Theatre reviews roundup: Cabaret

Dark immersive production Bowles critics over

Playhouse Theatre (KitKat Club)
Cabaret at the KitKat Club. Photo: Marc Brenner

Cabaret is the top rated West End show of the 2020s. Only the eye-watering ticket prices have prevented it from being top value. The original stars Eddie Redmayne and especially Jessie Buckley (as Sally Bowles) were a significant focus of the many 5 and 4 star reviews, but the many subsequent replacements have shown that Rebecca Frecknall’s production is the true strength of the show. It is a dark interpretation of Kander and Ebb’s musical that uses a dazzling transformation of the Playhouse into the KitKat Club, and immersive elements within the performance to dupe the audience into being complicit in the growth of Nazism. The extracts from the reviews from the opening night that are reproduced below concentrate on the production rather than the stars.

5 stars ★★★★★

Nick Curtis of the Standard was Bowlesd over: ‘Wow. Rebecca Frecknall’s new revival of Kander and Ebb’s musical set in interwar Berlin is a stunning, breathlessly exciting theatrical happening. It feels loyal to the 1966 original yet astonishingly contemporary, and properly immersive.’

WhatsOnStage‘s Sarah Crompton declared: ‘The stamp of a great work of art is that it can bear many interpretations. Director Rebecca Frecknall…has taken Kander and Ebb’s 1966 musical and completely reimagined it. The result is both shattering and utterly magnificent.’ She went into detail: ‘ Scutt’s costumes are a riot of soft colour and texture, and Julia Cheng’s extraordinarily detailed choreography creates a tawdry, sexualised world, where everyone gets to express themselves and no-one is quite what they seem. By the close of a devastating night in the theatre, that image has been replaced with beige uniformity and straight lines of movement…The result, central to Frecknall’s thinking, is terrifying, with a darkness that reaches all the deeper because the audience has been made to feel complicit.’

Marianka Swain for BroadwayWorld said: ‘We came here to escape, but we emerge shattered. This is musical theatre at its absolute finest. A total knockout.’ She described ‘Julia Cheng’s rich choreography’: ‘a mix of styles, from jazz and contemporary to waacking, with angular freezes, chest pumps, swaying and shimmies – knowing and challenging.’ And how ‘Isabella Byrd’s exceptional lighting design creates eerie shadows, casts the characters in sudden shafts of light, or uses the lamps in the audience to draw us into the performance.’

Tim Bano at The Stage pointed out: ‘Frecknall’s direction doesn’t let style sideline substance. Perhaps her strongest play is the careful balance she maintains in terms of the Nazis as metaphor and as literal Nazis. This is a production specifically about antisemitism and the rise of fascism in 1930s Germany. It’s also about attacks on sexuality, gender, ethnicity and religion – or any other marker of identity at any other time.’ He ended: ‘While the whole nonsense of the Kit Kat Club – the secret entrance, the champagne – is completely at odds with what the musical is really about (not to mention the eye-watering ticket prices), it’s also perfect: the production dupes us, turns us into delusionists just like Sally, Cliff and the rest. It tricks us into feeling as if we’re at a party when really we’re at the most visceral display of political theatre in the West End.’

The Telegraph’s Dominic Cavendish wrote that Rebecca Frecknall ‘creates an immersive evocation of the Kit Kat Club, the early-1930s Berlin dive in which much of the action is set. She supercharges the ambience, though. The whole Playhouse has become a louche playground. In the modified auditorium, ranged with tables and with a raised, often revolving circular wooden stage at its heart, old-world decorum mingles with wild abandon.’

Roz Wyllie for LondonTheatre1 said: ‘The whole production is about as good as theatre gets; with every shade of emotion and absolutely no wasted dialogue or scene. It’s tight, it’s tender it’s shocking… it’s sinfully brilliant.’

Alexandra Pollard for The Independent commented: ‘Back in the Sixties, the musical’s original director Hal Prince called Cabaret “a parable of contemporary morality”. In such capable hands, it’s a parable that still packs a punch.’

4 stars ★★★★

Time Out‘s Andrzej Lukowski described the design: ‘the Playhouse Theatre has been heavily retooled by designer Tom Scutt, and literally renamed the Kit Kat Club… Scutt’s revamp is extremely classy. From opening up backstage areas and drenching them in atmospheric lighting to creating a secondary, gold-draped performance space for the fun (if inessential) pre-show cabaret-with-a-small-c entertainment, it’s full of quietly spectacular little flourishes.’ He continued: ‘costumes are angular, vivid, somewhat grotesque; the performers’ faces are sardonic, or sinister, not submissive or lusty. There is an alien harshness and a sense of confrontation and mischief, a feeling we have left the world behind: you really can picture this place as a strange nocturnal bubble removed from the increasingly grim realities of the Germany outside.’

The Guardian‘s Arifa Akbar found: ‘Rebecca Frecknall’s production on the whole lives up to its hype, magnetising us with flamboyant camp and then delivering menace that feels freshly charged.’

Suzy Evans at LondonTheatre noted: ‘Coupled with Tom Scutt’s immersive design and Isabella Byrd’s atmospheric lighting, this production feels like a world away from outside…And Frecknall doesn’t pull any punches with her high-concept approach…The approaching horror and absurdism of this escape is at the forefront, and her highly choreographed tableau feels like a ballet or a marionette show, where someone calculating is pulling all the strings.’

Fiona Mountford of the i pointed out: ‘Despite the immersive backdrop – all credit to designer Tom Scutt – this is a Cabaret that has been stripped back and cleansed of the reassuring layers of jollity that it often wears. Sex might be everywhere, but no one is enjoying it.’

Clive Davis of The Times was harder to please.  ‘Julia Cheng’s choreography for a blowsy set of dancers…never quite overcomes the limitations imposed by the lack of space.’

The Mail’s Patrick Marmion was less impressed than most but still gave it high marks: ‘It may be a little parsimonious in its pleasures, but this eagerly anticipated new staging of Cabaret certainly looks good, sounds good – and runs like clockwork.’

