Theatre reviews roundup: Cloud 9 by Caryl Churchill

Critics on cloud nine

Lyttelton Theatre, National Theatre
Cloud 9 in the Lyttelton Theatre. Photo: Johan Persson

First performed in 1979, Caryl Churchill‘s Cloud 9 has been revived by the National Theatre. Many were fearing its satire on the Victorian British imperialism and, in the second act, the would-be liberated 1970s would seem dated. However, the critics decided (with one dissenter) that it was ‘still incendiary, still challenging, still surprising’ (WhatsOnStage). Dominic Cooke’s direction helped by playing it straight (‘Cooke wisely avoids updating, instead leaning into the play’s self-conscious theatricality and treating both parts as period pieces’ FT). The actors were praised and everyone had a good word to say about Miriam Buether’s set that is broken up during the interval, much as the Empire was. Only The Times found it ‘a long evening’.

(Most of these extracts carry links to the full reviews but you may find that, in some case, you are blocked by a paywall.)

5 stars ⭑⭑⭑⭑⭑

WhatsOnStage‘s Sarah Crompton informed us: ‘(It was) first performed in 1979, yet it lands on stage like a radical blaze of hope. It’s still incendiary, still challenging, still surprising.’ She explained: ‘It binds together two very distinct strands. The first half is a farcical examination of British Colonialism and its effect on the social and sexual identities of the individuals who ran the Empire. The second bends time; it takes place in London in 1979, but it brings those characters together 25 years later, when they are trying to define and explore new ways of living with themselves and with others.’ She concluded: ‘It’s a great play, superbly staged, dazzlingly rich. The politics of gender may have changed in the intervening years, but Churchill’s always rigorous willingness to grapple with the hardest questions makes its ultimate tolerance and acceptance of the right to be different piercingly relevant today.’

4 stars ⭑⭑⭑⭑

The Guardian‘s Arifa Akbar opened: ‘Caryl Churchill’s time-hopping 1979 drama is not revived as often as it might be, perhaps because it is so magnificently madcap. Bouncing from a first act satirising Victorian life in colonial Africa to a second act exploring sexual liberation in 1970s London, it could easily roll off-kilter in the wrong hands. There is also its complicated framework. Cloud 9 is a play in two distinct parts which follows some of the characters a century on, although they only age 25 years in that time and are played by different actors through ironic cross-casting. Thankfully this crisp, handsome and note-perfect revival lands in exactly the right hands with director Dominic Cooke, clear as crystal despite the complications, sizzling with satire but showing itself to be a deadly serious, and still highly topical, play about identity beneath its playful sending up of everything from empire and Britishness to the confinements of marriage.’

The Stage’s Sam Marlowe was ‘dazzled by her daring, her freewheeling imagination, her piercingly astute use of theatrical language and her galvanising irreverence for the conventions of form. This 1979 play – which joyously explodes gender politics, family structures and the hierarchies embedded in history and society, as well as its own logical chronology – is not only riotously funny, but startlingly subversive.’

The Telegraph’s Dominic Cavendish was on cloud 9: ‘Deploying a superb cast of seven, the director Dominic Cooke triumphantly affirms the work as a modern classic and asserts the genius of its now-88-year-old author. True, the satiric critique of Victorian-era imperialism rather sidelines the colonised, and the second-act venting of “liberal” society confusions feels of its period. Yet the way Cloud 9 broaches sexism, feminism and how we get socially constructed seems prescient and pertinent, especially given debates around gender today, and in form the work is pioneeringly theatrical, while avoiding earnestness.’

Time Out‘s Andrzej Lukowski told us: ‘the whole (first) half amounts to a ferocious takedown of the Victorians via the playwright’s suggestion that the zenith of British colonialism was fuelled by sexual frustration and gender confusion: seething Englishmen, not entirely clear what they’re supposed to be doing out in the world, taking out their resentment on women, Africans and ultimately themselves.’ He concluded: ‘Churchill is still going strong at 88, but she doesn’t write ‘em like this anymore: her modern plays are short, neutron-dense works of shimmering intellect. Cloud 9 is more human than all that, a little more tied to its era, but no less genius, I think – and this is an immaculate revival.’

The Financial Times‘ Sarah Hemming found ‘Dominic Cooke’s rare, beautifully poised revival of her groundbreaking Cloud 9, a reminder of just how prescient and formally daring a writer Churchill has always been.’ She described how ‘Churchill, flipping ideas around with the alacrity of pancake chef, explores gender and sexual politics, the legacy of colonialism and the way historical power structures shape personal lives. Serious as all this is, it comes packaged with Churchill’s incisive wit, playfulness and brilliant understanding of theatrical language. Key to Cloud 9 is the roleplay at the heart of theatre, which she uses to prise open the gap between individuals’ desires and the expectations to which they conform.’ She pointed out: ‘Cooke wisely avoids updating, instead leaning into the play’s self-conscious theatricality and treating both parts as period pieces. It’s an approach that continues the play’s restless challenge: what chimes, what chafes and why? How far have we travelled and how does the past still inhabit and shape the present?’

Dominic Maxwell of The Sunday Times ended his review: ‘what an enduringly odd triumph. All hail Caryl Churchill.’ He said: ‘ Churchill is out to join the dots between colonial and sexual oppression and repression (…) It’s equal parts fun and games to pointedness and pain. How does she make it all so soulful? How does she create almost cartoonish characters then expose all their damaged innards too?’ He continued:: ‘ to some extent it is a parody, although a sympathetic one, of the shapes we bend ourselves into to find what we really like and who we really are.’

Josh Maughan for BroadwayWorld noted: ‘What is particularly interesting is how much of the first half remains present in the second. The question becomes less about whether we have progressed and more about what we have managed to carry forward, consciously or otherwise. Miriam Buether’s set design reinforces this exceptionally. The second half inhabits the collapsed remains of the first half’s set, a physical destruction of the world we have just witnessed. Yet the characters continue to live, love, have sex and argue within it. It is an effective visual metaphor for the persistence of history: the structures that once governed us may have fallen, but their remnants are part of the landscape.’

Anya Ryan for LondonTheatre said: ‘All of it is gloriously good fun, with ideas about societal progress, both then and now, bubbling beneath it all.’

3 stars ⭑⭑⭑

Olivia Jordan writing for CityAM decided: ‘many of its observations have lost their cutting edge’ and ‘much of the intersectional gender, sexual and racial dynamics are still relevant – but overall makes it feel more like a fascinating historical piece than a work of theatre offering a fresh perspective.

2 stars ⭑⭑

The Times’ Clive Davis disagreed: ‘once Churchill has laid out her stall on the evils of the patriarchy and Union Jack imperialism, it turns out to be a long evening.’ He observed: Churchill deals in archetypes rather than characters. The Victorian sequence descends into a grinding series of vignettes which have all the subtlety of a chin-stroking version of Carry On Up the Jungle. After an interval of 25 to 30 minutes, we return to the auditorium to find audience members who were sitting in the front two rows now lounging behind the actors. The set, once framed by a traditional proscenium arch, has fallen into ruins. Was it really worth making us wait so long? I don’t think so.‘

Critics’ average rating 3.6⭑

Value rating 44 (Combination of average rating and typical ticket price)

Cloud 9 can be seen at the Lyttleton at the National Thetare until 13 January 2027

If you’ve seen Cloud 9 at the National Theatre, please leave your review and rating below

Theatre reviews roundup: Speculations

The main speculation is ‘why’

Marylebone Theatre
Speculations at Marylebone Theatre

Torben Bett’s play Speculations follows a reporter’s investigations into the deaths of Marilyn Monroe, John F Kennedy and Lee Harvey Oswald. The critics liked Janie Dee in the lead but found the rehashed conspiracy theories too familiar, even with Trevor Nunn directing.

