panels which swoop in with archival photographs and striking period artwork (set by Bob Crowley and projections by Luke Halls). Rory Kinnear brings typically deft nuance to Keynes’.

The Standard’s Nick Curtis called it a ‘joyfully Stoppardian if overstuffed new play about economics, art, sexuality and how to live a good life.’ He revealed: ‘I loved the sweep and brio of it, the epigrammatic wit and the zing of ideas, the compassion and love of human life that underpins a play that’s about worth not value. Nicholas Hytner’s sparely staged production features a stealthily compelling central performance from Kinnear as Keynes, magnetic though socially awkward and stiffly academic. Former Royal Ballet principal Natalia Osipova reveals ravishing comic timing – as well as faultless turns and leaps in dance interludes’.

3 stars ⭑⭑⭑

Dominic Maxwell of The Times was definite: ‘It’s no classic. Graham hasn’t found the form to turn so much content into a drama with a compelling hook. The great Hytner often just seems to be doing his best to keep a large cast organised (and sometimes dancing) as we skip forward from 1914 to Keynes’s death in 1946 and, briefly, beyond.’ He had mixed feelings about the star: ‘The contained Kinnear struggles to convince as Keynes the offbeat loverman (…) Kinnear excels, however, as Keynes the man arguing against the laissez-faire economics that dominated, Keynes the godfather of the welfare state.’

The Guardian’s Arifa Akbar was complimentary: ‘There is typically for Graham, dextrous storytelling and accessibility of ideas. Bob Crowley’s set design is little short of ravishing with its moving screens of art and archival footage.’ However, ‘The drama has a slightly static quality despite the twirling red-and-white feathered dancers of the Ballets Russes and its slick movements through time. It seems essentially like a biographical trot through Keynes’s life, made with fondness and admiration for the man – but perhaps not enough of what lies beneath the surface.’

The Financial Times‘ Sarah Hemming found: ‘some of the play feels overly diffuse. Graham and Hytner bring great sweep and drive to establishing the extraordinary facts about Keynes’ life: we watch him shuttle between grey Whitehall and the bohemian Bloomsbury Group. We witness him argue passionately against the punitive terms of the Treaty of Versailles and push for economic intervention during the Depression. We see him with male lovers, then falling unexpectedly for Lopokova (played with wit and charm by Osipova). Throughout, Kinnear beautifully conveys the contrast between his character’s buttoned-up exterior and his buzzing, creative mind.’ She delved deeper: ‘The whole thing moves like a dance, with ideas, people and politics swirling in and out of the spotlight. Bob Crowley’s sleek design of sliding geometric panels suggests a world in flux. But, despite droll work from Pip Carter as Lytton Strachey, Thomas Flynn as Grant and Naomi Frederick as Virginia Woolf, the episodic structure becomes unwieldy and prevents deeper engagement with any of them.’

Time Out’s Andrzej Lukowski also thought Mr Graham had bitten off more than he could chew, but ‘even when he’s not at his absolute best dramatically you’ll still come out of one of his historical dramas having learned a lot.’ He conceded: ‘It is still pretty damn good: nobody brings the past to life with the verve of Graham. It is, to be fair, almost certainly the most enjoyable play about an economist ever written. Kinnear is a delight as Keynes, who combines starchy Victorian gent, idealistic Boy Scout and sexually liberated bohemian in equal measures’.

Aliya Al-Hassan of BroadwayWorld agreed: ‘despite Graham’s adept writing, there is too much ground to cover in the space of the play; Keynes and the Bloombury Group; Keynes as the economist and his rivalry with Austrian economist Fredrich Hayek; Keynes as an art and culture lover. All fascinating individually, but impossible to really delve into sufficiently in the time given.’ Like other reviewers, she complimented various actors: ‘ Natalia Osipova makes a solid and convincing acting debut as his wife, Russian ballerina Lydia Lopokova, often using movement to convey more than her words.’ And ‘Laurie Kynaston is excellent as rival Hayek, showing huge admiration for Keynes, but also unafraid to contradict him totally. The dialogue between Kynaston and Kinnear is sparkling.’

2 stars ⭑⭑

The Independent’s Alice Saville was emphatic: ‘James Graham’s play about a pioneering economist is about as dull as a pessimistic audience member might fear (…) In an attempt to make this man sexy rather than stodgy, Graham and director Nick Hytner have layered on all sorts of added excitements. Royal Ballet principal Natalia Osipova pirouettes between scenes, resplendent in red feathers, and there is no end of bisexual shenanigans. But it’s not enough to drag this tale out of lecture theatre territory.’