Critics’ average rating 4.5⭑

Value rating 36 (Value rating is the Average Critic Rating divided by the typical ticket price)

Cabaret is currently booking to 23 May 2026. Buy tickets directly from the theatre

If you’ve seen Cabaret at the Playhouse/KitKat Club, please add your review below 

Theatre reviews roundup: Born With Teeth

Charismatic stars save the play when Shakespeare meets Marlowe

Wyndham’s theatre
Ncuti Gatwa & Edward Bluemel in Born With Teeth. Photo: Johan Persson

Born With Teeth is an RSC production receiving its premiere in London rather than Stratford, and directed by the company’s co-Director Daniel Evans. The critics were generally agreed that Ncuti Gatwa  and Edward Bluemel were the saviours of the drama. They liked the concept of rising playwrights William Shakespeare (Bluemel) and Christopher Marlowe (Gatwa) revealing their differing characters as they collaborated on a play, but many felt the execution was repetitive and lacking wit.

[Links to full reviews are included but a number are behind paywalls and therefore may not be accessible]

5 stars ⭑⭑⭑⭑⭑

In a review that must have had some of his readers reaching for the smelling salts, the Daily Mail’s Patrick Marmion detailed the outrageous behaviour of Ncuti Gatwa’s Marlowe before declaring: ‘Daniel Evans’s steamy production fizzes with rare theatrical chemistry.’

4 stars ⭑⭑⭑⭑

Marianka Swain for LondonTheatre called it ‘a seriously steamy cat-and-mouse game, as American dramatist Liz Duffy Adams places these two brilliant men in one room so we can watch the sparks fly.’  She assured us: ‘this is an accessible romp that honours Shakespeare’s populist spirit, jubilantly reclaims queer history, and explores a literary mystery that continues to fascinate.’

The Financial Times’ Sarah Hemming (sadly often hidden behind a very expensive paywall) said it was ‘a tantalising piece — for better and for worse. It’s greatly entertaining, peppered with literary gags and impish anachronisms, and delivered with immense flourish. What holds it back is a reluctance to dive deeper into the huge themes it raises and give its characters more time to explore loaded issues such as religion, artistic freedom and self-preservation.’

Nick Curtis of The Standard needed a bucket of water thrown over him: ‘Phwoar! The chance to see a jacked and shirtless Ncuti Gatwa snogging his snake-hipped, chisel-cheekboned former Sex Education co-star Edward Bluemel is undoubtedly part of the appeal of Liz Duffy Adams’s seductively clever two-hander.’ He liked the play, saying it ‘blends intrigue and shifty eroticism with in-jokes and a discourse on creativity. The keynote of Daniel Evans’s production…is fluidity: nothing is every quite what it seems.’ He ended: ‘the way Duffy’s script entwines the vicissitudes of sex, celebrity and Elizabethan politics is enormous fun. And as star vehicles go, Evan’s production is a smart and subtle one.’

Cindy Marcolina for BroadwayWorld was star struck: ‘The production would be a resounding flop without Gatwa and Bluemel. Their bond is fun and attractive, magnetic in how it compels us to forgive the flimsiness of the script, the fluctuating quality of its dialogues, and its (mis)use of specific terminology’. Both she and Time Out’s critic described the play as ‘slash fiction’, which she helpfully explained is ‘a genre of fanfiction that focuses on the romantic relation between preexisting fictional characters of the same sex.’ So now you know.

Heather Neill sitting at TheArtsDesk told us: ‘under Daniel Evans’ spirited direction, Ncuti Gatwa as Marlowe and Edward Bluemel as Shakespeare grab every opportunity to explore their versions of these fascinating, contradictory characters’. She told us the playwright ‘is interested in the cause of – and often barriers to – artistic freedom now as well as in Elizabethan England. This is echoed in designer Joanna Scotcher’s set, the stage surrounded by banks of lights that might suggest interrogation as well as theatricality, and her costumes combining punk materials with Tudor shapes.’

TheatreWeekly‘s Greg Stewart was more enthusiastic about the script than others: ‘a bold and cerebral imagining of a clandestine creative collision between Christopher (Kit) Marlowe and William (Will) Shakespeare.’ He continued: ‘Adams’ writing is dense and richly layered, peppered with references and easter eggs that will delight aficionados of both playwrights. While the dialogue occasionally veers into the overly verbose, it remains riveting, especially when delivered with the electric chemistry of its two leads.’

3 stars ⭑⭑⭑

Sarah Crompton of WhatsOnStage summed it up as ‘an odd confection, at once challenging and comic, slightly circuitous and oddly revealing… it’s brought to vital, charismatic life by its casting’.

Time Out’s Andrzej Lukowski found it ‘comes across like a particularly insane workplace comedy’. He went on: ‘Born with Teeth is pretty trashy. I rolled my eyes at the whole sexual tension thing: our two heroes do end up snogging, but it mostly seems to be because that’s what happens in slash fiction’. Getting down to the nitty gritty, he said: ‘ultimately what Born with Teeth suffers from the most is asking us to imagine a sex and paranoia crazed Elizabethan society while not actually showing it to us.’ He concluded: ‘Born with Teeth is a lot of fun: two charismatic actors having a ball pinging off each other while chomping down on a script that spikes the trashiness with some genuine wit.’

For The Guardian’s Arifa Akbar, ‘this is Gatwa’s show. His boisterous Kit sweats in Zoë Thomas-Webb’s leather two-piece, his every lithe action a flirtation’. For her, the play promised more than it delivered: ‘The stakes simmer throughout but never reach boiling point.’

Sam Marlowe of The Stage described the production: ‘The aesthetic of Evans’ staging is chic modernity. Andrzej Goulding’s video design intercuts fever-dreamlike, monochrome scenes of the two playwrights being subjected to torture by the Elizabethan state with pixellations and static – designer violence, MTV-style. Meanwhile, their interactions take place on a set by Joanna Scotcher, lit by Neil Austin, of enclosing walls made up of banks of lights.’ She ended: ‘We know where this story is heading – after all, there’s no Royal Marlowe Company – and Duffy Adams never builds much tension on the way there. But this is a diverting enough double act, glinting with wit and style.’

