Review: Ruth Wilson & Michael Shannon in A Moon For The Misbegotten

A long evening lit up by Ruth Wilson

Almeida Theatre


⭑⭑⭑⭑⭑

Ruth Wilson & Michael Shannon in A Moon For The Misbegotten. Photo: Marc Brenner

I admit there were moments when I thought Eugene O’Neill’s A Moon For The Misbegotten could hurry I up a bit but I came to appreciate this is a play where every word- and the unspoken words- count, and I appreciated the way that director Rebecca Frecknall deliberately made space to let this time bomb of a play achieve its impact.

It’s a kind of sequel , or perhaps an epilogue, to A Long Day’s Journey Into Night. It features Jamie Tyrone, one of the sons from that play, now known as Jim, and refers to his late mother and father. He is landlord to Josie Hogan and her father Phil. He seems benign but Phil fears he will sell their farm, so hatches a plot by which Josie will seduce Jim and he will be forced to marry her. Which is ironic because they do actually desire one another.

At first Josie comes across as a confident, independent woman, able to handle herself and the men around her, including her cynical, mean father. Playing the part is Ruth Wilson, at first swaggering and fearless, striding confidently and literally wielding a big stick. But from the beginning we sense a brittleness behind the bravado. We also see she is selfless, and, as the play progresses, this aspect of her character manifests itself in her approach to Jim and Phil. The gradual cracking of the shell she has built around herself is shown by Ms Wilson in multiple small ways. She becomes increasingly tender, as she admits the truth about herself and sees the reality of others   It could be the acting performance of the year.

Michael Shannon’s Jim, an alcoholic, is clearly a broken man but a gentle one who seems to be drowning his sorrows not only in booze but in casual encounters with women. His falsetto laugh and sad face hint there is more to him than a drunken womaniser, and his deliberate movements are not only those of a bourbon-soaked body but also of a man who hates his own being. As he moves from destructive self hate to a kind of temporary redemption, a calm takes over his body.

Ruth Wilson & David Threlfall in A Moon For The Misbegotten. Photo: Marc Brenner

What emerges over the length of the play is a gradual peeling off of the images Josie and Jim project to cover their insecurity and the discovery of the reasons they feel vulnerable, which are very much tied up with their parents- hence the ‘misbegotten’ of the title.

There are wrong assumptions and misunderstandings, especially over what they actually desire, and many moments in which there are two steps forward and one step backward, before a finale when their true feelings are laid bare. I called it a bomb earlier but I don’t want to imply the end is explosive- it’s softer and more moving than that, but there are some dramatic incidents on the way.

Rebecca Frecknall’s slow unwinding of the play would not be so mesmerising  without actors of the calibre of Ruth Wilson and Michael Shannon, not to mention the inimitable David Threlfall, who totally convinces as a wily old farmer whose twinkling eyes betray his love for his daughter.

Tom Scutt’s circular set, made of battered wood conveys the poverty of the farm business. Jack Knowles’ lighting design centres on a moving spot high up at the back of the stage which moves its beam across the scene and the characters. It powerfully represents a moon which witnesses and encourages their revelations.

Maybe O’Neill could have written a shorter play, but I wouldn’t want to mess in any way with this perfect production.

A Moon For The Misbegotten can be seen at the Almeida Theatre until 16 August 2025. Buy tickets direct from the theatre.

Paul paid for his ticket.

Watch this review on YouTube

Read a roundup of other critics’ reviews here

Theatre review: Top Hat at Chichester Festival Theatre

This summer’s musical treat

Chichester Festival Theatre


⭑⭑⭑⭑

Lucy St Louis & Phillip Attmore in Top Hat. Photo: Johan Persson

Every year I look forward to the Chichester Festival Theatre musical. Among the first class revivals of recent years have been Oliver!, South Pacific, Crazy For You with the incomparable Charlie Stemp, and Gypsy with Imelda Staunton. This year, they have chosen Top Hat, and, while it may not reach the heights of the aforementioned hits, it does not disappoint. There’s already an extensive UK tour booked for it, so you will have the chance to see for yourself.

Once again, Chichester have put together a mouth watering feast. Top Hat is primarily a tap dance show- it was written for Fred Astaire- and the dancing here is creme de la creme. Choreographed, as well as directed, by the great Kathleen Marshall, who was responsible for the London hit Anything Goes, the solo dances, the what you might call Fred and Ginger numbers and the chorus line work are all masterclasses in how it should be done. The sound of the tap is music in itself and 16 dancers or thereabouts combining to stamp the floor at the same time is explosive. The discipline, especially of the chorus lines, is genuinely awesome, as arm-in-arm they make a circular movement, all the while high kicking. Ms Marshall’s choreography is exuberant, uplifting and joyous.

A brief word about the story. A superstar tap dancer called Jerry falls in love with a woman called Dale but, owing to a misunderstanding, she thinks he’s his friend Horace, husband of her friend Madge. Spoiler alert- it all works out in the end.