The Stage’s Sam Marlowe also thought The Standard of Living was sub-standard: ‘Graham fails to pull off his usual adroit blend of sparkling perspicacity and lively, engaging drama; and what’s more, Nicholas Hytner’s production is uncharacteristically stolid and sterile, making this a disappointing double whammy (…) It’s irredeemably dry and ultimately, I’m genuinely sorry to say, a colossal yawn.‘

Critics’ average rating 3.2⭑

Value rating 33 (Value Rating is a combination of the critics’ rating and the typical ticket price)

The Standard of Living can be seen at Theatre Royal Haymarket until 12 December 2026. Buy tickets directly from standardoflivingplay.com

If you’ve seen The Standard of Living at Theatre Royal Haymarket, please leave your review and rating below

Theatre reviews roundup: Thelma & Louise

Road movie musical lacks horsepower

Young Vic
Thelma & Louise. Photo: Helen Murray

Many of the critics thought this musical didn’t live up to Ridley Scott’s classic movie, (‘the show just can’t match the film’s thrust, depth or stunning ending’ FT) despite being the work of the same writer Callie Khouri. Neko Case’s songs received a mixed response (‘more about mood than narrative’ Standard; ‘every song has its place in moving along plot and characterisation’ BroadwayWorld). The two leads Amy Lennox and Rachel Tucker were praised (‘sing their hearts out’ WhatsOnStage).

4 stars ⭑⭑⭑⭑

Louise Penn at BroadwayWorld disagreed with her fellow critics. She was adamant: ‘There’s no car, but the lighting by Natasha Chivers and sound by Gareth Owen make convincing stylistic choices to compensate.’ She concluded: ‘There’s always something to catch the eye in Thelma & Louise. As for the songs, occasionally a lyric doesn’t quite catch, but every song has its place in moving along plot and characterisation. Thelma & Louise works as a musical and, more importantly, matters as a comment on why these two made the choices they did.’

Holly O’Mahony at The Stage said: ‘the songs (music and lyrics are by Neko Case) have an infectious zest that doesn’t tamper with the story’s gutsy, rebellious spirit. Under Trip Cullman’s direction, Thelma and Louise are every bit the gun-toting, patriarchy-busting duo whose roguish ploys we whooped for on screen back in 1991 – and 30 years on, they’ve still got plenty to say to the men standing in their way.’ She concluded: ‘It’s a fist-pumping joyride – and, just as with the film, we’re rooting for them the entire way.’

Jess Phillips for the Daily Express had one problem with the show: ‘The problem is that the main set is made to look like a bar – which makes sense, since many of the scenes take place in various dive bars – but also has to double as a motel, a police interrogation room, and a diner (…) making it a bit of a confusing jumble.’ Otherwise: ‘Thelma and Louise is going to be a success, once it works out its kinks. Its central cast are incredible and their voices all hold weight – but they’re also a delight to watch come alive on stage.’

3 stars ⭑⭑⭑

WhatsOnStage’s Sarah Crompton said: ‘it all feels meagre, slow-paced, stripped of excitement and crucially of that sense of liberation which powers the narrative even as it dips towards its inevitable close. Lennox and Tucker sing their hearts out, but it’s not enough.’

The Financial Times’ Sarah Hemming reported: ‘try as it might, the show just can’t match the film’s thrust, depth or stunning ending. All in all, this musical version sadly hasn’t found its own road.’

Julia Rank at LondonTheatre was disappointed by the design: ‘The set opens up towards the beginning to reveal an overturned car, but that’s never seen again, and the staging is oddly bound to a single location (a dive bar designed by Christine Jones and Brett J. Banakis), with the car represented at brief intervals by whooshing lighting.’ She praised the stars: ‘Lennox and Tucker both have outstanding stage presence and do a sterling job’.

Time Out’s Andrjez Lukowski liked the music: ‘I’m a Neko Case fan and enjoyed how different to the average showtune her poetic country rock contributions are, with a thumping  live-band sound that foregrounds booming drums and forceful guitars’ but ‘good as the songs are, they’re mid-paced and contemplative, further slowing the action down.’

The Standard’s Nick Curtis pulled it apart. He explained the basic problem: ‘theatre can’t do literal scale or scope like film and one misses the wide-open vistas of Arkansas, New Mexico and Arizona. Ditto the sense of propulsive forward motion as Louise’s ’66 Thunderbird throatily devours the blacktop (represented here by a pair of weedy parallel lights zooming across the back wall).’ About the music, he said: ‘the country-rock score by Canadian powerhouse Neko Case, though distinctive and often beautiful, is more about mood than narrative, and her rich images often descend into word salad’.