Praising the actors’ performances, Fiona Mountford of i-news said: ‘Bluemel gives an understated performance of someone growing in confidence, growing into themselves, whereas Gatwa’s Marlowe is a flame that burns with explosive brightness and is then extinguished.’

‘It’s tragi-comical-farcical-ludicrous’, said the Telegraph‘s Dominic Cavendish, ‘What keeps you watching is the lusty bravura of Gatwa … with Bluemel…neatly evoking Shakespeare’s growing confidence and gnawing doubts.’ He concluded: ‘It’s diverting enough, but ultimately toothless.’

Alice Saville of The Independent took a balanced view about Ncuti Gatwa: ‘Gatwa revels in his role to an almost distracting degree: brandishing an implausibly long feathered quill, making an Olympics-worthy leap across the stage, and baring his gleaming chest. It’s all incredibly enjoyable. But what he doesn’t do is bare his soul, or show the inner torment of a man so obsessed with power and political intrigue that he’ll sacrifice everything else, even his happiness.’ And about the play: ‘It sings with all the sex and politics and religious iconoclasm that the bard handled so carefully in his plays, showing that every literary choice he made was freighted with danger. What it doesn’t do is show the emotional cost of living in this world. And that makes it hard to get deeply invested in this impossible literary love story, however intriguing its twists and turns might be.’

The Times’ Clive Davis found: ‘You wait in vain for this Marlowe to acquire some nuance when he flirts with Edward Bluemel’s ingenuous Will’.  For all its literary references, ‘At its heart, though, it hovers at the level of conscientiously researched fan fiction.’ He was not amused: ‘the attempts at humour soon begin to pall. Each line lands with the same thudding note, so much so that, halfway through, I found myself harbouring nostalgic memories of the much more deft wit of Ben Elton’s Shaftesbury Avenue version of Upstart Crow.’

2 stars

Dominic Maxwell at The Sunday Times couldn’t wait for it to end: ‘Born with Teeth is the kind of night at the theatre I like least: it’s too good in its execution to simply dismiss, too pointless for me not to long for it to end.’

Critics’ average rating: 3.5⭑

Value rating 37 (Value rating is the Average Critic Rating divided by the typical ticket price.)

Born With Teeth can be seen at Wyndham’s Theatre until 1  November 2025.  Buy tickets directly from the theatre

If you’ve seen Born With Teeth at Wyndham’s Theatre, please share your review and rating below

Theatre reviews roundup: The Gathered Leaves

A well acted, old fashioned family saga

Park200
Richard Stirling and Chris Larkin in The Gathered Leaves. Photo: Rich Southgate

The Gathered Leaves seems to have been missed by some of the heavyweight media amidst all the reporting from the Edinburgh Fringe. I admit I missed its opening, but here’s a belated roundup of the limited number of reviews. The critics praised both the acting and Adrian Noble’s direction in this revival of Andrew Keatley’s family saga. Despite it being only ten years old, many felt the play was old fashioned (not always a bad thing) and a little too long.

[Links to full reviews are included but a number are behind paywalls and therefore may not be accessible]

4 stars ⭑⭑⭑⭑

The Standard‘s Nick Curtis declared: ‘It’s an old-fashioned and at times schematic family saga that nonetheless treats its multiple themes with seriousness and care and eventually exerts a cumulative power…Adrian Noble’s elegant revival is peopled with thoroughbred stage actors, who plough determinedly through the boggier bits of dialogue and exposition.’

Louise Penn for BroadwayWorld found: ‘Keatley’s writing rewards his starry cast in every line. The length of the play (2hr 20 of performance) allows storylines to shape and realities to be revealed. Director Adrian Noble and designer Dick Bird allow the beautifully realised set to spread beyond the confines of the stage, spilling out onto the sidelines and into the audience.’

3 stars ⭑⭑⭑

Miriam Sallon for WhatsOnStage claimed: ‘It’s not that Keatley’s writing isn’t sharp and witty, and at times insightful. It’s that it could have been excellent, and instead, he’s settled for something closer to fine.’

Over on TheArtsDesk, Rachel Halliburton wrote: ‘Dick Bird’s fastidiously observed design in beiges and pale greens sets the scene for emotional daggers in the drawing room.’ She ended: ‘You emerge from this play simultaneously feeling as if you’ve taken a gentle walk back in time and thankful that the world has moved on. Keatley’s script holds up well enough, but it’s Noble’s subtle direction – in which the cast doesn’t strike one false emotional note – that gives the evening its pull.’

Holly O’Mahony at The Stage felt it could have done more: ‘While avoiding melodrama is no bad thing, this staid story craves a s midge more disrepute.’

Alan Fitter at LondonTheatre1 had some thoughts about the set: ‘A special mention should go to Dick Bird’s set which is startling. The walls go all the way up to the ceiling of the auditorium, some 25 feet or so, with picture rails, architraves and cornices – just like the walls of a grand house would be. However, it does look as if most of the budget has been spent on the walls, as the furniture in the very grand house is sparce and quite cheap looking – not what you’d expect.’ He concluded: ‘The Gathered Leaves is interesting, if a little old-fashioned and long …What makes it work and what’s at the heart of Keatley’s play is that, amidst all the angst of a family in disarray, is the love and humanity of two brothers who will stick together whatever life throws at them.’

Critics’ Average Rating 3.3⭑

The Gathered Leaves can be seen at Park200 until 20 September 2025. Buy tickets direct from the theatre

If you’ve seen The Gathered Leaves at @sohoplace, please add your review and rating below

Theatre reviews roundup: Juniper Blood

Conflicting views over play about clashes

Donmar warehouse
Hattie Morahan & Sam Troughton Juniper Blood. Photo: Helen Murray

Despite the mixed reception to Unicorn, his play advocating the merits of a menage-a-trois as an alternative to the traditional couple, Mike Bartlett continues to push radical re-thinking in his latest play. This time he explores farming and the land. A couple played by Sam Troughton and Hattie Morahan consider extreme living off the grid. Many ecological and generational debates are explored, with a state of the nation motif running through it. It was too didactic for some critics but others liked the challenge. Most found it funny. If you want to read a thoroughly positive review, go to Sarah Crompton’s at WhatsOnStage. Her customary insight and meticulous detail make her one of our best reviewers. For the polar opposite point of view, try the damning review from Clive Davis in The Times.