[Links to full reviews are included but a number are behind paywalls and therefore may not be accessible]

3 stars ⭑⭑⭑

The Guardian’s Arifa Akbar was moderately happy: ‘Director Trevor Nunn creates a smoothly oiled production …, eliciting strong performances from the cast which never seem like tacky imitations.’

Caroline McGinn for Time Out noted: ‘Dee is always a dream to watch, but the play suffers from too much exposition and, because we know what’s coming, not enough peril. It feels scattered and unsettled (…) The speculations are intriguing and Nunn has put together a well-crafted production. But in an era where political lying has gone beastmode, to the algorithmic next level, this just didn’t feel to me like an urgent story to re-tell.’

2 stars ⭑⭑

The Stage’s Sam Marlowe declared: ‘The writing seems to be aiming at noirish, hard-boiled, side-of-the-mouth wit. Instead, it’s slow, clunky, laden with exposition and often laughably melodramatic. And it’s improved not one iota by Nunn’s stodgy direction.’

Julia Rank for WhatsOnStage said: ‘Betts‘s writing and Trevor Nunn’s production both fail to grip and are hampered by a stilted talkiness (…) Unfortunately, the speculations raised by this piece aren’t enough to make for compelling drama.‘

Clementine Scott for BroadwayWorld reported: ‘The setup for Torben Betts’s new political thriller is an unlikely one: a successful New York journalist in the 1960s hires a new nanny, then proceeds to draw her into a dangerous investigative reporting project, before ultimately ending up in an effective hostage situation. Unfortunately, the rest of the show does little to draw the audience away from the absurdity of the premise.’

The Times’ Clive Davis began: ‘Hardcore conspiracy theorists may enjoy it; no one else will. Speculations, which tries to tease out a link between the assassination of John F Kennedy and the death of Marilyn Monroe, is full of mysterious dead ends. Yet the only real mystery here is how Torben Betts’s garbled script attracted the attention of the director Trevor Nunn and that superb actress Janie Dee.’

1 star ⭑

Gary Naylor at The Arts Desk ‘Torben Betts’ play rakes over some very, very well worn theories (never more than a click or two away from where you are right now in the Internet Age) about the assassination of John F Kennedy, The Mob connections of Lee Harvey Oswald and the tragic death of Marilyn Monroe (…) it’s that weary familiarity of subject matter that finally sinks a show, already holed beneath the waterline by flaws in all the components that need to come together for an engaging and interesting evening.‘

The Standard’s Nick Curtis was damning: ‘Maybe the mob did kill Monroe and JFK (and Kilgallen, whose research was missing when her body was found after a supposed overdose, and then RFK and MLK). Who knows? Who cares? I’m not sure Betts or Nunn really do, otherwise they’d come up with something more considered and less cloth-eared.’

Critics’ average rating 2.0⭑

Speculations can be seen at Marylebone Theatre until 17 January 2027. Buy tikcets from the theatre marylebonetheatre.com

Do you agree with the critics? If you’ve seen Speculations at the Marylebone Theatre, please leave your review and rating below

Theatre reviews roundup: The Lives of Others with Keira Knightley

Mixed reviews for Ike’s eavesdropping thriller

Adelphi Theatre
Keira Knightley & Luke Thompson in The Lives Of Others. Photo: Pamela Raith

Theatrical wunderkind Robert Icke has turned his attention away from the classics to adapt a film. The critics were happy that he had created a gripping play that reflected on the power of art, although some felt it didn’t match the subtlety of Florian Henckel von Donnersmarck’s 2006 film. The play and film are set in East Germany during the communist days when the Stasi spied on everybody, looking for dissent. In this case, Gerd Wiesler played by Stephen Dillane is listening in on a couple from the arts world, gradually becomes involved in their lives and tries to save them. Luke Thompson is Georg Dreyman, a playwright who initially compromises his work in order to stay out of trouble before becoming rebellious. As so often, a big West End play requires a big screen name, in this case, Keira Knightley, who plays Christa-Maria Sieland, a fragile star actor who tries to survive by sleeping with the enemy.  All the actors were complimented and there was much praise for Hildegard Bechtler‘s set.

Its ‘Value’ rating is currently the lowest of any limited run show listed. At the time of writing, mid-price tickets on which my rating is based started are £195. The top price is £275. If this makes you you think only rich people can afford to go to the theatre, you may be surprised to find there is only a handful of seats available.

[Links to full reviews are included but a number are behind paywalls and therefore may not be accessible]

5 stars ⭑⭑⭑⭑⭑

The Standard‘s Nick Curtis was bowled over by Icke’s ‘magnificent adaptation’. He thought Keira Knightley ‘is fittingly cast as Christa-Marie Sieland, the bright, brittle star of the East Berlin theatre scene – all professional sheen and charm until a devastating scene that Knightley performs with wrenching conviction. This is not a celebrity vehicle, though, but an ensemble piece. Indeed, you could almost call it a gesamtkunstwerk – a “total artwork” – so vital are design, sound and music to Icke’s vision.’ He ended: ‘It’s great to have Knightley back on the London stage after 15 years, alongside Dillane and Thompson in a fine, big cast. Icke, best known for his radical Shakespeares and startlingly reworked classics, here brilliantly re-examines the recent past at a time when we’re arguably more surveilled, monitored, and eavesdropped-upon than ever.’

WhatsOnStage‘s Sarah Crompton declared in a passionate review: ‘Icke has transmuted a film about heroic resistance to authority and the moments that people crack or rebel into a play about the power of art and the need for the kind of understanding it provokes, subtly but insistently altering the focus. His vision is an immense achievement not least because it is nigh-on perfect in execution (…) The whole production is a triumph because it embodies its own theme. Art matters, empathy counts. A society that forgets compassion for the lives of others is not worth having. And it shows that by being a deeply moving and utterly spellbinding evening of theatre.’

Aliya Al-Hassan of BroadwayWorld called the adaptation ‘utterly compelling’. She ended: ‘This is a gripping and totally absorbing night out, with star casting that pays off in spades.’

Jane Edwardes for Plays International was impressed by the way ‘Icke has put together an outstanding production team who support his work all the way. Hildegard Bechtler’s design is noteworthy for the austerity of the black flats that slide back and forth, and for a revolving stage which adds to the sense that the state can probe into every aspect of one’s life (…) Giles Thomas’s sound design brilliantly shifts from the classical music in Dreyman’s apartment to the crackle of the sound waves, to the insistent sound of Max Richter’s music.’