The Times’ Clive Davis was another who thought the musical failed to live up to the film: ‘where Scott expertly tweaked the tension on the big screen, here the final confrontation with the forces of law and order fizzes gently. This musical lacks horsepower.’

2 stars ⭑⭑

The Guardian’s Arifa Akbar was even more disappointed than her colleagues that the musical didn’t live up to the movie: ‘Fans of the film can forget those glorious scenes of the women’s turquoise convertible Thunderbird, and of the magnificently lonely desert, both of which felt like characters in their own right. Instead, the backdrop is a prosaic saloon bar’. She continued: ‘The narrative plays out as two women on the run. You wish for more depth, more bonding between them, which does come in the second half when the show finally fires up, but it still feels like empowerment-lite.’

Franco Milazzo for Plays International asked: ‘“How did such a talented cast get suckered into signing up?” Amy Lennox, Rachel Tucker, and Jordan Luke Gage (a sheer waste of talent for the thinly written thief JD) do well with what they are given but there are notable shortfalls where the drama, emotion, connection, character definition, and thrilling set pieces in the original film are concerned. It’s not helped that Neko Case’s songbook is, by and large, underdeveloped and eminently forgettable. As with most other screen-to-stage adaptations, projection is doing the work of imagination, lending a cinematic sweep to writing that has done nothing whatsoever to earn one.’

Critics’ average rating 3.1⭑

You can see Thelma & Louise at the Young Vic theatre until 24 October. Tickets available from the theatre

If you’ve seen Thelma & Louise at The Young Vic, please leave your review and rating below

Theatre reviews roundup: Golden Boy with Josh O’Connor

Josh O’Connor is a knockout

Almeida Theatre
Josh O’Connor and Zubin Varla in Golden Boy. Photo: Marc Brenner

Josh O’Connor returns to the stage to play a young violinist who decides he can earn more money by becoming a boxer. The critics praised his acting and that of all the cast which includes Daniel Mays and Zubin Varla. There were mixed opinions of  Clifford Odet‘s 1937 play: some loved the ‘bluntly brilliant satire of capitalism’ (Independent) but others thought didn’t quite land the punch intended (‘the moral sophistication of an RKO Studios B-movie’ Times. They liked Sam Yates‘ direction (‘lends the piece energy’ The Stage).

4 stars ⭑⭑⭑⭑

Time Out‘s Andrzej Lukowski liked it a lot: ‘Though elements of Sam Yates’ stylish take will doubtless prove to be divisive, I thought it was great, a crack cast meeting a bold vision that seeks to do more than just squeeze Golden Boy into standard naturalist tragedy shapes.’ He described the production: ‘Yates meets Odets’ lack of subtlety with operatic intensity (…) he does add a whole string quartet who hang out behind a wooden screen in Rosanna Vize’s stark ‘30s house interior set. Obviously they ram the point home. But it’s not like there was much subtlety there to begin with and very crucially they sound amazing, not simply for their more elegiac, melodious contributions but also the thrilling dissonance they unleash later on as Joe’s divided mind begins to crumble. The boxing scenes are a maelstrom of strings, movement and a black and white camera feed  beaming images from a punchbag O’Connor is sparring with: it’s weird and chaotic and a bit Jamie Lloyd – I was a fan.’

The Independent‘s Alice Saville called the play ‘a bluntly brilliant satire of capitalism and the way it destroys people who mess with it’. She appreciated this version: ‘Yates’s superlative production throws everything it can at this savage play, making its text ripple through an operatic sonic universe.’ As for the star: ‘A shirtless, blood-smeared Josh O’Connor is a standout … taking on the title role of an ambitious young boxing star whose arrogance masks his vulnerability in the jaws of a machine he’ll never master.’

Dave Fargnoli of The Stage reported: ‘A canny staging from director Sam Yates lends the piece energy, slipping in surprises and striking images. Moments of symbolic movement – both graceful and tortuous – develop between scenes. Joe beats out rhythms on a punching bag that has a camera embedded inside, live streaming dizzying black-and-white shots, like scenes from Raging Bull.’

for the Telegraph called it ‘a gripping revival that proves there’s plenty of life in Clifford Odets’s half-forgotten American tragedy.’ ‘O’Connor carries himself with a loser’s stoop, leaning forward as if constantly yanked on by his ambition, or just bracing himself against the battering winds of the world.’ He concluded: ‘the strength of this production isn’t its handling of moral issues, but the thrill of blow-by-blow sensation.’