[Links to full reviews are included but a number are behind paywalls and therefore may not be accessible]

4 stars ⭑⭑⭑⭑

WhatsOnStage’s Sarah Crompton called it ‘a questing, knotty, philosophical piece, often circular and didactic but always utterly gripping as the arguments twist and turn. Juniper Blood does exactly what theatre has always done: offers a forum for debate, lining up the arguments with a clarity and courage that is rare.’ As for the set, ‘Designer Ultz has turned the Donmar into a patch of the countryside, with a living bank of grass surrounding a wooden platform.’ She concluded : ‘It has the feeling of being ancient myth and a report from the front line. It is utterly absorbing.’

The Telegraph’s Dominic Cavendish reassured us: ‘Although Juniper Blood suffers from some trowelled-on exposition, Bartlett’s ability to dig deep into a rich subject with flair and wit is again to the fore.’ ‘Hattie Morahan and Sam Troughton lead the small cast, superbly, as a flaky middle-aged couple making a go of it as “permaculture” farmers in north-west Oxfordshire, forging a sustainable life in the sticks. Think Chekhov meets Clarkson…Bartlett’s asking if something more radical is needed.’

Aleks Sierz at The Arts Desk found it ‘more cerebral than emotional’. He decided ‘The main problem with the play is that the deadlock between its conflicting ideas is never really resolved in a satisfying way…Nevertheless, for all its imperfections, this is a compelling evening mainly because of James Macdonald’s directing and the acting of his cast. Macdonald’s production has the vibe of hyperrealism.’

3 stars ⭑⭑⭑

The Guardian’s Arifa Akbar had reservations: ‘The cast give excellent performances and the action is intriguing, the arguments holding us, but the story in itself seems contrived around the play’s ideas.’ However, ‘Despite its lecturing and trowel-load of ideas, it is compelling and ambitious, Chekhovian in glimmers. Bartlett masterfully weds levity through social satire with complexity and depth of subject matter.’

Holly O’Mahony popped up at Time Out with an equivocal review: the ‘production directed by Barlett’s regular collaborator James Macdonald is really very funny. But for a play that holds a mirror up to the gaping chasm between idealism and pragmatism, it has some disparities of its own. Though rivetingly performed all round, several characters become wildly different people between its three acts, while its form is slippery too.’

For Marianka Swain at LondonTheatre ‘There are keen observations here and sharply witty lines, but rather than developing the characters’ inner lives’.

Adam Bloodworth at CityAM took a similar line: ‘Bartlett’s writing, as it always has been, is often funny, though too much of the script feels didactic. The talk about tech solutions to climate problems, and idealism versus pragmatism, starts to feel a little too on-the-nose and gets a bit dreary.’

Mary Beer for LondonTheatre1 summarised: ‘As a showcase for a thoroughly brilliant cast, including younger faces to watch, Juniper Blood succeeds.  With some decent bits of theatrically and a winning set by ULTZ along with some zinging lines, there is pleasure to be found in taking in this play.  But it is not fresh or revelatory or frankly remotely important or urgent despite the themes that underpin it.

After a long analysis at BroadwayWorld, Cindy Marcolina summed up her review regally: ‘It generates enough of a conversation to get you going, but is it Bartlett at his best? We don’t think so.’

2 stars ⭑⭑

The Times’ Clive Davis had no time for it, calling it ‘a maddeningly self-indulgent play of ideas, tosses around one half-formed notion after another…you sit there, gazing at the mound of turf on the set, wondering who thought this script was worth inflicting on the audience at the Donmar’.

The Standard’s Nick Curtis was of the same mind: ‘the play itself feels thin and undercooked, the plot twists and emotional revelations unearned. Every character is underwritten’.

Sam Marlowe’s review in The Stage was also dismissive: ‘Static, effortful and irredeemably verbose, it pits its dislikeable characters against one another in a series of overworked debates…James Macdonald’s rather languid production…fails to inject Bartlett’s contrivances with much nuance or urgency.’

Juniper Blood can be seen at the Donmar Warehouse until 4 October 2025. Click here to buy tickets directly from the theatre  

Critics’ average rating 3.0⭑

If you’ve seen Juniper Blood at the Donmar, please add your review and rating below

Theatre reviews roundup: Twelfth Night or What You Will

‘Joyous’ or ‘empty’?

Shakespeare’s Globe
Twelfth at Shakespeare’s Globe. Photo: Helen Murray

Carnival’ and ‘carnivalesque’ were words that cropped up frequently in reviews of Twelfth Night at The Globe. However there were contrasting views on Robin Belfield’s production (‘joyous’ vs ‘empty’, ‘strongest rapport with an audience’ vs ‘may try a little too hard to engage the crowd’), the performances (Ronkẹ Adékọluẹ́jọ́ as Viola gives a ‘delicious central performance’ or needs to play the part  ‘with more depth’), and the design. Take from them what you will.

[Links to full reviews are included but a number are behind paywalls and therefore may not be accessible]

4 stars ★★★★

There was a rare but welcome review from Dzifa Benson in the Telegraph. With her usual perspicacity she analysed the gender themes of the play and how the production exploits them before praising the actors and concluding: ‘this summer jamboree is riotous fun and joyfully tongue-in-cheek’.

Rachel Halliburton for The Times liked the way ‘in Robin Belfield’s joyous, kaleidoscopically coloured production, Quigley makes (Malvolio’s) humiliation in love every bit as resonant as the gender-swapping romances of the main characters.’ She said: ‘Amid the prevailing colourful whirligig, this is the production’s darkly beating heart.’

Dave Fargnoli for The Stage stated: ‘Belfield’s production never lets us forget that a dangerous current of lust and cruelty lurks beneath the whimsical frivolity.’ He was not alone in praising the design: ‘The bold aesthetics of Jean Chan’s gorgeous costumes are integral to evoking the play’s weird world and marking shifts in the characters’ emotional states.’

The Standard’s Nick Curtis said: ‘Inclusion and exclusion are the keynotes of Robin Belfield’s carnivalesque production of Shakespeare’s play, which features a delicious central performance from as Viola. The cast build what’s possibly the strongest rapport with an audience that I’ve ever felt at the Globe and the comedy is delightfully on point.’