4 stars ⭑⭑⭑⭑

The Financial Times’ Sarah Hemming praised ‘Robert Icke’s brilliantly slippery and exquisitely acted adaptation (…) On stage, the interplay between truth and artifice, trust and deception, so central to live drama, becomes critical not just to the story but to its delivery, bringing the issues thrillingly and troublingly alive.’ She described how the actors portray characters are trying to survive in an authoritarian regime: ‘The actors trace precisely and eloquently the cost this exacts. Thompson’s glossy confidence and boy-next-door bounce gradually drain away as he realises that he’s a pawn; Knightley’s defiantly tilted chin and poised charm give way to brittle, strung-out despair. Dillane, meanwhile, is sensationally good as a man eaten away by the sordid reality of grubbing about in people’s intimate lives.’

Marianka Swain for LondonTheatre called it a ‘sleek and riveting adaptation’. She reported: ‘Keira Knightley … is inspired casting for the glamorous star possessed of an otherworldly beauty. She’s excellent, too, as the insecure offstage Sieland’.

The Telegraph‘s Dominic Cavendish was delighted by the return of Keira Knightley to the stage: ‘you can’t take your eyes off her – even if the evening belongs to Stephen Dillane as Wiesler, the conflicted Stasi captain in the attic.’ He said: ‘the achievement of the production, played without interval and often using a stage revolve to create a sense of remorseless scrutiny, is that it has its own strange, nightmarish logic.’  He continued: ‘Sparingly employing camerawork for the interrogation scenes, the director makes the case for the story as a live, communal experience: there’s an astounding coup de théâtre when the set is pulled apart, exposing the Adelphi’s full stage, the scene-shifters, and the artifice of it all. That’s not just a Truman Show-style indictment of Communist oppression, but a form of mass implication, too: we’re all voyeurs here.’

The Independent‘s Alice Saville said Icke succeeded in ‘turning grimy state machinery into heartstopping visual poetry (…) Icke’s staging here creates a series of beautifully-designed prisons; spaces that trap, stifle and ultimately destroy the people who live in them. Sliding screens move at breakneck speed to shrink the audience’s view of the stage into a tiny, cinematic close-up. Designer Hildegard Bechtler creates a midcentury apartment whose covetable modernist comforts can vanish in an instant, replaced by desolate institutional punishment.‘

3 stars ⭑⭑⭑

Dave Fargnoli of The Stage felt: ’Icke’s production never quite equals the film’s oppressive atmosphere, puncturing the tension too often with out-of-place comic relief and a frustrating tendency to gloss over the emotional impact of certain key events. Still, the story remains absolutely gripping, and Icke’s staging is typically slick and tautly paced.‘

The Guardian‘s Arifa Akbar declared: ‘Icke chooses a difficult story to adapt and direct here’ and concluded the adaptation ‘does not manage the immensely difficult task it sets itself.’ She had particular words to say about the actors: ‘Luke Thompson … seems too puppyish in the role. Knightley (…) gives a committed performance, but the character feels overheated and underwritten’ and Dillane’s ‘inner change is portrayed too subtly and not subtly enough.’

Time Out‘s Andrzej Lukowski also dissected the actors: ‘Dillane is terrific in the role: a desiccated, hollowed out old apparatik who passionlessly destroys lives but is astounded to discover the flickering embers of a conscience deep inside. Thompson is very good as Georg, a man whose initial bland niceness and aversion to risk isn’t actually a front (the Ed Sheeran of East Germany). But his slide into rebellion is really well-handled, with Thompson keeping him winningly innocent throughout. Big name Knightley lacks the stage experience of her co-stars (…) She’s fine, but a really great stage actor could probably have elevated not only the part, but by extension  probably the entire play. As it is, it’s not prime Icke, but he’s at least done a fine job in turning a 20-year-old foreign language film into gripping West End entertainment.’

Mary Conway for The Morning Star found: ‘That Robert Icke is the director adds excitement to what would otherwise be a pale copy of the film. And Icke’s visual imagination leaves us with lasting images: not least Bechtler’s glorious revolving set which brings us every detailed corner of Dreyman’s flat, all fully exposed except for the bedroom and bathroom — both sites of significant private happenings in the drama — which appear in misty focus as if Wiesler himself can’t bear to look.’ She assured her readers: ‘While the play does highlight the ever-present potential threat of writers and artists to the dominant political philosophy, it more precisely embodies the corruption of power and the abiding humanity of ordinary people. And it’s not an anti-socialist play. At one point Dreyman asserts that the socialist experiment of the Eastern bloc is overwhelmingly a quest for good. And that is the takeaway, not a Western celebration of glasnost as we might expect.’

The Times‘ Clive Davis offered faint praise: ‘in the end you are often left admiring the bravura flourishes rather than being drawn into the story itself’ (…) ‘Knightley is perfectly fine’ (…) ‘Thompson is likeable enough’ (…) ‘Hildegard Bechtler’s revolving set … the constant movement does tend to overshadow the actors at times’ (…) ‘Icke’s extended soundtrack delivers mixed results as well.’ (…) ‘Icke also indulges in a few too many theatre in-jokes … in the context of a drama set in a totalitarian state they had a frivolous air to them.’

Critics’ average rating 3.9⭑

Value rating 20 (combining average rating with typical ticket price)

The Lives of Others is at The Adelphi Theatre until 9 January 2027. Buy directly from the theatre 

If you’ve seen The Lives Of Others at the Adelphi Theatre, please leave your review and rating below

Theatre reviews roundup: Ilford Boy

Portrait of working-class family is warm and funny

Donmar Warehouse
Ilford Boy at the Donmar theatre. Photo: Helen Murray

Danny Lee Wynter’s second play looks at a working-class family in Ilford in 1980 and 1995. In particular we follow a mixed-race teenager coming to terms with his homosexuality, influenced and overwhelmed by his mother and her two sisters. The critics warmed to it, some more than others, and all agreed it was ‘very, very funny’ (Time Out). They liked the period accuracy. They praised the actors including Ria Zmitrowicz, Jodie McNee, Charlotte Jaconelli, and young Leo Whitfield Harris. Director Tim Sheader got credit too for ‘the charm and warmth’ (The Stage). The Times’ Clive Davis went so far as to say: ‘It is, quite simply, the most entertaining homegrown play I’ve seen since Till the Stars Come Down’. Praise indeed.

[Links to full reviews are included but a number are behind paywalls and therefore may not be accessible]

5 stars ⭑⭑⭑⭑⭑

The Times’ Clive Davis declared it was ‘extraordinarily funny, endlessly thought-provoking and propelled by some electrifying performances. It is, quite simply, the most entertaining homegrown play I’ve seen since Till the Stars Come Down (…) In much the same way, it homes in on ordinary lives lived far from the metropolitan smart set.’

4 stars ⭑⭑⭑⭑

Holly O’Mahony for WhatsOnStage noted: ‘It’s reminiscent of Beth Steel’s Till the Stars Come Down in its hyper-naturalism: hair is blowdried and a roast is eaten in real time. There’s a little of Billy Elliot in Ted too, as he finds himself torn between the boxing gloves Ken wants him to wear and Mrs S’s musical tapes, which he adores. Wynter himself grew up in east London and presumably pours some of his own experiences into what ultimately unwinds as a by-turns acutely funny and desperately sad tapestry of a very particular time and place.’