Neil Dowden for Plays International said about the star: ‘Sufficiently muscular to convince and increasingly bloodied as Joe’s bouts take their toll, O’Connor strongly conveys a sensitive awareness as well as the ambitious hardening of his behaviour, as his internal sparring plays out before us.’ He drew attention to: ‘Dan Balfour’s splendid sound design evokes the raucous boxing crowd as well as the fast, noisy traffic of NYC.’

Olivia Rook for LondonTheatre brought attention to the whole cast: ‘O’Connor is joined by a stand-out supporting cast. Mays’s desperate and slippery Tom, full of empty promises, is happy to use people to get ahead — even his lover, the realistic Lorna Moon … who has learned to protect herself after a lifetime of disappointments. Zubin Varla is unsettling as the macabre puppet master Eddie Fuseli, who wants a stake in Joe and helps to shred his humanity. Meanwhile, Stanley Townsend’s kind Mr Bonaparte, Joe’s loving father, is the warm heart of this play.’

3 stars ⭑⭑⭑

Chris Wiegand reported for The Guardian: ‘It is a play of opposing forces: cynicism and optimism, instinct and intellect, defence and offence. Staging Golden Boy is principally a question of strings and ropes: how to capture Joe’s gift for the violin and his force in the ring. Sam Yates’s revival adds a prologue of stillness, with O’Connor watching a young boy play the instrument. As the music swells, he draws back the shutters on Rosanna Vize’s half-office, half-home set to reveal musical director Roman Lytwyniw’s elevated string quartet before picking up the violin delicately himself.’ The play didn’t knock him out: ‘Odets was a seasoned Hollywood screenwriter and the play has a hard-boiled poetry and deadpan humour, with the kind of polished lines that fly in a film noir or screwball comedy but are difficult to land on stage.’

The Times’ Clive Davis described it as ‘a production that has lots of muscle, but throws too many loose punches.’ He was almost persuaded: ‘O’Connor is so compelling, in fact, that you’re almost willing to overlook the flaws in a play that, at heart, has the moral sophistication of an RKO Studios B-movie.’

2 stars ⭑⭑

Gary Naylor for BroadwayWorld found: ‘the closing 30 minutes or so descends into melodrama, punctuated by so much shouting that I can’t have been alone in letting it just wash over me. Why director, Sam Yates, went for that approach, I do not know, but nothing gathers diminishing returns like an ear-battering in the theatre.’ He decided: ‘despite all that talent on stage and a superstar draw on the playbill, the production fails to establish a place in our hearts, the care we need to feel for those lost in capitalism’s seductive grip just not breaching the fourth wall.’

Critics’ average rating 3.5⭑

Golden Boy can be seen at The Almeida Theatre until 31 October 2026. Buy tickets from the theatre almeida.co.uk

If you’ve seen this production of Golden Boy, please leave a review and rating below

Theatre reviews roundup: Man To Man with Tilda Swinton

Tilda Swinton returns to the stage in triumph

Royal Court Theatre
Tilda Swinton in Man To Man. Photo: Tristram Kenton

In 1987 director Stephen Unwin, designer Bunny Christie and actor Tilda Swinton caused a sensation with Man To Man, the fragmented story of a German woman who transforms herself into her dead husband in order to survive in Nazi Germany and beyond. The trio are back with the same play, slightly updated, to celebrate the Royal Court Theatre’s 70th anniversary. The critics were all impressed by Tilda Swinton (‘verbal flexibility and perfect pacing’ Guardian) but some but some didn’t think Manfred Karge‘s play had aged well (‘a little bit boring’ Standard).

4 stars ⭑⭑⭑⭑

The Stage’s Sam Marlowe was gripped: ‘the combination of Swinton’s white-hot talent and the vividness of Karge’s imagery grips you in its teeth like a rabid dog, and shakes and shakes you. I can’t stop thinking about it.’

Time Out‘s Andrzej Lukowksi reassured us: ‘this isn’t one of (Swinton’s) arch performance projects, it’s a proper play, in which she loses herself in a proper character.’ He extoled her qualities: ‘it’s genuinely astonishing how ageless she looks – you’d never put her at 65. But it feels like that’s not simply because she doesn’t look it, but because she really really is a great and incredibly vigorous actor who can choose to channel the energy and voice and posture of a younger woman. Slash man. Slash woman pretending to be a woman pretending to be a man.’