Then there’s the music. Irving Berlin wrote 1500 songs throughout a long career but the five he wrote for the original film represent him at his peak and extending his ability to write songs that serve the story: No Strings establishes the carefree character of Jerry, as well as his prowess as a tap dancer; Isn’t This A Lovely Day starts with Jerry and Dale in a standoff but reveals her increasing attachment to him as the song progresses; Cheek To Cheek, the centrepiece of the musical, shows Jerry seducing Dale through the power of dance- a true representation of the saying ‘dance is the vertical expression of a horizontal desire, with climactic moments as he swings her through the air; and then there are the two big chorus line numbers Top Hat, White Tie And Tails and The Piccolino, which end the first act and begin the second in the stage version. All praise to Stephen Ridley and the 10 piece orchestra for their swinging sound.

Top Hat, released in cinemas in 1935, only became a stage musical in 2011 when it was adapted by Matthew White and Howard Jacques. There are many more Berlin tunes added, quite a few plundered from other Fred and Ginger movies, including Puttin’ On The Ritz, I’m Putting All My Eggs in One Basket, Let Yourself Go and Let’s Face The Music And Dance.

Top Hat at Chichester Festival Theatre. Photo: Johan Persson

The six principals are superb, and the ensemble is wonderful. The hardest task goes to Phillip Attmore. How to step into the shoes of Fred Astaire? Not to mention that the show itself refers to him as a world-class dancer. And, unlike the legendary star, he has to perform live. He may not quite be Fred Astaire (who is?) but he is a likeable lead and an accomplished dancer.

Lucy St Louis as Dale is the full package. She has a powerful singing voice, acts well and dances beautifully. For me she was a revelation, although I shouldn’t be surprised, because she’s already played Glinda in Wicked and Christine in The Phantom Of The Opera (you may have seen her perform at the Platinum Party At The Palace).

Clive Carter and Sally Ann Triplett as Horace and Madge provide a weight of experience and a huge dose of comedy. James Clyde as Horace’s servant Bates in various disguises, and Alex Gibson-Giorgio as Alberto, a comical Italian fashion designer and Dale’s would-be lover also keep the laughs coming. I know it’s no longer acceptable to make fun of foreigners who don’t speak English as well as us- ‘I am very displeased to meet you!’- but such lines were written a long time ago.

There is a great deal of funny lines, or perhaps corny jokes would be a better description. Here are a couple of examples: Horace is afraid of flying because the first word you see on signs at the airport is ‘Terminal’. He also explains that a man is incomplete until he’s married- ‘Then he’s finished.’ But that’s very much in the mood of this light comedy which, as I said, is about dance first, then music, and only then comedy to fill the gaps.

Peter McIntosh‘s luminous art deco set is very clever. The thrust stage is kept clear for dancing, although there are semi-circular rises.  At the back there is a revolve that swiftly takes us from one bedroom to another bedroom to a bar. He along with Yvonne Milnes also designed the costumes which have the loose, easy-going feel of the 1940s rather than slavishly copying the 1930s style of the film.

I left the auditorium on a high. Top Hat on stage may not have the wow factor of Crazy For You or Anything Goes. But then again there were no equivalent films to compare them with,  so it is disadvantaged by not being able to match  the perfection of the film. On the other hand, the fact that it is performed live, and you can see a group of supremely talented people right there in front of you creating beautiful, athletic, complex dance together to some of the greatest songs ever written, makes Top Hat at Chichester Festival Theatre, despite any imperfections,  a joy better than any flickering screen.

Top Hat can be seen at Chichester Festival Theatre until 6 September 2025. Buy tickets direct from the theatre

Paul was given a review ticket by the theatre.

Watch this review on YouTube

 

 

 

 

Reviews roundup: Inter Alia with Rosamund Pike

Tour de force from Rosamund Pike

Lyttelton at the national theatre / Wyndham’s Theatre
Rosamund Pike in Inter Alia. Photo: Manuel Harlan

Comparisons with Prima Facie abound in reviews for Inter Alia: same writer (Suzie Miller), same director (Justin Martin), and a major star playing a female lawyer specialising in rape cases (then Jodie Comer, now Rosamund Pike). The latter is universally praised for her performance as Judge Jessica, juggling marriage, motherhood and meting out justice to misogynists, before her life spirals out of control. Some critics found the plot predictable and preachy.

The production has transferred to the West End but not all media chose to review it twice. Some did but sent a different reviewer. The average rating was slightly higher from the West End reviewers.

[Links to full reviews are included but a number are behind paywalls and therefore may not be accessible]

Reviews of the West End transfer

5 stars ★★★★★

Clementine Scott for BroadwayWorld gave out top marks: ‘Pike is an inherently physical performer, and flaws in the script are glossed over by her constant bounding around the set, morphing from courtroom gravitas to dinner party femininity and back again.’ She pointed out: ‘it does more than simply present ethical dilemmas. At its heart is a compelling character study of a woman forced to be everything at once’.

4 stars ★★★★

WhatsOnStage‘s Sarah Crompton declared: ‘It is Pike’s play and Pike’s night, and she seizes it with such relish, whether belting out a karaoke number and downing shots with the girls before getting in a taxi exhausted at 9pm, or facing her worst fears of failure as a wife and mother. She is supremely witty and sharp, but also devastatingly exposed and tender.’