Fiona Mountford for the Telegraph declared: ‘What is an unending delight is the frank, witty and expletive-filled conversation between Tillie and her sisters Jackie (Jodie McNee) and heavily pregnant Ann (Charlotte Jaconelli). As Chekhov conclusively demonstrated, three sisters is the ideal number and we could happily watch this trio strop and bicker all day. Zmitrowicz, McNee and Jaconelli all put in gloriously vibrant performances in this heartfelt production from Tim Sheader who, fresh from his successful remounting of Jesus Christ Superstar with Sam Ryder, once again proves himself a notably versatile director.’

Aliya Al-Hassan for BroadwayWorld concluded: ‘this production shows the strength and realism of Wynter’s writing; the playful banter at the family dining table, the sharp ribbing that only a relative can get away with and relationships carefully drawn to reflect the diverse messiness of human life. With some brilliant performances and a thoughtful exploration of Black manhood, Ilford Boy is an imperfect, but gorgeous little production.’

The Standard‘s Nick Curtis called it: ‘A coming-of-age tale in a rich East London milieu, actor Danny Lee Wynter’s second play is warm but not cosy. It teems with vulgar wit and life, and Tim Sheader’s production features a host of fine performances.’

Anya Ryan popped up at Time Out to tell us: ‘it is very, very funny, full of the kind of casual idioms that make up the easy way you speak to family and friends: ‘you can’t turn a dog into a chair, and if you do it won’t be comfy’. Drawing the lines between the people we were in the past and the people we become, Wynter has written something wise, witty and packed with big feelings. But here, it is the little things that move you: having to hand back the keys to your family home or inheriting old cassette tapes that have been held by the people you love. It’s good stuff.’

3 stars ⭑⭑⭑

WhatsOnStage‘s Sarah Crompton thought: ‘Wynter crams too much into his narrative, and the play never escapes its sense of being a therapeutic outpouring. But it is wonderfully vital in its portrayal of Ilford life – and sobering in its depiction of just how hard it was to be a Black gay man in this context. The sisters are wonderfully drawn and very convincing in their relationships to each other.’

The Stage‘s Sam Marlowe called it a ‘slight, but big-hearted play’.  She declared: ‘Gossamer-light and sequin-sparkly, this bittersweet new play by Danny Lee Wynter is as beguiling as it is insubstantial. It’s essentially a conventional coming-of-age story, with choppy family dynamics set against a teenager’s emerging sense of self and sexuality. The tone and texture of the writing has shades of sitcom and soap; it’s also reminiscent of the earlier work of Mike Leigh, Jonathan Harvey and Jim Cartwright. But if it all feels a little overfamiliar, it’s pretty tough to resist the charm and warmth of Tim Sheader’s production, with its vigorous, cartoonish performances. And at its best, Wynter’s effervescent dialogue is deliciously funny.’

Kate Wyver for The Guardian commented: ‘There is sharpness and humour within the core family’s spiky arguments, with an abundance of anguished love offered by Ted’s mum (Ria Zmitrowicz), though some of the wider family could have more substance.’

Aleks Sierz for The Arts Desk had a mixed response: ‘On the “yes” side, this is a good old-fashioned family play, with some neat comedy and entertaining episodes (…) Then there’s the “no” side of the playwriting: just as the play is set in the mid-1990s so Wynter’s writing style is of a similar pre-in-yer-face-theatre vintage.’

The Financial Times’ Sarah Hemming decided: ‘it’s a play that takes on rather more than the structure can hold. But it honours both family and found family, cherishes the bravery of ordinary people in the face of adversity and prejudice, celebrates acceptance and is written with huge heart and wit.’

Critics’ average rating 3.6⭑

You can see Ilford Boy at the Donmar Warehouse theatre until 28 November. Buy tickets directly from donmarwarehouse.com

If you’ve seen Ilford Boy at The Donmar, please leave your review and rating below

Theatre reviews roundup: Martin Guerre

Latest version of musical flop better but still not a hit

Old Vic Theatre
Martin Guerre at The Old Vic. Photo: Helen Maybanks

Boublil and Schonberg‘s  Martin Guerre got a poor reception when it premiered in 1996 and there have been many unsuccessful attempts to re-launch it ever since. The latest iteration is directed by the Old Vic’s soon to be ex-Artistic Director Matthew Warchus. The critics seemed to agree that it is the best version yet but still not there, ‘there’ being on a par with the creators’ big hits Les Mis and Miss Saigon. Structure was said to be the problem and that has been altered considerably in this chamber presentation in which the story now centres on Guerre’s wife played by a well reviewed Liv Andrusier.

[Links to full reviews are included but a number are behind paywalls and therefore may not be accessible]

4 stars ⭑⭑⭑⭑

‘lean into its pagan excess and heart-on-sleeve emoting, and this is a gripping evening’ said Claire Allfree writing for the Telegraph. She highlighted: ‘The singing – notably Liv Andrusier’s Bertrande, mixing sweetness and steel particularly beautifully on new song Someday – is superb.’ While acknowledging that ‘Warchus’s production is far stronger at emphasising the story’s mythic darkness than fleshing out character psychology’, she pointed out: ‘By staging it so effectively in pocket-sized form, Warchus may have inadvertently made a case for Martin Guerre as a minor piece rather than a rediscovered classic; it’s hard to imagine this iteration of the musical transitioning to a bigger stage. But as the final scenes seamlessly build and build, I was thoroughly seduced.’

3 stars⭑⭑⭑

Alexander Cohen of BroadwayWorld reported: ‘this updated version’s heart remains elusive, but its undeniable charm keeps our blood pumping. The rambunctious music is impossible to ignore, and the tightly choreographed chorus sways and throbs like a shoal of tuna. Rob Howell’s in-the-round wooden set heats it with folktale warmth.’

Tim Bano, writing for Time Out, opined: ‘it is, simply, not a great musical. There are soaring solo melodies, contrapuntal chorus numbers, a sense of a score always bursting at its seams, but only a couple of numbers stand out – the title song and a swelling new anthem called ‘Someday’ – and the result is a restless musical about identity that can never quite find its own.

The Standard‘s Nick Curtis decided: ‘Warchus’s direction, and Rob Howell’s basic design of a circle of benches strewn with red chaff, are succinct and effective. The lighting and the band are crisp. But my god it’s over the top. Everyone here sings with a tremulous, volcanic passion, but on the bus home I realised I was humming the signature number “Martin Guerre” to the “Go Compare” ad jingle (…) Perhaps the story is itself the problem: the very mystery that makes the real-life tale of Martin Guerre so tantalising doesn’t lend itself to an easily resolved narrative. Oh well., Back to the drawing board.’

LondonTheatre‘s Anya Ryan noted: ‘Part of the problem is that Martin Guerre will always be judged against its illustrious siblings. While it has many of the hallmarks of a Schönberg and Boublil musical – multilayered love songs, sweeping operatic melodies, and emotionally charged storytelling – the material itself just isn’t as carefully constructed or momentous. But this production does its very best to breathe fresh excitement into the story. Warchus rips up what has gone before to deliver a delicate chamber piece, leaning into the personal relationships and deep longings at the musical’s core (…) but I was forever questioning what Bertrande was actually thinking, wishing for even a flash more insight.’

