Theatre reviews roundup: Thelma & Louise

Road movie musical lacks horsepower

Young Vic
Thelma & Louise. Photo: Helen Murray

Many of the critics thought this musical didn’t live up to Ridley Scott’s classic movie, (‘the show just can’t match the film’s thrust, depth or stunning ending’ FT) despite being the work of the same writer Callie Khouri. Neko Case’s songs received a mixed response (‘more about mood than narrative’ Standard; ‘every song has its place in moving along plot and characterisation’ BroadwayWorld). The two leads Amy Lennox and Rachel Tucker were praised (‘sing their hearts out’ WhatsOnStage).

4 stars ⭑⭑⭑⭑

Louise Penn at BroadwayWorld disagreed with her fellow critics. She was adamant: ‘There’s no car, but the lighting by Natasha Chivers and sound by Gareth Owen make convincing stylistic choices to compensate.’ She concluded: ‘There’s always something to catch the eye in Thelma & Louise. As for the songs, occasionally a lyric doesn’t quite catch, but every song has its place in moving along plot and characterisation. Thelma & Louise works as a musical and, more importantly, matters as a comment on why these two made the choices they did.’

Holly O’Mahony at The Stage said: ‘the songs (music and lyrics are by Neko Case) have an infectious zest that doesn’t tamper with the story’s gutsy, rebellious spirit. Under Trip Cullman’s direction, Thelma and Louise are every bit the gun-toting, patriarchy-busting duo whose roguish ploys we whooped for on screen back in 1991 – and 30 years on, they’ve still got plenty to say to the men standing in their way.’ She concluded: ‘It’s a fist-pumping joyride – and, just as with the film, we’re rooting for them the entire way.’

Jess Phillips for the Daily Express had one problem with the show: ‘The problem is that the main set is made to look like a bar – which makes sense, since many of the scenes take place in various dive bars – but also has to double as a motel, a police interrogation room, and a diner (…) making it a bit of a confusing jumble.’ Otherwise: ‘Thelma and Louise is going to be a success, once it works out its kinks. Its central cast are incredible and their voices all hold weight – but they’re also a delight to watch come alive on stage.’

3 stars ⭑⭑⭑

WhatsOnStage’s Sarah Crompton said: ‘it all feels meagre, slow-paced, stripped of excitement and crucially of that sense of liberation which powers the narrative even as it dips towards its inevitable close. Lennox and Tucker sing their hearts out, but it’s not enough.’

The Financial Times’ Sarah Hemming reported: ‘try as it might, the show just can’t match the film’s thrust, depth or stunning ending. All in all, this musical version sadly hasn’t found its own road.’

Julia Rank at LondonTheatre was disappointed by the design: ‘The set opens up towards the beginning to reveal an overturned car, but that’s never seen again, and the staging is oddly bound to a single location (a dive bar designed by Christine Jones and Brett J. Banakis), with the car represented at brief intervals by whooshing lighting.’ She praised the stars: ‘Lennox and Tucker both have outstanding stage presence and do a sterling job’.

Time Out’s Andrjez Lukowski liked the music: ‘I’m a Neko Case fan and enjoyed how different to the average showtune her poetic country rock contributions are, with a thumping  live-band sound that foregrounds booming drums and forceful guitars’ but ‘good as the songs are, they’re mid-paced and contemplative, further slowing the action down.’

The Standard’s Nick Curtis pulled it apart. He explained the basic problem: ‘theatre can’t do literal scale or scope like film and one misses the wide-open vistas of Arkansas, New Mexico and Arizona. Ditto the sense of propulsive forward motion as Louise’s ’66 Thunderbird throatily devours the blacktop (represented here by a pair of weedy parallel lights zooming across the back wall).’ About the music, he said: ‘the country-rock score by Canadian powerhouse Neko Case, though distinctive and often beautiful, is more about mood than narrative, and her rich images often descend into word salad’.

The Times’ Clive Davis was another who thought the musical failed to live up to the film: ‘where Scott expertly tweaked the tension on the big screen, here the final confrontation with the forces of law and order fizzes gently. This musical lacks horsepower.’

2 stars ⭑⭑

The Guardian’s Arifa Akbar was even more disappointed than her colleagues that the musical didn’t live up to the movie: ‘Fans of the film can forget those glorious scenes of the women’s turquoise convertible Thunderbird, and of the magnificently lonely desert, both of which felt like characters in their own right. Instead, the backdrop is a prosaic saloon bar’. She continued: ‘The narrative plays out as two women on the run. You wish for more depth, more bonding between them, which does come in the second half when the show finally fires up, but it still feels like empowerment-lite.’

Franco Milazzo for Plays International asked: ‘“How did such a talented cast get suckered into signing up?” Amy Lennox, Rachel Tucker, and Jordan Luke Gage (a sheer waste of talent for the thinly written thief JD) do well with what they are given but there are notable shortfalls where the drama, emotion, connection, character definition, and thrilling set pieces in the original film are concerned. It’s not helped that Neko Case’s songbook is, by and large, underdeveloped and eminently forgettable. As with most other screen-to-stage adaptations, projection is doing the work of imagination, lending a cinematic sweep to writing that has done nothing whatsoever to earn one.’

Critics’ average rating 3.1⭑

You can see Thelma & Louise at the Young Vic theatre until 24 October. Tickets available from the theatre

If you’ve seen Thelma & Louise at The Young Vic, please leave your review and rating below

Be the first to write a review

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

×