Caroline McGinn for Time Out noted: ‘Multitasking is the watchword for Justin Martin’s bold, high-energy production, which really relishes the plate-spinning scenario of working motherhood, sending Pike bouncing all over Miriam Buether’s wonderful set, a pistachio-green kitchen-diner whose cupboard doors pop open to supply the props needed for the various different aspects of her life: a slinky red husband-pleasing dress; her judge’s wig; a steaming iron; a tray of baked fish; a karaoke mic.’

Olivia Rook commented for LondonTheatre: ‘What Miller does so adeptly is explore the impossible burden often placed on women, specifically the task of protecting your child whilst honouring your own principles. Pike masterfully works her way through Miller’s demanding script, hurtling through the lines with precision from the moment she enters the stage, poised with a microphone in hand, as though ready to begin her opening set in a rock band. Her arena is her courtroom, and the fans, her jury.’

The Standard‘s Nick Curtis, who reviewed the production at The National, noted: ‘This transfer feels slightly tighter, the ending tweaked and the architecture of a West End playhouse pulling the story and Pike’s bravura central turn into closer focus.’

The Daily Mail’s Patrick was enthusiastic: ‘Marmion Pike’s one hour and 40 minute whirlwind of a performance, changing in and out of judge’s wig and robes and slipping into silk blouses and a scarlet cocktail dress, ensures we don’t get too much time for lateral thinking. It’s a gripping, socio-political railroad. Justin Martin’s production steams ahead, powered by Pike’s breathless performance’.

The Times’ Dominic Maxwell was more taken by the play than his colleague Clive Davis who reviewed the premiere: ‘Take this as a story about the wild challenge of balancing morality and legality, of protecting your children and letting them go, and you have something fine indeed. All rendered vivid by a remarkable central turn that is all action yet deeply felt.’

3 stars ★★★

Holly O’Mahony in The Stage was disappointed (although not as critical as her colleague Sam Marlowe last time out): ‘The play breathlessly unpicks its knotty moral conundrum, packaged in a style that grates. Pike’s Jess Parks is narrator as well as main character, and she describes her situation (high-flying career woman diminished to a doormat at home) and the events that befall her family (18-year-old son Harry gets accused of something life-shatteringly terrible) with so much exposition that it never scorches as it might.’

Critics’ average rating 4.0⭑

Value rating 42 (Value rating is the Average Critic Rating combined with the typical ticket price)

Inter Alia can be seen at Wyndham’s Theatre until 20 June 2026. Buy tickets directly from the theatre 

If you’ve seen Inter Alia, please share your comments, review and/or rating at the bottom of the page

Reviews of the National Theatre premiere

4 stars ★★★★

The Standard‘s Nick Curtis got straight to the point:  ‘Rosamund Pike gives a hectic, vital, riveting performance at the centre of Suzie Miller’s gut-punch of a play, as a judge, Jess Parks, who discovers that the toxic masculinity she sees in the courtroom has taken root in her own home’

As The Mail’s Patrick Marmion put it: ‘the wheels come off Jessica’s dream.’ He added: ‘The fact that we can see it coming a mile off simply adds to the sense of dread in Martin’s helter-skelter production’. Pike, he said, ‘blazes alone: multitasking in the kitchen and in her judge’s chambers, walking a mental tightrope and talking us through her 360-degree collapse.’

Emma John for The Guardian called it ‘a searing commentary on the justice system and a purposefully uncomfortable insight into contemporary parenting.‘ She had a reservation: ‘Determined to give every issue and angle a fair hearing, Inter Alia sheds its nimbleness and wit as it grapples with the serious stuff in its later stage’.

Dominic Cavendish of the Telegraph couldn’t stop thinking about Prima Facie: ‘the play revisits the emotive subject of sexual offences and how the law works, only this time involving teenagers. It grips, too, and is gut-wrenching, but in comparison feels sketchier’…’Once again, the piece calls for a transfixing, shape-shifting performance from its star, and the hurtling 105-minute action showcases Pike’s theatrical bravura’…’if the evening stirs debate about how one generation guides the next, how men should behave and how the culture can foster respect, safety and justice for women, it’s all to the good. Whether it will have the same impact of Prima Facie is open to question.’

About Rosamund Pike, Time Out‘s Andrzej Lukowski declared: ‘she is good: of course she’s posh, but she’s earthy, likeable, open, vulnerable, somewhat demystifying of her profession. And it’s not entirely unsubtle writing, just full tilt. We’re bouncing around in Jessica’s head, and being asked to consider that she is attempting to fulfil several impossible roles: neither the perfect mother nor the perfect judge really exist, and certainly not a seamless mix of the two.’ He ended: ‘Inter Alia is kind of a big performance lecture exploring a subject that is close to Miller’s heart to the point of artistic fixation. It is a contrivance that her plays concern women who are high up in the legal profession and thus able to clearly explain the mechanics of what’s going on. But once warmed up Inter Alia hits home thoughtfully and forcefully…Inter Alia benefits from a gale-force Pike and a sophisticated production from Martin – its final image will chill you to the bone.’