Dominic Maxwell of The Times recorded: ‘for all the grandness of the feelings so earnestly expressed on stage, few of them stretched into my part of the stalls. Complexity is good in storytelling, confusion is bad, and for too long I was just clinging on to who was who and what was what and wondering why the cast were daubed with bits of white make-up.’ He ended: ‘I found it intriguing rather than devastating, skilful more than soulful.’

The Guardian‘s Arifa Akbar reported: ‘Among the twists and surprises, the real fireworks come from Matthew Warchus’s ingenuity as director. His in-the-round production creates intimacy between Martin and his wife, Bertrande (Liv Andrusier), but also brings a frothing sense of mob rule as the villagers brand her a witch and punish her for his desertion. Warchus, as deft as he is, cannot override all the problems of the musical and the reworking feels simultaneously fast and slow, the sleeker shape bringing momentum but the songs – operatic, emotional, too tonally similar – slowing everything down again.’

Critics’ average rating 3.2⭑

You can see Martin Guerre at The Old Vic until 31 October 2026. Buy tickets from oldvictheatre.com

If you’ve seen Martin Guerre at the Old Vic, please leave your review and rating below

Theatre reviews roundup: Triumph by Caryl Churchill

Not quite a play but quite an impact

Almeida Theatre
Triumph at The Almeida Theatre. Photo: Marc Brenner

I was in two minds whether to round up the reviews of Caryl Churchill‘s latest play. It only last 20 minutes, the run is short and sold out, and there weren’t many reviews. But she is an important voice in theatre and the reviews are on the whole enthusiastic. Triumph (an anagram of Hi Trump) starts with Kate O’Flynn‘s press officer talking about her Leader’s triumphs. Later we find her and her journalist lover, played by Matthew Beard, in bed, at which time he tells her the reality of the leader’s vile behaviour. All the words are from Roman historian Suetonius‘ descriptions of Roman emperors. Back at the lectern, she reveals the truth she’s learned, only to find the people are even more convinced in their support. James Macdonald directs.

[Links to full reviews are included but a number are behind paywalls and therefore may not be accessible]

4 stars ⭑⭑⭑⭑

WhatsOnStage‘s Sarah Crompton described the work: ‘Triumph isn’t quite a play. At just over 15 minutes, you’d call it a jeu d’esprit, or a sketch, except that fails to describe its utterly chilling quality. Churchill has taken the words the Roman historian Suetonius used to describe the cruelty of emperors from Julius Caesar to Domitian and put them into the mouth of a modern-day media manipulator. All the words used to describe the tyrant are from Suetonius as a panel on Miriam Buether’s red-hued set announces; all the echoes are for us to find.’ She explained: ‘Directed with crisp straightforwardness by James Macdonald, Triumph makes its point by using sheer excess of Suetonius’s descriptions. This gory cruelty is historic, yet it speaks utterly to the dangers of anyone seeking absolute power.’ She continued: ‘Triumph is a reminder of the power of Churchill’s imagination: the way her mind makes dramatic leaps and forges links that most people do not see’.

David Benedict of The Stage stated: ‘It’s more of a politicised sketch than a play, but it’s hugely welcome that at 88, Churchill’s urge to question the world theatrically remains undimmed.’

The Financial Times‘ Sarah Hemming had a similar view: ‘it has the quality of a cautionary sketch and it runs for only a week. But it shares with much of her work that scalpel-like wit and use of fantasy to hold a dark mirror up to society.’

3 stars ⭑⭑⭑

The Standard‘s Nick Curtis commented: ‘Like all of Churchill’s most recent works, it is a bright miniature with a crystalline single idea, straightforward in its message. It contains little of the metaphysical hijinks, formal experimentation or character depth of her great earlier plays. The passages describing the attitudes and acts of “the emperor” apparently come directly from Suetonius. I confess it’s not a work I’m familiar with, but Churchill isn’t the first person to draw parallels between the orange president and Nero, Caligula or Claudius.’

The Times’ Clive Davis was not a fan: ‘It’s not so much a play, more a fragment (…) As a satire on Donald Trump’s presidency, it’s of passing interest. Any playwright who didn’t happen to be the octogenarian grande dame of radical theatre would probably have been told to come back with something more original than the idea of using Suetonius as a metaphor for the mayhem in Washington.’ He questioned: ’how deeply can you explore any character in just 20 minutes? Is this theatre for the TikTok generation?’

Critics’ average rating 3.6⭑

You can see Triumph at The Almeida theatre until 23 October 2026. Buy tickets (returns only) from almeida.co.uk

If you’ve seen Triumph at The Almeida Theatre, please leave a review and rating below

Theatre reviews roundup: Some Woman with Anne-Marie Duff

Anne-Marie Duff is ‘magnificent’ in disappointing play

Dorfman Theatre, National Theatre
Anne-Marie Duff in Some Woman. Photo: Ellie Kurttz

The critics were delighted to see Anne-Marie Duff back on stage (‘magnificent’ The Guardian) but most of them were disappointed that it wasn’t in better vehicle (‘slovenly writing’ The Times). Helen Edmundson‘s play shows how an incident, in which an ‘ordinary’ middle-aged woman is abused by a 11 year old boy, escalates until she becomes a victim of a misogynistic society and is pushed to the brink. Not all the critics were negative about the play: ‘leaves you feeling thoroughly shaken and queasy’ said Time Out. Blanche McIntyre directs.

[Links to full reviews are included but a number are behind paywalls and therefore may not be accessible]

4 stars ⭑⭑⭑⭑

WhatsOnStage‘s Sarah Crompton explained why she liked the play: ‘The setup of Helen Edmundson’s new play is very simple. Its twists and turns, however, draw gasps from the audience as Anne-Marie Duff’s Julie, an ordinary woman living an ordinary life, suddenly finds herself at the centre of a legal and emotional maelstrom. Its plot is part of its pleasure, so it’s a shame to give too much away, but suffice it to say that Julie quickly moves from being victim to being accused in a court system that allows manipulation and injustice to thrive.’ She continued: ‘What gives Some Woman its particular quality, though, is Edmundson’s interest in the way that women of a certain age become ignored. Julie’s reaction to what happens to her is in part because she is tired of being invisible, putting her needs last. She wants, as she says, people to look at her and to see her.’ She concluded: ‘it’s a tense and engrossing evening and a wonder to spend it with Duff, the kind of actor you could watch forever.’

The Telegraph‘s Dominic Cavendish was another supporter of the play: ‘As well as chiming with our Kafkaesque times – in which law-abiding citizens can feel they’re only one misstep from losing everything – Julie’s intensifying isolation embodies a sense of the insurmountable forces faced by feminism’ and of the star: ‘Duff makes a nominally “invisible” woman a potent presence, moving from eyes-closed disbelief, to bleak, blank despair, to a sense of courageous resolve.’

Holly O’Mahony for Time Out said: ‘Helen Edmundson’s new play Some Woman is described as a thriller, but the experience of watching it is more like a slow strangulation – one that leaves you feeling thoroughly shaken and queasy on the other side.’ She concluded: ‘Edmundson’s play posits that women beyond ‘a certain age’, as they’re so often described, are not only invisible to society, but dangerously vulnerable once they’re no longer deemed of value to men. This is feminist theatre that serves justice to its case.’