3 stars

Matt Wolf for LondonTheatre disagreed with The Standard (above) about Ronkẹ Adékọluẹ́jọ́, finding that ‘this fine performer only intermittently lands the passion and pathos that help drive the play forward’. He also disagreed about the rapport with the audience: ‘The production may try a little too hard to engage the crowd in a vapid clap-along’. However he was impressed by ‘Jos Vantyler’s beautifully spoken (and danced), Harlequinade-adjacent Feste’ who ‘steers an expert course through the contrasting shores of the sublime and the sad between which this play navigates.’

Time Out’s Andrzej Lukowski was unimpressed: ‘Robin Belfield’s production falls into a very Globe-ish trap of having a lot of fun individual turns but failing to really cohere into a whole that makes much sense. And the lack of set changes leaves it without any sense of place, just groups of characters mucking about in front of Jean Chan’s unhelpfully abstract sun-ray set design.’

Clementine Scott for BroadwayWorld felt ‘Belfield’s direction too often allows the complex, gender-bending love triangle between Viola (in disguise as ‘Cesario’), Olivia and Orsino to play second fiddle to the Saturnalian slapstick.’ To support this view, she pointed out: ‘it’s a shame that our audience avatar, Viola (Ronkẹ Adékọluẹ́jọ), the only character who’s experiencing this fantasy world for the first time alongside us, isn’t played with more depth.’ She conceded: ‘This production might not probe Twelfth Night’s nuances as far as it could, but even the most hardened critic can’t resist the serotonin hit.’

2 stars ★

The Guardian’s Arifa Akbar summed up: ‘A period-dress production with passing modern-day asides, it is extremely knockabout, steering away from the play’s anguished layers.’ She explained: ‘You do not feel the pangs of unrequited desire, and much of the verse is dampened by unremarkable delivery in general.’ For her, Malvolio was ‘ almost loveably crabby’ and his ‘gulling never enters the realm of the tragic’. It was, she said, ‘a baggy production whose japery spills into messiness, leaving some plot points opaque.’

Alun Hood at WhatsOnStage was disappointed: ‘Belfield certainly rips through the play with commendable pace and attack, but the overall lack of subtlety or real emotion robs this entrancing comedy of much of its magic. When the majority of the characters are reduced to clownish ciphers, it’s pretty hard to care about them and that ultimately renders this Twelfth Night, for all its freewheeling irreverence and high energy revelry, a disappointingly empty experience.’

Critics’ average rating 3.2★

Twelfth Night can be seen at Shakespeare’s Globe until 25 October 2025. Buy tickets directly from shakespearesglobe.com

Theatre reviews roundup: Brigadoon

Romantic dance but silly musical

Open Air Theatre, Regent’s Park
Brigadoon at the Open Air Theatre

Lerner & Loewe’s Brigadoon is rarely seen, and for good reason thought quite a few of the critics. Even though Rona Munro had updated the book to make it more authentically Scottish and changing the visitors from lost tourists to crash-landing World War 2 pilots, they still found the plot about a village that only appears every hundred years somewhat silly. Other reviewers were carried away by the romance, Drew McOnie’s choreography and the look of the production.

[Links to full reviews are included but a number are behind paywalls and therefore may not be accessible]

4 stars ⭑⭑⭑⭑

It put LondonTheatre’s Marianka Swain in a romantic mood . She reported that it ‘has been ingeniously and gloriously revamped by director-choreographer Drew McOnie and Scottish playwright Rona Munro. Why, it’s almost like being in love.’ She laid responsibility clearly at McConie’s dancing feet: ‘McOnie’s detailed production balances (a) poetic, psychologically rich reading of Brigadoon with a realistic, lived-in village.’ She continued: ‘McOnie’s choreography is absolutely knockout. He embraces the lush romanticism by evoking Agnes De Mille’s lyrical Golden Age dances, and incorporates Scottish folk like a reel and sword dance (we also get accompanying bagpipes), while also infusing the whole thing with thrilling, contemporary expressiveness’.

Holly O’Mahony for The Stage was also impressed, although perhaps not as much as Marianka: ‘it’s charmingly whimsical.’ It is, she said, ‘a tight, traditional production – winningly so – with Agnes De Mille’s original dances interwoven with McOnie’s sprightly ballets’. She also noted: ‘Sami Fendall’s costumes of rustic tartan in meadowy shades of yellow and green’ and ‘Basia Bińkowska’s atmospheric set’.

’The show is delightful’ wrote Claire Allfree for the Telegraph. She found: ‘McOnie’s production retains Brigadoon’s old-fashioned MGM musical quality with beautifully choreographed Oklahoma!-style scenes of swirling village women in full skirts and lace-up boots, and men merrily loading wagons with milk churns, images that knowingly lean into the idea of the art form itself as escapism incarnate.’

WhatsOnStage’s Sarah Crompton declared: ‘It is a truly magical evening. Drew McOnie’s…production…has a shining clarity of purpose. With the help of a book by Rona Munro that keeps the emotion but strips away the sentiment, the production sweeps along on a wave of luscious songs’.

Fiona Mountford at the i is a fan of Brigadoon (‘a tune-stuffed delight’) and thought Drew McOnie’s production did it proud: ‘a sumptuous spectacle of movement’.

3 stars ⭑⭑⭑

For Aliya Al-Hassan at BroadwayWorld, ‘the production feels like an odd choice for a revival. The characters are thinly drawn, the plot bizarre and uneven and the musical numbers are just not memorable. Much of the mawkishness of the romance has been stripped back, but it still feels a little cloying.’ Although she did admit: ‘The ensemble bounds with energy and their movement is as beautiful as you would expect from McConie.’

The Standard’s Nick Curtis was reserved, saying it ‘just about works thanks to some fine performances, spirited choreography and a strikingly effective Grand Designs set by Basia Bińkowska. But it’s an effort to tough your way through the more saccharine moments.’  His review is an amusing read for its list of holes in the plot.