Lucinda Everett for WhatsOnStage enjoyed Rosamund Pike’s performance: ‘Pike streaks out of the blocks with just the right blend of possessed energy and blindsiding anxiety. Shimmying expertly in and out of clothes and roles, swapping judges’ gowns for aprons for dinner party dresses, she addresses the audience, actors and her courtroom in quick succession without misstep. The play keeps Jessica’s mental anguish close to the surface, as images from her cases and concerns about Harry (unpopular and often bullied) plague her…Pike also relishes a script which beautifully captures the singularity of motherhood – the beaming pride and protective fury, the pain of letting go, the seesaw of smugness and shame – as well as the effect Jessica’s job has had on her parenting.’

Alice Saville of The Independent was bowled over by all aspects of the evening: ‘Inter Alia’s impact builds and builds until it’s almost unbearable. That’s a testament to Martin’s production, which uses jagged bursts of light and sound to turn this intimate story into a swaggering epic – while Miriam Buether’s design creates a stage that feels like the contents of Jessica’s brain, childhood scenes emerging from the blackness. But most of all, it’s down to Pike’s immaculately judged performance, as the principles Jessica has built her life upon start to crumble to dust.’

LondonTheatre1‘s Chris Omaweng summed up his experience thus: ‘Rosamund Pike is a convincing tour de force, giving her central character a wide range of palpable emotions. A worthy and worthwhile experience’.

3 stars ★★★

The Times’ Clive Davis declared: ‘Pike will surely be in line for the big prizes at the end of the year. In an interval-free piece that is more monologue than straight play, she’s forever centre stage, flitting between courtroom and kitchen’. The production also pleased him: ‘Justin Martin… ensures that the tempo never falters. It’s an intensely choreographed evening, executed on a fluid set design by Miriam Buether that brings a rare sense of intimacy to the Lyttelton’s stage.’ However, ‘Miller’s tale is actually quite slender fare. The writing may be more nuanced than in Prima Facie but you can still see where the story is heading long before the final scene…for all the quality of the production, I have the nagging feeling that deep down it’s really a lecture.’

2 stars ★★

The Stage‘s Sam Marlowe was unimpressed: ‘We cycle through all the obvious, well-worn topics: the stranglehold on power of the patriarchy, working mothers’ feelings of guilt and their struggle to “have it all”, the devastating travesty of rape trials and their pitiful conviction rates. These still merit discussion, but the baldness and lack of nuance or originality with which they’re raised here feels hackneyed.’ She conceded: ‘Martin’s staging strives to dress all of that up in some style. Miriam Buether’s set, a multi-room composite of the family’s tastefully pistachio-painted home, dissolves cleverly into a courtroom, robing room or a murky fairytale forest where nightmarish horrors might lurk, threatening to encroach on these comfortable lives.’ She ended; ‘Pike does her impressive best to galvanise the material, bringing intelligence, humour and sparkle to even the most heavily contrived moments. But it’s an unenviable task. She is, frankly, much better than this lumpen play deserves.’

Critics’ Average Rating 3.7★

Value rating 43 (Value rating is the Average Critic Rating divided by the typical ticket price.)

Inter Alia premiered at the National Theatre and closed on 13 September 2025.

If you’ve seen Inter Alia, please share your comments, review and/or rating below

Theatre reviews roundup: Burlesque

Musical is all right on the night

Savoy Theatre
Burlesque at the Savoy. Photo: Pamela Raith

Burlesque is a stage musical based on the film starring Cher and Christine Aguilera. In a rewritten plot, a young woman with a big voice goes to New York in search of her mother and ends up at a financially troubled Burlesque club run by a woman with a big voice.
Reviews are often described as ‘mixed’, in these roundups, usually meaning there are 2, 3 and 4 star ratings. It’s rare for the full range from 5 stars to 1 to feature. We had feared the worst, with rumours of chaos backstage and previews reporting a mess onstage. But it’s the official Press Night that matters, and for many of the critics, it was ‘all right on the night’.

[Links to full reviews are included but a number are behind paywalls and therefore may not be accessible]

5 stars ⭑⭑⭑⭑⭑

The Guardian’s Arifa Akbar talked of ‘its monster sound, energy and blinding bling’. Compared to the original film, it is ‘grittier and less sanitised’ and ‘far raunchier and more outre’. She was knocked out by so many aspects of the production: ‘You could generate electricity with the combined sound of Orfeh, as burlesque club owner Tess, and Jess Folley as Ali, a small-town singer with a big voice’…’Todrick Hall’s choreography is a sensation, with jaw-dropping athleticism, balletic moves and circus acrobatics, while Marco Marco’s “more is more” costumes deserve an award.’ She concluded: ‘It is over-adrenalised and messy in its plotting, but you forgive the blips. This is a production stuffed with personality, spectacle and wow factor. Come for the nostalgia, perhaps, but stay for the new kicks: bigger, naughtier and camp as hell.’