3 stars ⭑⭑⭑

‘Opposing forces tug against each other in this new drama as Anne-Marie Duff is magnificent amid playwright Helen Edmundson’s implausible plotting. The result is a failed suspension of disbelief yet a convincing central performance’ began The Guardian‘s Arifa Akbar. And ended: ‘She is not only the everyday victim of misogyny but an everyday female hero too. This message has its own power, however bad the plotting may be.’

The Standard‘s Nick Curtis started positively: ‘Anne-Marie Duff gives a fine performance of harried, slowly ramping desperation in this bleak drama about the hostility and unfairness women face in society. It’s good to have this subtle, heartfelt actress back, after two years away from the limelight, in a story that feels both horribly timely and horribly timeless.’ He was more negative about the play: ‘(The) script is punchy but schematic … with situations and characters arranged to push Duff’s Julie Robson toward a series of brinks (…) Much of Edmundson’s writing is eloquent, particularly Julie’s elucidation of her own lurch toward despair, and her paean to motherhood. But some of it is clunky beyond belief from a writer who is usually adroit.’

Jane Edwardes for Plays International praised the star: ‘Duff is such a good actor that every time she comes back home, which she does at the start of most of the scenes, you know her state of mind as she moves from bewilderment, through anguish, despair, and resentment to rebellion.’

The Stage’s Sam Marlowe gave this analysis: ‘It’s a grim, somewhat monochromatic picture: beyond a vague, rather dated-sounding reference by Julie to “the online stuff, the stuff with influencers”, there’s not much sense of context. The play’s observations are accurate, undeniably, but they’d have greater impact in a drama with a more varied texture and colour palette.’

2 stars ⭑⭑

Anya Ryan of LondonTheatre said: ‘Despite being a play that puts forward a tick-box collection of social issues, Duff is remarkably sincere, becoming progressively more shattered as Julie’s options close in around her. She looks constantly on the verge of releasing a scream, physically trembling in moments of distress.’

The Independent’s Alice Saville was disappointed: ‘Julie finally rebels – but with a gentleness and caution that doesn’t make sense in this black-and-white world. Duff is capable of delivering so much fire. Here, it’s as though she’s giving the patriarchy a kicking in house slippers, when what she needs is a steel-capped boot.’

The Times’ Clive Davis complained: ‘Anne-Marie Duff is a fine actress, but even her presence can’t compensate for the slovenly writing’ and warned: ’you’d be wise to stay away from this one’.

Critics’ average rating 3⭑

Some Woman can be seen at the National Theatre’s Dorfman Theatre until 21 November 2026. Buy tickets from nationaltheatre.org.uk

If you’ve seen Some Woman at The Dorfman Theatre, please leave your review and rating below

Theatre reviews roundup: The Cherry Orchard with Kristin Scott Thomas

Kristin Scott Thomas & Stephen Mangan shine in Chekhov’s tragi-comedy

Harold Pinter Theatre
Kristin Scott Thomas in The Cherry Orchard. Photo: Johan Persson

All eyes were on this production after the previously successful Chekhov productions from the same artists- The Seagull starring by an Olivier Awrad winning Kristin Scott Thomas, and Uncle Vanya directed by Ian Rickson and adapted by Conor Mcpherson. For most of the critics, The Cherry Orchard didn’t quite match the glories of those productions, but it was still much appreciated: ‘Ian Rickson’s elegantly directed production uses a plain-speaking new adaptation by Conor McPherson’ (Guardian). Kristin Scott Thomas was highly praised (‘luminous’ CityAM) as the down-at-heel aristocrat. So was Stephen Mangan as her would-be rich working class would-be saviour (‘a serio-comic masterclass’ Standard). All the cast were complimented for their portrayals of the motley collection of characters unable to come to terms with change.

[Links to full reviews are included but a number are behind paywalls and therefore may not be accessible]

4 stars ⭑⭑⭑⭑

Dave Fargnoli of The Stage was impressed: ‘Sweeping through the familiar passages of Chekhov’s tender tragicomedy like a crisp autumn breeze, this faithful new adaptation from celebrated playwright Conor McPherson is refreshing, clear and unfussy. McPherson’s lucid take on the story of fading aristocracy glitters with moments of disarming vulnerability and deadpan humour that honours Chekhov’s play while illuminating subtext, developing the dramatic potential of some relationships and alighting on unexpected interpretations of others. Director Ian Rickson paces it decorously, allowing each scene plenty of time to breathe, but never letting the pace flag, wringing out laughs with physical comedy and wry, rapid-fire punchlines. The atmosphere that develops is at once ghostly, fragile as cobwebs, and unexpectedly warm-hearted, full of bittersweet yearning.’

CityAM‘s Adam Bloodworth thought: ‘Luminous Kristin Scott Thomas is the perfect choice for eccentric, blinkered stateswoman Lyubov Ranevskaya in Anton Chekhov’s The Cherry Orchard, a mound of gesticulating passion and nostalgic delusion as the broke matriarch being slowly and painfully dethroned from her Russian country pile.’ He pointed out: ‘Conor McPherson and Ian Rickson’s new adaptation leans into the script’s farcical elements. In particular, Rickson exploits Mangan’s comedic nose; at times his performance nears slapstick, but he carries a general effeteness and lightness of touch that makes him an interesting provocateur opposite (Scott Thomas’s) airily out of touch matriarch.’

The Telegraph‘s Dominic Cavendish dwelt on the quality of the cast: ‘displaying her gift for clenched emotion… the star stamps her mark on the superficially carefree, inwardly agonised heroine, Ranevskaya (…) The low-born local businessman Lopakhin, brilliantly played by Stephen Mangan with sheepish charm and evident inner conflict’. There are, he said: ‘glorious performances across the board and the generations: mention should be made of Vinette Robinson as her long-suffering adopted daughter Varya; Shubham Saraf as the accident-prone, lovelorn Yepikhodov; and Jeff Rawle as the dotty, hard-up landowner Pishchik. Karl Johnson, simply superb throughout, supplies the requisite pathos as the scatty old retainer Firs, left to his own devices in a final, presumably fatal act of abandonment that tallies the cost of the others’ self-absorption.’

Alun Hood of WhatsOnStage declared: ‘Rickson’s direction is masterful, alive to every nuance, confidently embracing the dualities in Chekhov’s text: these people are deeply unhappy yet uproariously funny, and the sense of lives about to change forever is keenly felt. McPherson’s script is salty and smart and, most laudably, never sounds like a translation. Not everything about the update works, but that’s a small quibble about an emotionally intelligent production that renders a classic play alive and accessible, while still satisfying the most exacting of Chekhov enthusiasts, and boasting one of the greatest ensemble casts on any current London stage.’

Marianka Swain for LondonTheatre noted: ‘When Kristin Scott Thomas’s Ranevskaya returns home to this place full of ghosts, she describes it as a “crossroads”, and that sense of a liminal space – between past and future, one world and the next – pervades both Conor McPherson’s evocative new translation of Chekhov’s masterpiece and Ian Rickson’s gorgeous, elegiac production.’