The Independent’s Alice Saville called it ‘a strange fable that feels out of step with the times, however beguiling its dance may be.’ She acknowledged Mcconie ‘lovingly recreates and reimagines golden age Hollywood choreographer Agnes de Mille’s balletic sequences of yearning and skittish flirtation. Lerner and Loewe’s score is sumptuously romantic, too, and beautifully rendered here by a sizeable orchestra placed centre stage.’ But in the end, ‘no amount of sylvan magic can hide the fact that this is a very, very silly kind of story.’

The Times‘ Clive Davis acknowledged the changes to the story but felt ‘The results are less sentimental, but still haven’t solved the problem of how to inject pace, not to mention plausibility, into a meandering book…we’re left trying to keep track of a tangled narrative’.  He did like many other aspects of the show: ‘The dozen or so musicians led by the MD Laura Bangay generate just the right mixture of velvet and tartan… Basia Binkowska’s diagonal set design, which evokes the stark timber lines of a Frank lloyd Wright house, is topped by an assortment  of heather shimmering under Jessica Hung Han Yun’s subtle lighting.’

2 stars ⭑⭑

The Guardian’s Arifa Akbar called it a ‘too tame, too purposeless revival seems simply to be a love letter to Scotland with bagpipes and drumming galore’. On the plus side: ‘The cast is filled with strong singers…but the songs sound anodyne and generic…McOnie’s choreography is beautiful and balletic in itself’.

Critics’ average rating 3.4⭑

Brigadoon can be seen at the Open Air Theatre until 20 September 2025.  Buy tickets directly from the theatre

If you’ve seen Brigadoon at the Open Air Theatre, please share your review and rating below

 

Theatre reviews roundup: Every Brilliant Thing

A Brilliant Show

@sohoplace
Lenny Henry in Every Brilliant Thing at @sohoplace. Photo: Helen Murray

After over ten years of performing in the UK and around the world, Every Brilliant Thing by Duncan Macmillan and Jonny Donahoe finally made its West End debut, and the critics were delighted. The solo show will star Minnie Driver, Sue Perkins, Ambika Mod, and Jonny Donahoe over the next few weeks, but the run started with a much appreciated Lenny Henry in charge.

When a mother attempts suicide when she has acute depression, her child decides to make a list about all the things that make life worth living. They  keep adding to the list as they move through adolescence into adulthood.

[Links to full reviews are included but a number are behind paywalls and therefore may not be accessible]

5 stars ⭑⭑⭑⭑⭑

Ke Meng for TheatreWeekly was impressed that ‘Macmillan’s writing is both endearing and nostalgic, a feeling I haven’t encountered in ages. His language is equally funny and poetic’. She said: ‘Lenny Henry masters the space as if it’s his own living room—chilled, playful, and chatty.’

Marianka Swain reviewing for the Telegraph was uplifted: ‘the communal storytelling format remains a neat demonstration of the play’s central thesis: it’s vital to reach out and connect with one another, whether through therapy or theatre. This life-affirming show proves that and more – an absolute tonic.’ As for Lenny Henry, she found it ‘enormous fun watching him take charge of the intimate, in-the-round @sohoplace auditorium and roll with the punches.

4 stars ⭑⭑⭑⭑

The Standard‘s Nick Curtis described it as ‘a unique show with the texture of theatre but the communal immediacy of stand-up.’ He found Lenny Henry was perfectly suited: ‘Thanks to his pre-thespian career in comedy, his natural bonhomie and the indulgence granted to him as a bona fide national treasure, Henry manages the crowd and the pivots of mood adroitly.’ He declared ‘the auditorium of @sohoplace, with its uncluttered intimacy, suits the material perfectly’

In her review for Time Out, Anya Ryan took a different view of the venue: ‘With a much greater capacity and the audience spread across three tiers, creating the world of the play feels less like a communal endeavour and more the responsibility of a select few.’ However, she added: ‘If there’s any larger venue fit to house Macmillan’s mini masterpiece, it is @sohoplace.’ She concluded: ‘For all its sorrow, the play gleams with hope. It is a truly brilliant thing.’

Fiona Mountford at the i reported: ‘Jeremy Herrin’s appealing production plays to Henry’s many strengths – twinkling with joy and mischief, he exudes an affable affinity with the audience from the get-go. This rapport is all-important, as we are integral to the action…Our fellow spectators, with all their quirks and idiosyncrasies, are delightful in their contributions’.

Helen Hawkins, sitting on The Arts Desk, thought: ‘Henry is a natural for this assignment, still a livewire performer (watch him fly as he listens to his favourite bongos solo), but warm and accessible, a born communicator and improviser who can coax even the shyest person to deliver.’ She declared: ‘In its decision to balance grief and glee and not to allow one to exclude the other, this is a clear-sighted, heartening show.’

Dave Fargnoli in The Stage described Lenny Henry’s technique: ‘Lenny Henry demonstrated his consummate facility for building a rapport with an audience through a mix of playful mockery and easy-going warmth. Henry owns the part, filling out the narrator’s character with precise personal detail. When he plays a taciturn father, a hint of a gruff Jamaican accent creeps in. When he’s representing a child, his words become clipped, shy, hesitant. There is always a smile or a wince about to break out on his face, a hitch in his voice as he prepares to share some melancholy memory.’

Holly O’Mahony at LondonTheatre compared Lenny Henry’s version to the original: ‘While there’s plenty of warmth and humour to it, I felt a depth missing. Watching Donahoe perform the part, it truly felt like his story, his depression. This version never quite plumbs those depths, and the plot is held aloof, as if secondary to the audience participation. Yet what Henry pulls off is no small feat – as a collective, participatory experience, it’s really quite brilliant.’

3 stars ⭑⭑⭑

Miriam Gillinson reported for The Guardian that ‘there’s something about the scale and downright snazziness of this production that doesn’t quite gel’ and found ‘It’s only when Henry isn’t trying to be funny that the show settles. There’s a stillness and steeliness to him when he talks about the importance of protecting our mental health.’

At BroadwayWorld, Alexander Cohen found ‘Where other performers have leaned into the childlike innocence of the narrator, Henry opts instead for something heavier. Memories are explored with emotional clarity rather than nostalgic whimsy, a choice that lends this iteration a quiet gravity that avoids sentimentality.’