Anya Ryan for LondonTheatre loved the stars: ‘With Folley and Orfeh playing the mother-daughter duo, the show is in excellent hands. Both have the vocal chops to rival the Aguilera-Cher partnership and then some. Folley makes a Hannah Montana-esque transformation as Ali, growing from a naive gospel singer from Ohio “with a big voice” to a full-blown burlesque star. Every time she sings, the whole auditorium tingles. Orfeh, who makes her West End debut as Tess, might have fewer opportunities to show off her husky growl, but she makes her mark just the same. Together, they send this musical soaring.’ She declared: ‘it would take industrial-strength scepticism not to fall for this glitter-ordained marvel.’

4 stars ⭑⭑⭑⭑

CityAM’s Adam Bloodworth said: ‘it feels pacey, high-octane, and often funny, and is more slathered than sprinkled with incredibly eye-catching performances.’ He declared: ‘The plotting feels thin and becomes increasingly confusing by act two, but Burlesque as a set of megawatt performances is so strong that you forgive the holes.’

Noting its pre-opening troubles, Claire Allfree for the Telegraph said: ‘it is so cheerfully itself, so zestily camp and so sharply performed it somehow snatches victory from the jaws of defeat.’

3 stars ⭑⭑⭑

The Independent‘s Alice Saville reported: ‘writer Steven Antin and mammoth songwriting team of Aguilera, Sia, Todrick Hall and Jess Folley have given this messy source material a thorough once-over. And it scrubs up surprisingly well, enlivened by endless queer in-jokes, spectacular burlesque routines from both male and female dancers, and a naked desire to give audiences what they want.’ She ended: ‘it’s genuinely fun to watch. It might be skimpy, but it covers all the bases it needs to.’

Alex Wood at WhatsOnStage seemed almost disappointed it wasn’t the mess anticipated: ‘An entirely average, run-of-the-mill, engaging evening.’ He continued in the same vein: ‘Some powerhouse performances, popping choreography and a select few one-liners bring the joy in perfectly adequate measures.  But it’s a show broadly lacking in flare or heart – chugging through the motions like a well-oiled machine without the sweaty, grainy authenticity that made the film so memorable. There’s also little here that feels original’.

Aliya Al-Hassan of BroadwayWorld was similarly underwhelmed: ‘the length and wobbly script mean that Burlesque The Musical ends up feeling a bit meaningless. Many good musicals have paper-thin stories, but there must be compensation elsewhere. There’s nothing new or exciting to see here, but it’s an entertaining evening at the theatre. It’s not fabulous, but it’s perfectly fine.’

The Times’ Clive Davis was expecting the worst but ‘All I can say is that, despite its rough edges — the book, by the film’s director, Steven Antin, gets hopelessly tangled in the second half — Todrick Hall’s production has more vim than that other recently arrived contender in the hen party stakes, The Devil Wears Prada. And in the pairing of Jess Folley and the American singer Orfeh… the evening unfurls some powerhouse vocals.’

Time Out‘s Andrzej Lukowski said: ‘Burlesque isn’t totally inept, but it’s ultimately just bludgeoning, a clangorous three-hour pantomime on steroids that makes the original film look like a model of tastefully plotted restraint.’ He wasn’t keen on the sound: ‘It’s very silly and very loud: Folley is a sensational singer but across a three hour, 30-song night her weapons-grade vocals are so piercing and so constant it feels like being trapped in a warzone.’ He ended: ‘Basically if you’re a big fan of Todrick Hall, this show will be a real treat for you. Everyone else should approach with extreme caution.’ No rating was given but it seemed like a 3 star review at best.

Nick Curtis of The Standard was another critic surprised at finding it better than he expected, if not exactly in the top tier: ‘I’d take this daft paean to self-empowerment through wiggling around in complicated underwear over many other recent stage adaptations of established cinematic properties, from Mean Girls to Clueless.’

Paul Vale at The Stage had some nice things to say: ‘Burlesque is an upbeat, sassy story packed with astounding vocals – extensively from Folley and Orfeh – and some genuinely exciting dance routines choreographed by Hall.’ He ended: ‘It could all be much tighter and Hall, in his debut as director, loses focus occasionally. Otherwise, this is a noisy, fun show that actually stands head and shoulders above the source material.’

1 star ⭑

The Mail’s Patrick Marmion hated  it. ‘How to make a travesty out of a travesty?’ he began, and went on to tell us: ‘Antin’s script, adapted from his film, is flat as an Iowa homestead’ and ‘The would-be steamy choreography (is) rote, oven-ready eroticism.’ Even the lead singers failed to impress: ‘Both women… run a tortuous scale on every syllable of every song, bending notes like Uri Geller.’  He summed up: ‘The upshot is rambling raunch, musical cliche and automated whooping. May it rest in peace.’

Critics’ Average Rating 3.3★

Value rating 22 (Value rating is the Average Critic Rating divided by the typical ticket price.)

Burlesque can be seen at the Savoy Theatre until 6 September 2025. Click here to buy tickets direct

If you’ve seen Burlesque at the Savoy Theatre, please add your review and rating below

Theatre reviews roundup: The Estate

Did two plays become one?