The Independent‘s Alice Saville remarked: ‘What really does shine is Rickson’s mastery of Chekhov’s humour, in a production that never feels drawn-out or stodgy. This play is very, very funny, until it’s not – until you realise that this estate has stolen untold lives for centuries, and these unlucky, lingering, lovable few must pay the price.’

The Standard‘s Nick Curtis described the stars’ performances: ‘Scott Thomas gives a twitchy, strained, rictus-smiling central performance as Ranevskaya, the adored but terminally feckless landowner who seemingly can’t bear to be in a room with herself. She’s always slipping out of embraces and tricky situations, squirreling secretive drinks. Mangan delivers a serio-comic masterclass in timing and fretful awkwardness as the peasant turned businessman Lopakhin, and the supporting cast is impressive. The whole thing is a little rough around the edges but … also thrilling and refreshing.’

Time Out‘s Andrzej Lukowski pointed out: ‘Adapting playwright Conor McPherson cranks up both the bitter and the sweet as he massages the plot and dialogue for some big laughs … More importantly, there (is) an absolutely storming performance – dare I say career best – from the perennially underestimated Stephen Mangan as Yermolai Lopakhin. A self-made man of humble origins, his relationship with the lofty but impoverished household of Lyubov Ranevska (Kristin Scott Thomas) is the complicated heart of play.’ He concluded: ‘it’s the more painful emotions that linger in the splendid central turns from Scott Thomas and Mangan, the sense of people too in love with a perfect past to ever truly embrace an imperfect future.’

3 stars ⭑⭑⭑

Tim Bano for The Financial Times had mixed feelings about the mixed moods: ‘McPherson’s adaptation … clearly relishes the tonal shifts in Chekhov: they both enjoy weaving their plays with threads of daft humour as much as with anxiety and grief. That makes things difficult for the actors. Kristin Scott Thomas sticks very much to the serious side as once-wealthy landowner Ranevskaya … you get the sense of someone resentful of being the all-powerful matriarch, and so putting on an act of inertia and helplessness. It’s almost like she wants the coming reckoning. But it’s an uneven performance, as she underplays some moments and overcooks others. Though Mangan brings that expert comedy depth, even more thrilling is when he plays the tragedy, too. When his Lopakhin returns from the auction of the estate to reveal he’s bought it himself, the way he mutates nervousness into glee into disappointment is remarkable to watch.’

Gary Naylor for BroadwayWorld wasn’t convinced: ‘The Cherry Orchard is a state of the nation play – any time, any place – but it’s also a monument of literature, making the heart soar and dip as you see these fragile men and women make mistakes and take their chances. But Ian Rickson’s production doesn’t quite catch all the heights and depths of the emotions, the technical efficiency rather limiting the stakes. Do we really feel Madame’s despair as the orchard is cut down in plain sight as she stands next to her luggage, never to return? Do we really feel Lopakhin’s insensitive triumph, guilty but holding back a smirk? Do we really feel Firs’ isolation in a new world come to crush him at last?’

The Times’ Clive Davis observed: ‘all eyes are on Scott Thomas as her character wraps herself in illusions. There is sometimes an emptiness to her eyes that is quite chilling, as if she is living her real life inside her head. When she is not at the centre of things, though, the evening falters.’

The Guardian‘s Arifa Akbar thought: ‘Kristin Scott Thomas … brings a hard-edged modernity that you believe in. She feels of our time, despite the references to dachas and peasants, and could be an upper-middle-class Chelsea mother or minister’s wife, stewing in regret and an unfulfilled life. Ian Rickson’s elegantly directed production uses a plain-speaking new adaptation by Conor McPherson. (…) (it) is handsome and engaging, the crumbling drawing room of Chloe Lamford’s set design bearing damp patches and a faded grandeur.’ However, she felt: ‘some of the edges are softened, such as the fire of student and would-be revolutionary Trofimov (Jack Riddiford). You don’t feel much pathos for the set as a whole, and the drama never quite enters dark or tragic territory.’

2 stars ⭑⭑

The Daily Mail’s Patrick Marmion didn’t like the anachronistic adaptation: ‘The Cherry Orchard is a subtle study of tragic self-delusion from a time when Russian society was falling apart before the first revolution of 1905. Yet in Conor McPherson’s hollowed-out ‘reimagining’ of the play, any sense of place or class struggle has all but vanished. Instead, the action looks like it’s been transferred to the 1980s – a peculiar move, at odds with continued references to the end of serfdom in 1861.’ He ended his diatribe: ‘it’s like watching a herd of cats purposelessly gathered on Chloe Lamford’s damp-riddled set. A few desultory artefacts, including a shrine of religious icons, are largely ignored – just like the play’s historical moment.’

Critics’ average rating 3.5⭑

Value rating 37 (Combination of average rating and typical ticket price)

The Cherry Orchard can be seen at the Harold Pinter Theatre until 9 January 2027. Buy tickets from haroldpintertheatre.co.uk

Read Paul Seven’s review of The Cherry Orchard here

If you’ve seen this production of The Cherry Orchard, please leave your review and rating below

Theatre reviews roundup: Rent

New production does Rent’s score justice

Tom Stoppard Theatre
The cast of Rent at the Tom Stoppard Theatre. Photo: Pamela Raith

Luke Sheppard, perhaps best known for Paddington The Musical, has directed an in-the-round production of Jonathan Larson‘s 1990s musical about love, creativity in the shadow of AIDS. The critics mostly felt it did justice to the score but some found the storyline was drowned by the fabulous songs. Stranger Things’ Gaten Matarazzo acquitted himself well.

5 stars ⭑⭑⭑⭑⭑

Marianka Swain for LondonTheatre said: ‘under Luke Sheppard’s electrifying direction, it … packs an almighty punch. It honours the soul of the original, while making it feel thrillingly fresh’. She clearly loved this musical: ‘its passion is undeniable, especially the oft-cited line “No day but today”, which is both wrenchingly sad and a call to action. As Mark puts it: “The opposite of war isn’t peace – it’s creation”. RENT is a soul-stirring act of creation, and so too is this exhilarating revival.’

4 stars ⭑⭑⭑⭑

‘this is a thrilling musical, both perfectly of its time and still relevant today’ declared WhatsOnStage’s Sarah Crompton. She explained: ‘The in-the-round staging has been preserved for this larger and more splashy West End revival and it helps to lend great spirit and energy to a piece that is baggy and episodic but always engaging.’ She went on: ‘Sheppard’s direction is also cleverly paced, letting big scenes – Maureen’s “arty” performance to demand proper housing for the homeless, the meeting at the Life Café – unfold with panache, while keeping the focus on the individual stories that are being told. The actors are all are terrific.’

The Times’ Clive Davis described how ‘With cast members seated in a semicircle around the stage (some audience members are up there too), David Woodhead and Tom Jackson Greaves, the designer and choreographer …  generate a rock club-style sense of community (…)  Katy Richardson’s band, half-concealed on a raised platform at the rear of the stage, is suitably loud and loose-limbed.’