Critics’ average rating: 4.0⭑

Every Brilliant Thing can be seen at @sohoplace until 8 November 2025. Click here to buy tickets directly from the theatre

If you’ve seen Every Brilliant Thing at @sohoplace, please add your review and rating below

 

 

Theatre reviews roundup: Good Night, Oscar with Sean Hayes

A Very Good Night with Sean Hayes

Barbican Theatre
Good Night, Oscar at The Barbican. Photo: Johan Persson

With a couple of exceptions, the critics loved Good Night, Oscar. Plays don’t always travel well across the Atlantic, even a big hit like this, and, as the 2 and 3 star reviews pointed out, the subject of the play, Oscar Levant, is not well known over here and author Doug Wright doesn’t enlighten us. Also, the true story of how this musician-comedian-actor-raconteur was temporarily released from a psychiatric hospital to appear (and be exploited) on a popular TV show may seem very American. However, the 5 and 4 star reviews acclaimed one of the performances of the year by Sean Hayes in bringing the troubled artist to life.

5 stars ⭑⭑⭑⭑⭑

For Gary Naylor at BroadwayWorld it was the Sean Hayes show: ‘He simply inhabits the part. There’s the desperate vulnerability of the addict, the ticks that speak of a roiling mind, the ruthless exploitation of the decency of others. But there’s also the speed of the wit, the grudging willingness to do the right thing, the sheer chutzpah of the man. Most of all, and this elevates the  performance to the very best of any I’ve seen, there’s the charisma – Levant’s and Hayes’ – that bounces around this large house like a laser show.’

LondonTheatre’s Julia Rank also praised him: ‘Hayes…has the hangdog expression and an abundance of tics and twitches… To make the casting even more ideal, Hayes trained as a pianist before becoming an actor and plays a rendition of “Rhapsody in Blue” that’s essentially a nervous breakdown on the piano.’ She was one of many who complemented the set design: ‘Rachel Hauck provides a series of mid-century modern sets, the piece de resistance being a soundstage with sound-absorbent walls that could double as a padded cell. What is television if not another madhouse, one of the characters notes.’

Chris Omaweng at LondonTheatre1 called it ‘A delightful, memorable and charming night out.’

4 stars ⭑⭑⭑⭑

Dave Fargnoli in The Stage liked the writing: ‘Through a series of focused, fast-paced scenes, the play touches on themes of artistic integrity, the exploitation of performers and drug addiction.’ And he liked the production: ‘Director Lisa Peterson gives the production a slick, effective staging, conveying both the exhilarating momentum and crushing time pressure of a live broadcast’. And he definitely liked the star: ‘Sean Hayes gives a consummate, larger-than-life performance as Oscar, channelling a profoundly unsettled, manic energy’.

Helen Hawkins at The Arts Desk was also taken with the star: Hayes gives an impeccable physical performance, one part or another of his body constantly in motion, a jiggling foot, a rocking upper body. After he downs a bottle of Demerol, he makes his body move in slo-mo, each casual gesture attenuated. His features are unrecognisable as fresh-faced Jack’s, drawn and haggard, like a mournful spaniel’s. He pratfalls and slumps and tumbles.‘

Tom Wicker for Time Out commented: ‘Hayes is extraordinary as Levant, crumpling into himself even as he makes the one-liners prompted by Paar sing off the stage. His well-honed way with comedy is the play’s secret weapon. Our laughter is complicit in the implosion we know is happening.’

The Standard’s Nick Curtis wrote about Sean Hayes: ‘Doug Wright’s play is a fast-paced, highly polished, zinger-packed vehicle for his astonishing performance, which culminates in an electrifyingly expressive live rendition of Rhapsody in Blue’.

Ben Dowell in The Times noted: ‘What sets this dazzling, considered Tony award-winning Broadway transfer apart is the fantastically energised performance from Sean Hayes… (He) puts the versatility and high-octane physicality that fans of that show will know to brilliant use, timing Levant’s sizzling wordplay…smoking furiously, anguish written on every twist of his face.’ He was impressed by the director: ‘Lisa Peterson snaps sure-footedly through the action, while allowing the tender moments to breathe’.

Alun Hood for WhatsOnStage concluded: ‘Inevitably, Good Night, Oscar won’t resonate with British audiences as keenly as with their American counterparts…but this remains a waspish, compulsive, meticulously well-crafted piece of theatre. Hayes’s brilliance elevates it into a must-see.’

3 stars ⭑⭑⭑

The Independent’s Alice Saville accused the play of ‘delivering a glimmering, beguiling surface without looking too hard at what’s going on underneath’ while acknowledging ‘Sean Hayes drenches this role in pathos and awkward brilliance’.

Mark Lawson for The Guardian commented: ‘Hayes gives a performance of such busyness – twitches, tics, lip curls, cigarette business – that you wonder if the stage has a fast-forward button. He also, in the moment that surely guaranteed his Tony award, delivers the piano climax live at a Steinway with exceptional panache. Lisa Peterson’s slick, whizzy production, co-starring Rosalie Craig as Levant’s wife June, is a thrilling theatrical experience but, perhaps perversely for a play arguing for television to be more serious, does not bear looking at too closely.’

2 stars ⭑⭑

Fiona Mountford writing for the Telegraph complained: ‘we leave this 100-minute play no wiser as to the real man behind this troubled facade. Although we understand that Wright has serious points to make about the shifting morality of what is served up in the name of ratings and entertainment, we cannot help but feel a little bit grubby.’

Critics’ average rating 3.9⭑

Value Rating 27

Good night, Oscar can be seen at The Barbican until 21 September 2025. Buy tickets  directly from the theatre

If you’ve seen Good Night, Oscar, please leave a review and your rating below

Review: A Midsummer Night’s Dream at The Bridge

Immersed in shallow water


⭑⭑⭑

JJ Feild & Emmanuel Akwafo in A Midsummer Night’s Dream at The Bridge Theatre. Photo: Manuel Harlan

The Bridge Theatre’s immersive production of A Midsummer Night’s Dream is tremendous fun. Then again, I recently spent the day at Peppa Pig World, and that was a lot of fun too. For me the question is, is The Bridge’s Dream more than a party? Of course I could ask, do we need an excuse to enjoy a joyous night out inside one of our favourite theatres?