Dorfman Theatre at National Theatre
Adeel Akhtar in The Estate at the National Theatre. Photo: Helen Murray

The National Theatre’s smallest space The Dorfman has reopened following a refurbishment with a debut play by Shaan Sahota. It concerned a British politician with a Punjabi background vying for the party leadership while in the midst of a family feud following the death of his father. Many of the reviews praised her writing and her ambition but didn’t think her attempt to amalgamate the two stories worked. Adeel Akhtar took on the lead role to considerable acclaim.

[Links to full reviews are included but a number are behind paywalls and therefore may not be accessible]

4 stars ★★★★

Calling it a ‘deliciously vicious satire’, Dave Fargnoli at The Stage said: ‘the piece has a slow-building heft, starting out as a sparky, close-to-the-knuckle political caper but growing increasingly grim and shocking as the characters’ facades of privilege and civility are stripped away to reveal the seething greed, entitlement and cruelty beneath.’

The Standard’s Nick Curtis declared: ‘Though contrived in parts, Shaan Sahota’s debut play about a British Sikh politician wrestling with his family and his desire to lead his party is an absolute blast. It’s anchored by an extraordinary performance from Adeel Akhtar, in which emotion seems to possess and convulse his wiry body. Wildly funny, sometimes shocking, occasionally absurd, Daniel Raggett’s shouty, kinetic, music-studded production is a hell of a ride.’

The Guardian’s Arifa Akbar agreed. She began with the star: ‘his creepingly explosive turn in Shaan Sahota’s debut drama is unmissable. It carries this first play, almost eclipsing its imperfections.’ She had good things to say about the playwright: ‘It is exciting writing, fast and funny in its political satire’. But there are Buts: ‘But there is too much stuffed in, jostling for air’ and ‘But the biggest hole is that none of it resembles the politics of today.’ Nevertheless ‘it is a sensational debut, and if the best kind of failure is one that bears too much ambition, there is an admirable kind of over-reaching here, and a great playwright in the making.’

Chris Omaweng of LondonTheatre1 thought, to paraphrase, that the story was a lot of fuss about nothing, even so, ‘What the play and this production of it provides, in bucketloads, is dramatic tension.’ Despite his reservations, he labeled it ‘entertaining, engaging and energetic.’

Theo Bosanquet of LondonTheatre concluded: ‘it’s always welcome to find a dramatist who can deliver a serious message with such a light touch. All told it makes for an ideal summer play, a highly enjoyable evening that will give you plenty to debate on the journey home. It confirms Sahota as a writer to watch, and Akhtar as one of our most luminous acting talents.’

Alex Wood at WhatsOnStage praised the star: ‘At the heart of it all is Adeel Akhtar, giving a brilliant sleight-of-hand performance. At the start of the show, put-upon and beleaguered, he feels like some socially awkward school prefect…Like Atlas, weighed down by the overwhelming mass of constitutional concerns, he leans, crouches, staggers almost. By the close, a toxically masculine metamorphosis has taken place…and Akthar breathes genuine menace into Singh.’

3 stars ★★★

Time Out’s Andrzej Lukowski found it ‘funny and frustrating in equal measures.’ He explained that there are two ‘pretty good plays’ that don’t align: ‘Daniel Raggett’s production the comedy bits are so broad as to undercut the more sensitive bits. It feels like two different shows crashing into one another, bound only by a corrosive skepticism about politicians.’

Alexander Cohen at BroadwayWorld took a similar view: ‘the personal and political are layered on top of each other until they collapse under their collective weight.’ But ‘In Daniel Raggett’s sharp direction subtle touches dissolve tension and hint at the silliness beneath it all’.

The Telegraph’s Dominic Cavendish described it as an ‘impressive but uneven debut play’. He explained: ‘The play’s ambition – as it shifts from lighter moments to vexed concerns about equality, race, patriarchy and trauma – is refreshing. But Sahota covers so much terrain that Daniel Raggett’s production sometimes stumbles when the mood shifts and the piece becomes hobbled in terms of plausibility by its plot-motoring twists.’

Alice Saville in The Independent found the author’s writing ‘refreshing’ but said Daniel Raggett, who directed Accidental Death of an Anarchist, ‘hasn’t quite worked out how to bring together this more serious play’s two disparate halves here, even if there’s enough pace and slickness to disguise the joins. Chloe Lamford’s design is a literal cabinet that ingeniously slides open to reveal hidden spaces. Sahota’s writing doesn’t always achieve the same feat,lacking the surprise revelations and twists that normally power both funeral sagas and political dramas.’

2 stars ★★

The Times’ Clive Davis was blunt: ‘Two plays are running side by side here and neither of them really works.’ He continued: ‘Sadly, Daniel Raggett’s hectic production can’t compensate for the wild implausibilities in the storyline and while Angad has all the makings of a man of straw, there are some uneven performances elsewhere.’

Critics’ Average Rating 3.5★

The Estate is at the National Theatre’s Dorfman Theatre until  23 August 2025. Buy tickets from the theatre here.