The Financial Times‘ Sarah Hemming was also impressed that ‘The Tom Stoppard Theatre (formerly the Duke of York’s) has been reconfigured to embrace a portion of the audience onstage, with the cast weaving through them and sometimes sitting among them before rising to sing. It’s a change that wraps the spectators in “la vie bohème”, as it’s depicted here, emphasising the communality at the musical’s heart and giving a rough, impromptu feel to the production that contrasts with the blazing professionalism of its execution. It just adds to the soaring emotion of this pulsating staging.’ She had reservations: ‘the storylines tend to crowd each other out (…) And the episodic, propulsive nature of the piece undercuts the weight of the issues. The ravages of both Aids and heroin addiction are framed a little too aesthetically.’ But ‘Flaws aside, this is still an exhilarating show, superbly delivered, its central message about making the best of your brief time on earth powering across loud and clear.’

The Telegraph‘s Dominic Cavendish this rousing, felt this ‘faithful revival by Paddington director Luke Sheppard more than earns its keep. It boasts a strong West End debut, too, for Gaten Matarazzo.’ He complimented all the cast: ‘Every leading player gets the opportunity to shine, with particularly fine performances from Travis Ross as the brooding Roger, always plugging away in the hope of writing one last belter; Alexa Lopez as Mimi, sexually cavorting and howling like a wolf in the love-hungry Out Tonight; and Jeevan Braich, flamboyant and defiant as Angel.’ He noted: ‘as the show has become more distinctly of its time, it paradoxically looks more durable – it captures a vanished New York but its relentless spirit seems undimmed.’

Louis Chilton for The Independent concluded: ‘At the end of the day, the big question facing a revival like this is whether it can fundamentally justify its own existence. Rent manages that, and then some.’

Aliya Al-Hassan of BroadwayWorld declared: ‘(Larson’s) lyrics hit as hard as ever, even though the duration (two hours, 45 minutes) may be a little too long for some. This version of Rent deserves the hype it has been receiving and is a fitting tribute to the monumental legacy of a musician and creative genius that we lost far too young.’

3 stars ⭑⭑⭑

Tom Wicker for The Stage pronounced: ‘There’s a fierce, sincere anger in the book and lyrics at the heartless gentrification of New York (now pretty much complete) and power in its centring of queer characters. But its earnestness, however on the money, feels heavy-handed.’

Time Out’s Andrzej Lukowski (3 stars assumed) was more critical of the production: ‘The concert-like production is based around an ensemble of hot androgynes and self-consciously beautiful misfits, dressed like a more-stylish-than-it-sounds collision of Dickensian urchinwear and early Pearl Jam chic. Sheppard has put a large amount of additional audience seating on the stage, which hems the action into a small performance space with minimal sets (…) It would be a great staged concert but I’m not sure how well it works as a theatre show. Sheppard’s aesthetic choices seem to override his interest in storytelling (…) A formidable vehicle for Larson’s songs, but a less impressive one for his story.’

David Jays for The Guardian wasn’t sure about the strength of the book (‘keeping eight principal characters in play is tricky’) but ‘The glory of the show is its songs – the bolshie ensembles and scared solos. Larson threw everything into Rent, from wrenching anthems and witty tango to strutting pop. He must have hoped to have more musicals ahead of him, but wrote like he was running out of time – that desperate sense to write the songs, love the love and live the life is the urgent heart of the show.’

Adam Bloodworth for CityAM was critical: ‘by today’s standards, taking something so horrific as AIDS, which took the lives of 20,000 Brits alone, and putting it as a backdrop to a central story about people getting kicked out of their flats (which is dealt with with far more emotion) feels strange and tone deaf.’ He opined: ‘the story line (is) often there to service the arrival of the next song rather than advancing the plot’.

Critics’ average rating 3.8⭑

Value Rating 38 (combination of average rating and typical ticket price)

Rent can be seen at the Tom Stoppard Theatre until 29 May 2027. Buy tickets from the theatre tomstoppardtheatre.com

If you’ve seen Rent at the Tom Stoppard Theatre, please leave your review and rating below

Theatre reviews roundup: Affluenza

The worst play of 2026?

Riverside Studios
Noah Schnapp in Affluenza. Photo: Danny Kaan

Affluenza , written and directed by Andy Sandberg, is a candidate for the worst play of the year according to the critics. Why? ‘It’s not deep nor funny, it lacks pace and determination, and it’s ultimately an atrocious watch’ (BroadwayWorld). The stage debut of Noah Schnapp didn’t save it: ‘Schnapp is the main draw but doesn’t have much to do in either of his thinly-sketched roles beyond swear and strop around’ (WhatsOnStage).

[Links to full reviews are included but a number are behind paywalls and therefore may not be accessible]

2 stars ⭑⭑

Aliya Al-Hassan for LondonTheatre suggested: ‘A dramaturg is urgently needed to add structure to a production that goes off on bizarre and unnecessary tangents’. She described it as ‘a missed opportunity to say anything thoughtful at all.’

Holly O’Mahony for The Stage found: ‘it grows increasingly directionless and leaves you unsure of exactly what it is you have just watched.’

The Standard‘s Nick Curtis reported: ‘For the record, Schnapp is fine, and Manrara isn’t bad, but there’s no real depth to anyone or anything here.’

1 star ⭑

The Guardian’s Arifa Akbar was puzzled that ‘Both (Schapp’s) characters are supporting parts, taking up so little oxygen on stage that you wonder why anyone would cast a big name and then tuck it away in two bit-parts?’ Similarly, ‘Janette Manrara is acting rather than foxtrotting here, but again plays a host of tiny roles’. In fact, she was mystified by the whole play: ‘It is hard to decipher what we are watching here – comedy, drama or a theatrical car crash in slow motion.’

Theo Bosanquet for WhatsOnStage declared: ‘it goes on one of the most head-scratchingly befuddling narrative trajectories I’ve ever seen on stage.’ He notedf: ‘Schnapp is the main draw but doesn’t have much to do in either of his thinly-sketched roles beyond swear and strop around, while Young is convincing as the lawyer but woefully miscast as the adult Noah’.

Cindy Marcolina let rip in her BroadwayWorld review: ‘not even a lavish set by Charlie Corcoran can hide the fact that this is a tasteless, aimless, pointless piece of theatre.’ She continued: ‘It’s almost unimportant to talk about the performances, as none of them make a difference…Schnapp is merely adequate, but the script wouldn’t allow him to be anything else. The rest of the cast amble between wooden, overdramatic, underachieving, and eager to see the curtain drop. It’s understandable: AFFLUENZA doesn’t add anything to the landscape. It’s not deep nor funny, it lacks pace and determination, and it’s ultimately an atrocious watch. ‘

Louise Penn for Plays International complained: ‘Affluenza is a victim of its own self-importance, and by the end it has collapsed into a ridiculous turn of events blighted by pizza boxes, shouting, and a plot which is impossible to follow. When so little of a play makes sense, it is hard to recommend it on any level.’

‘Unfortunately there’s not an ounce of subtlety in the script or Sandberg’s direction’ said The Times’ Clive Davis.

Critics’ average rating 1.4⭑

Affluenza can be seen at Riverside Studios until 28 November 2026. Buy tickets from riversidestudios.co.uk

If you’ve seen Affluenza, please leave your review and rating below

 

×