Before I go on, let me be clear: Nicholas Hytner’s production A Midsummer Night’s Dream was better theatre than Peppa Pig World. The acting including J J Feild as Oberon, Susannah Fielding as Titania, David Moorst as Puck and Emmanuel Akwafo as Bottom was excellent; Bunny  Christie’s bed-strewn set and Christina Cunningham’s costumes were wondrous; Arlene Phillips’ movement, and the effects, the lighting and the sound were the best you could hope for. Even so, it felt like being immersed in shallow water.

I have no doubt that creating a pseudo anarchy is in the spirit of Shakespeare’s play. Faeries fly above you, characters appear and disappear all over the place, while you are being moved this way and that wondering where the action will erupt next.  And yes, swapping the lines of Oberon and Titania sets up even more laughs as the King of the Fairies falls in love with an ass.

And there are lots of laughs, not only the predictable humour of  the Rude Mechanicals, but also from everyone else as a punk-like Puck unleashes mayhem. Lysander loses his trousers, there are accidental gay encounters, modern phrases enliven the Elizabethan text.

A Midsummer Night’s Dream at The Bridge Theatre. Photo: Manuel Harlan

The problem for me is, what is lost when everything becomes an excuse for a laugh or a party is an involvement in the characters and their fate. There is little sense of a major theme of the play- what happens to people’s emotions when their world is turned upside down. In every production I’ve seen until now, the Athenian women are genuinely upset when their lovers swap affection, the King of the Fairies, or Queen in this case, shows remorse at the effect of their magic.

I had the same feeling when I saw Punchdrunk’s The Burnt City. The feeling of wonder at what I was seeing, and the almost thrill of being lost as I stumbled into the mixed up scenes was fantastic, but I didn’t give a jot about the Greek tragedy that was unfolding.

Guys And Dolls, another immersive production at The Bridge, worked, for me, because, no matter how impressive the fluidity of the set was, the characters, book and music were allowed to speak for themselves. So, no matter how much the audience were lost in the action, we never lost ourinvolvement in the love stories.

I can see why for many critics it was a 5 star party. Sharing laughter is good for us, and I would totally recommend getting one of the not-very-expensive promenade tickets. But when I go to the theatre, I am also expecting to come out changed, if only a little bit, by what I have experienced, and on this occasion I wasn’t.

A Midsummer Night’s Dream can be seen at The Bridge Theatre until 20 August 2025. Buy tickets directly from the theatre

Paul paid for his ticket

Click here to watch this review on the YouTube channel Theatre Reviews With Paul Seven

Click here to read Paul’s roundup of other critics’ reviews of A Midsummer Night’s dream at The Bridge Theatre

Review: Intimate Apparel

Powerful play about women in a man’s world

⭑⭑⭑⭑⭑

Samira Wiley & Claudia Jolly in Intimate Apparel. Photo: Helen Murray

The intimate apparel in question is a corset which back in 1905 when this play is set, helped women present to the outside world a body shape that conformed with that era’s restrictive standard of female beauty. But corsets aren’t the only deception going on in Lynn Nottage’s twisty play. Intimate Apparel shows us women faking it in a man’s world, while revealing their intimate feelings about their lives to each other when the disguise is off. At times, it is so believable, you forget you’re watching actors. This despite a minimal set and an audience on three sides.

It’s a play centred on women’s place in society at a time when black people were emerging from slavery and only men had the vote. The central character is Esther played by Samira Wiley. She is a black 35 year old unmarried seamstress who makes the intimate apparel of the title. She is shy and self deprecating about her looks. Her lack of confidence has kept her away from a social life, until she is now 35, has never had sex, and is effectively ‘on the shelf’. It is a monumental piece of acting, mixing downtrodden subservience with naive optimism, that totally convinces.

Esther’s clients are her world: they are quasi friends despite the difference in status. A motherly Mrs Dickson played by Nicola Hughes owns a boarding house in which Esther rents a room; Mrs Van Buren (Claudia Jolly) is a brittle white woman with a rich husband who neglects her; Mayme played with panache by Faith Omole achieves her independence through prostitution.

In a lesser play, these characters might be two dimensional ciphers representing different types of women in that society. We are told very little about their backgrounds or personal lives but Lyn Nottage’s special skill is to know her characters so well that every word they speak seems coated with the truth of a fully formed human being. It helps that these talented actors are there to inhabit the carefully created characters and give them a three dimensional reality.

The high quality of the acting extends to the two male characters- Kadiff Kirwan swaggers and whines as George, the kind of man who has never grown up, and Alex Waldmann gives a touching performance as the gentle, humorous Mr Marks, a haberdasher who is genuinely attracted to Esther and a would be a perfect match for her, but is held back by a religious faith that prevents him having physical contact with women outside his family.

Intimate Apparel at The Donmar. Photo: Helen Murray

When Esther gets a letter out of the blue from a man looking for a pen pal, the other women encourage her to respond. Because she can neither read nor write, they pursue the correspondence on her behalf until a remote love affair takes place and Esther accepts a marriage proposal without ever having met her fiancé.

So, a marriage has been built on something every bit as fake as the bodies created by intimate apparel. Might it still work out or will Esther’s world come crashing down? That’s the subject of the second act.  I’d love to talk about what happens but it would be unfair to spoil the dramatic twists and revelations which actually provoked gasps from the audience- an indication of how involved we were. Credit to director Lynette Linton for the romantic build-up that drew us in and the explosive pinball machine speed with which it blew up in our faces.

Alex Berry’s set used the cramped space of the Donmar well- key props like a bed and sewing machine nimbly moving around while the male characters appeared from high up at the back like Gods. Her costumes were fabulous and I assume accurate representations of the clothes- and underwear- of the period.

Intimate Apparel can be seen at the Donmar theatre until 9 August 2025. Buy tickets direct from the theatre.

Paul paid for his ticket.

Watch this review on the YouTube channel Theatre Reviews With Paul Seven

 

×