If you’ve seen The Estate at Dorfman Theatre, please add your review and rating below

 

Theatre reviews roundup: The Merry Wives of Windsor

Bad play, good fun

Shakespeare’s Globe
The Merry Wives of Windsor at Shakespeare’s Globe. Photo: Marc Brenner

It may be one of Shakespeare’s worst plays, but, in the opinion of most of the critics, this production of The Merry Wives of Windsor still manages to be funny, thanks to Sean Holmes’ direction and the comic performances of the cast.

[Links to full reviews are included but a number are behind paywalls and therefore may not be accessible]

4 stars ★★★★

Anya Ryan at LondonTheatre was impressed: ‘This production fizzes, right from the start, with zooming scenes and every speck of humour wrung out and paraded.’

The Standard’s Nick Curtis ended his review: ‘This Shakespearean curiosity has been most handsomely and thoughtfully mounted’.

Dominic Cavendish of the Telegraph called it ‘lucid, edited for swiftness, emphatically spoken and offers those seeking some light relief at Shakespeare’s Globe a dependably enjoyable, if basic outing – possibly, on a balmy evening, a blissful one.’

For The Guardian, Mark Lawson wasn’t enthusiastic about the play but liked the production: ‘The cast, though, also bring out what is most Shakespearean about this potboiler frivolity: the fascinated ear for speech.’ He concluded that it was ‘a joyous production that is a perfect summer night’s revel for tourists and citizens alike.’

3 stars ★★★

Alex Wood for WhatsOnStage called it ‘a completely serviceable and entertaining evening’. He praised George Fouracres: ‘(His) mastery of the text, his ability to pluck a laugh from a frenetic Falstaff aside, has to be commended. He also revels in the paradox of this central figure: a womanising, callous and selfish figure no doubt, but also a pitiable man swaddled, mocked and beaten by his peers.’

Holly O’Mahony for The Stage thought Fouracres, ‘along with a first-rate ensemble, lathers this tricksy play with sparkling humour, although Holmes’ staging doesn’t illuminate or elevate this lesser comedy in any way.’

Abbie Grundy for BroadwayWorld disagreed with Ms O’Mahony about the director: ‘confident direction from Sean Holmes allows for a laugh-a-minute production that’s full of sleazy charm, trickery, and wit’ but agreed ‘George Fouracres is absolutely fantastic as Falstaff, commanding the stage with natural charisma throughout.’

TimeOut’s Andrzej Lukowski concluded: ‘it’s not a great play, and rather than bend over backwards to try and make it look like it might be one, Holmes has opted to have fun. And so long as you’re not expecting too much from this flimsiest of works, you’ll have fun too.’

Rachel Halliburton for The Arts Desk summed up: ‘this shamelessly silly interpretation that won’t go down as a classic, but still provides more than enough hedonistic fizz for a summer’s evening.’

Patrick Marmion of the Mail was not impressed: ‘Excruciating subplots pass in a blur of regional accents and false beards…Cutting half an hour would be a small mercy — especially the random Welsh parson teaching grammar…But the set design of Liberty print wallpaper and matching costumes is easy on the eye, and the physical comedy just about gets us over the line.’

Critics’ Average Rating 3.5★

The Merry Wives of Windsor can be seen at Shakespeare’s Globe until 20 September 2025. Buy tickets directly from the theatre.

If you’ve seen The Merry Wives of Windsor at the Globe Theatre, please leave your rating and review below

 

Theatre reviews roundup: Noughts & Crosses

Critics split on drama about racism

Regent’s Park Open Air Theatre
Noughts & Crosses at Open Air Theatre. Photo: Manuel Harlan

Using Dominic Cooke‘s 2007 adaptation of Malorie Blackman’s novel Noughts & Crosses, Tinuke Craig directs her first production for the Open Air Theatre. The Romeo & Juliet-like story is set in a world where black people rule and the whites are subjugated. There was a significant split in the critics’ reaction to this revival: three 4 star reviews and three giving 2 stars, with five in the middle. Some found it ‘powerful’, others ‘dated’. Although they all praised the actors, there was no agreement on the quality of the adaptation, direction or set.

[Links to full reviews are included but a number are behind paywalls and therefore may not be accessible]

4 stars ⭑⭑⭑⭑

Holly O’Mahony of LondonTheatre called it ‘an action-packed take, with swift storytelling neatly compressing the plot into a little over two hours.’ She picked out the two young stars: ‘Fuelling it are a pair of passion-charged central performances. Corinna Brown plays the spunky cross Sephy Hadley, whose easy, comfortable confidence could only come from being born into privilege. Opposite her, Noah Valentine – in an impressive professional stage debut – is the downtrodden nought Callum McGregor, outwardly awkward but with a blaze in his belly.’  She concluded: ‘This moving and powerful production is a welcome political addition to the summer’s bill.’

‘As family-friendly shows go, this is no easy watch, but it’s thought-provoking and ambitious,’ said Alun Hood at WhatsOnStage. He pointed out: ‘Tinuke Craig’s tense, grungily handsome production is a surprising choice for Regents Park – Colin Richmond’s towering, brutalist set, all platforms, grotty tiles and rusting staircases, sits in stark contrast to the loveliness of the sylvan greenery – but wields considerable power.’