Mark Lawson of The Guardian described the star: ‘With a gruff laddishness as her base tone, Swinton – on a Bunny Christie set dotted with period East German technology including fridge and tape machine – regularly transforms verbally and physically into other women and men.’ He continued: ‘Anthony Vivis’s 1980s English version, revised by director Stephen Unwin, conveys Karge’s knack for vivid imagery. A smoker’s yellow-stained finger is able to write an endearment in after-sex sweat on Ella’s body; Hitler youth piss swastikas in the snow. The show at times resembles performance art (…) but the performer’s verbal flexibility and perfect pacing make Man To Man compelling theatre.’

WhatsOnStage‘s Sarah Crompton commented: ‘Stephen Unwin’s direction of the 28 short scenes is clear and driving, and the text (translated by Anthony Vivis) a compelling mixture of the raw and the poetic. When Ella/Max thinks of her past life as a woman she sees herself in terms of Snow White, pale as snow. Swinton’s wistful delivery of those lines is just one of the inflections of a performance that captures the contradictions of a divided life, at once pitiful and revolting, admirable and disgusting.  Her sense of alienation from herself and from the times in which she is living is like a warning cry.  A play written in the 1980s speaks loudly today’.

Franco Milazzo for BroadwayWorld riffed extensively about the original German title Jacke wie Hose: ‘The German idiom means, roughly, that a jacket and a pair of trousers amount to the same thing, so why fuss over which one you’re wearing? It perfectly encapsulates what the whole play is about, namely that personal identity can be a matter of tailoring, not conviction. Yet, now we are stuck with Man To Man which sounds more like a problem page in a gay lifestyle magazine.’ He did go on to talk about the production: ‘It’s an alluring performance that moulds itself around a challenging script. The twenty-eight short scenes have more stylistic variety than a Eurovision host’s wardrobe. Prose jostles for space alongside blank verse, rhyming couplets, pub songs, proverbs and whatever else was running through Karge’s mind at the time he wrote this. While the arthouse crowd will no doubt find this restless mashup of dramatic styles deeply arousing, there are times when the text barely resists the temptation to slide into pretentious twaddle. Unwin’s direction has real verve even when it sags a little towards the middle; frankly, though, it could sag all the way to Sydney and still be barely noticeable when Swinton is in this kind of dominant mood.’

Kirsten Grant for the Telegraph reported: ‘Despite its rather short 85-minute runtime, the text itself is overloaded, interspersed with doggerel, rhyming couplets, and songs. But Swinton’s command of the stage together with Unwin’s clever direction keep the pacing from lagging.’

3 stars ⭑⭑⭑

Holly O’Mahony for LondonTheatre gave an insight into the actor’s performance: ‘it’s easy to forget you’re watching Swinton as she burps and swaggers around the stage as Ella-turned-Max. A working-class German, Swinton bestows her with a thick cockney accent, sardonic sense of humour, and a matter-of-fact attitude towards a hard-up life (…)  Under Christie’s self-consciously cool design, though, she looks more like an 80s rock star. Her short hair stands as if petrified above her head, while a cakey smear runs down her cheek. Beneath a fishnet vest occasionally coupled with a suit jacket, she does not wear her husband’s trousers, as the play’s blurb describes, but a pair of red Y-fronts, exposing her bare legs, bloodied knees and chunky black boots.’

The Times’ Clive Davis had reservations: ‘Karge’s overextended portrait of a woman who could be a modern Mother Courage becomes a test of endurance. Random reflections tumble over each other as Ella rummages through memories in a voice which often slips into a surly monotone. And the political backdrop to her life is often sketched in unsubtle terms.’

The Independent’s Alice Saville also had doubts about the play: ‘In 1988, I’d imagine that seeing an actor existing between genders on stage felt simpler – an artistic choice, reflecting on the dehumanising nature of war and industrialisation. In today’s simultaneously more politicised and more nuanced landscape, there’s something a bit thin about the way this character’s identity is drawn. Her feminine side is painted using excerpts from Snow White, poetic snippets of lost girlishness that feel irrelevant to her harshly masculine present. It feels like we’re building towards some sort of fantastical transformation that never comes.’

The Standard‘s Nick Curtis found it: ‘surprisingly, a little bit boring (…) It remains disjointed and elusive despite the finessing of its original director Stephen Unwin, and Swinton’s larky, captivating performance (…) The play’s 28 scenes feel simultaneously overstuffed with imagery and frustratingly sketchy. You search in vain for solid meaning.’

Critics’ average rating 3.6 ⭑

Man To Man can be seen at The Royal Court Theatre until 24 October 2026 (sold out but try £15 Mondays- tickets available at 9am online for that day’s performance https://royalcourttheatre.com) It will then tour to Edinburgh, Berlin and New York.

If you’ve seen the current production of Man To Man, please leave your review and rating below

×