Critics on cloud nine
Lyttelton Theatre, National Theatre

First performed in 1979, Caryl Churchill‘s Cloud 9 has been revived by the National Theatre. Many were fearing its satire on the Victorian British imperialism and, in the second act, the would-be liberated 1970s would seem dated. However, the critics decided (with one dissenter) that it was ‘still incendiary, still challenging, still surprising’ (WhatsOnStage). Dominic Cooke’s direction helped by playing it straight (‘Cooke wisely avoids updating, instead leaning into the play’s self-conscious theatricality and treating both parts as period pieces’ FT). The actors were praised and everyone had a good word to say about Miriam Buether’s set that is broken up during the interval, much as the Empire was. Only The Times found it ‘a long evening’.
(Most of these extracts carry links to the full reviews but you may find that, in some case, you are blocked by a paywall.)
5 stars ⭑⭑⭑⭑⭑
WhatsOnStage‘s Sarah Crompton informed us: ‘(It was) first performed in 1979, yet it lands on stage like a radical blaze of hope. It’s still incendiary, still challenging, still surprising.’ She explained: ‘It binds together two very distinct strands. The first half is a farcical examination of British Colonialism and its effect on the social and sexual identities of the individuals who ran the Empire. The second bends time; it takes place in London in 1979, but it brings those characters together 25 years later, when they are trying to define and explore new ways of living with themselves and with others.’ She concluded: ‘It’s a great play, superbly staged, dazzlingly rich. The politics of gender may have changed in the intervening years, but Churchill’s always rigorous willingness to grapple with the hardest questions makes its ultimate tolerance and acceptance of the right to be different piercingly relevant today.’
4 stars ⭑⭑⭑⭑
The Guardian‘s Arifa Akbar opened: ‘Caryl Churchill’s time-hopping 1979 drama is not revived as often as it might be, perhaps because it is so magnificently madcap. Bouncing from a first act satirising Victorian life in colonial Africa to a second act exploring sexual liberation in 1970s London, it could easily roll off-kilter in the wrong hands. There is also its complicated framework. Cloud 9 is a play in two distinct parts which follows some of the characters a century on, although they only age 25 years in that time and are played by different actors through ironic cross-casting. Thankfully this crisp, handsome and note-perfect revival lands in exactly the right hands with director Dominic Cooke, clear as crystal despite the complications, sizzling with satire but showing itself to be a deadly serious, and still highly topical, play about identity beneath its playful sending up of everything from empire and Britishness to the confinements of marriage.’
The Stage’s Sam Marlowe was ‘dazzled by her daring, her freewheeling imagination, her piercingly astute use of theatrical language and her galvanising irreverence for the conventions of form. This 1979 play – which joyously explodes gender politics, family structures and the hierarchies embedded in history and society, as well as its own logical chronology – is not only riotously funny, but startlingly subversive.’
The Telegraph’s Dominic Cavendish was on cloud 9: ‘Deploying a superb cast of seven, the director Dominic Cooke triumphantly affirms the work as a modern classic and asserts the genius of its now-88-year-old author. True, the satiric critique of Victorian-era imperialism rather sidelines the colonised, and the second-act venting of “liberal” society confusions feels of its period. Yet the way Cloud 9 broaches sexism, feminism and how we get socially constructed seems prescient and pertinent, especially given debates around gender today, and in form the work is pioneeringly theatrical, while avoiding earnestness.’
Time Out‘s Andrzej Lukowski told us: ‘the whole (first) half amounts to a ferocious takedown of the Victorians via the playwright’s suggestion that the zenith of British colonialism was fuelled by sexual frustration and gender confusion: seething Englishmen, not entirely clear what they’re supposed to be doing out in the world, taking out their resentment on women, Africans and ultimately themselves.’ He concluded: ‘Churchill is still going strong at 88, but she doesn’t write ‘em like this anymore: her modern plays are short, neutron-dense works of shimmering intellect. Cloud 9 is more human than all that, a little more tied to its era, but no less genius, I think – and this is an immaculate revival.’
The Financial Times‘ Sarah Hemming found ‘Dominic Cooke’s rare, beautifully poised revival of her groundbreaking Cloud 9, a reminder of just how prescient and formally daring a writer Churchill has always been.’ She described how ‘Churchill, flipping ideas around with the alacrity of pancake chef, explores gender and sexual politics, the legacy of colonialism and the way historical power structures shape personal lives. Serious as all this is, it comes packaged with Churchill’s incisive wit, playfulness and brilliant understanding of theatrical language. Key to Cloud 9 is the roleplay at the heart of theatre, which she uses to prise open the gap between individuals’ desires and the expectations to which they conform.’ She pointed out: ‘Cooke wisely avoids updating, instead leaning into the play’s self-conscious theatricality and treating both parts as period pieces. It’s an approach that continues the play’s restless challenge: what chimes, what chafes and why? How far have we travelled and how does the past still inhabit and shape the present?’
Dominic Maxwell of The Sunday Times ended his review: ‘what an enduringly odd triumph. All hail Caryl Churchill.’ He said: ‘ Churchill is out to join the dots between colonial and sexual oppression and repression (…) It’s equal parts fun and games to pointedness and pain. How does she make it all so soulful? How does she create almost cartoonish characters then expose all their damaged innards too?’ He continued:: ‘ to some extent it is a parody, although a sympathetic one, of the shapes we bend ourselves into to find what we really like and who we really are.’
Josh Maughan for BroadwayWorld noted: ‘What is particularly interesting is how much of the first half remains present in the second. The question becomes less about whether we have progressed and more about what we have managed to carry forward, consciously or otherwise. Miriam Buether’s set design reinforces this exceptionally. The second half inhabits the collapsed remains of the first half’s set, a physical destruction of the world we have just witnessed. Yet the characters continue to live, love, have sex and argue within it. It is an effective visual metaphor for the persistence of history: the structures that once governed us may have fallen, but their remnants are part of the landscape.’
Anya Ryan for LondonTheatre said: ‘All of it is gloriously good fun, with ideas about societal progress, both then and now, bubbling beneath it all.’
3 stars ⭑⭑⭑
Olivia Jordan writing for CityAM decided: ‘many of its observations have lost their cutting edge’ and ‘much of the intersectional gender, sexual and racial dynamics are still relevant – but overall makes it feel more like a fascinating historical piece than a work of theatre offering a fresh perspective.
2 stars ⭑⭑
The Times’ Clive Davis disagreed: ‘once Churchill has laid out her stall on the evils of the patriarchy and Union Jack imperialism, it turns out to be a long evening.’ He observed: Churchill deals in archetypes rather than characters. The Victorian sequence descends into a grinding series of vignettes which have all the subtlety of a chin-stroking version of Carry On Up the Jungle. After an interval of 25 to 30 minutes, we return to the auditorium to find audience members who were sitting in the front two rows now lounging behind the actors. The set, once framed by a traditional proscenium arch, has fallen into ruins. Was it really worth making us wait so long? I don’t think so.‘
Critics’ average rating 3.6⭑
Value rating 44 (Combination of average rating and typical ticket price)
Cloud 9 can be seen at the Lyttleton at the National Thetare until 13 January 2027
If you’ve seen Cloud 9 at the National Theatre, please leave your review and rating below