Chris Omaweng of LondonTheatre1 came new to the story, despite its history as a novel and TV series, but he was impressed: ‘Noughts & Crosses has much to say about tensions in the community, inequalities in society, political inertia, and terrorism in the modern world, amongst other things. A thoughtful, gripping and unsettling production, it’s worth seeing.’

3 stars ⭑⭑⭑

Having praised the lighting, sound and set, Ella Duggan for The Independent bemoaned: ‘The script feels burdened by its source material, cramming in plot points at a relentless pace, often in blunt and heavy-handed ways. Themes are spelt out with all the subtlety of a Tannoy announcement, and characters are rarely allowed the space to develop before the next crisis strikes. As a result, many of their decisions feel confusing rather than tragic, hollowing out the emotional resonance that made Blackman’s novel so powerful and leaving audiences emotionally short-changed.’

Kate Wyver for The Guardian liked the story but not the adaptation: ‘Though Craig’s direction is punchy and clear, the emotional impact frequently feels pushed aside in order to move on to the next scene. Cooke’s excessive use of direct address repeatedly tells us everything we need to know, rather than letting us work anything out for ourselves.’

Theatre Weekly‘s Greg Stewart was lukewarm: ‘There is much to admire in this Noughts & Crosses; its ambition, its aesthetic, and its lead performances chief among them. But despite the best efforts of this bold and timely revival, the production never quite reconciles its competing themes or finds a consistent emotional rhythm.’

While acknowledging ‘ Craig directs forcefully, stylishly and brings clarity to a sprawling story’, Andrzej Lukowski at Time Out complained: ‘it feels both clunky and dated’. He was concerned that ‘racial discourse has changed over the last quarter century and there are bits of Noughts & Crosses that now play out uncomfortably close to a modern-day white grievance fantasy.’

‘This is strong stuff, sometimes expressed in broad strokes, but depressingly relevant,’ opined The Standard‘s Nick Curtis. However, ‘at just over two hours’ stage time, some characterisations are inevitably thin and some issues skated over.’

2 stars ⭑⭑

Clive Davis of The Times was critical: ‘Dominic Cooke’s adaptation… constantly strikes a moralising note, while Tinuke Craig’s lacklustre production rushes through scene after scene, leaving us to try to make sense of a collection of remorselessly one-dimensional characters.’ He continued: ‘A bleak storyline is complemented by unalluring visuals. The designer, Colin Richmond, has created a grim backdrop of rusting steel corridors, columns and ladders; his costume palette is dominated by muted greys and blues. Scenes of violence add routine touches of slow-motion choreography.’

The Stage‘s Sam Marlowe was left cold: ‘Directed by Tinuke Craig and unevenly acted by an energetic but haphazard ensemble, it lacks both theatrical coherence and political punch, leaving the narrative’s rather simplistic premise exposed.’ She ended: ‘Cooke’s adaptation is blunt-edged and the pacing of Craig’s staging is painfully sluggish, particularly in the protracted second half. It’s difficult to invest in what feels like storytelling by numbers: disappointing.’

Claire Allfree at the Telegraph said the play ‘comes a cropper in Tinuke Craig’s frenetic, over-emphatic revival…which is more interested in making sure we understand the importance of its message than in making us care about the characters. It’s like being battered over the head with a strobe light.’ She went on: ‘No one talks when they can shout instead.’ And, ‘there is often a disconnect between character reactions and the actual plot, which makes such great leaps in time and logic that the audience finds itself struggling to keep up.’

Critics’ Average Rating 3.0⭑

Noughts & Crosses can be seen at the Regent’s Park Open Air Theatre until 26 July 2025 and will then tour. Click here to buy tickets direct from the Open Air Theatre 

If you’ve seen this production of Noughts & Crosses, please add your review and rating below

Theatre reviews roundup: Evita with Rachel Zegler

Rachel Zegler wows critics, but is it the event of the summer?

London Palladium
Evita at the London Palladium. Photo: Marc brenner

Evita may turn out to be the theatrical event of the year, not only because of the most famous balcony scene since Romeo And Juliet. There has been massive publicity surrounding the appearance of Rachel Zegler each evening at 9pm singing Don’t Cry For Me Argentina, not to the audience inside the Palladium, but to the general public outside. This was just one of many innovations the critics loved.
Director Jamie Lloyd returned to the West End with another Lloyd Webber musical, following up his award-strewn Sunset Boulevard, which also featured off stage activity relayed to the audience via video. This time he has revived and enhanced his 2019 Open Air Theatre version of the story of Eva Peron.  The critics enjoyed Rachel Zegler’s performance and the company’s energetic dancing. The positive reviews praised the rock concert atmosphere, Soutra Gilmour‘s minimalist set of bleachers for the cast to climb, the show’s critique of populism, and the zoning in on the actors. The negative comments suggested the loud sound and spectacle drowned out emotion and narrative.

[Links to full reviews are included but a number are behind paywalls and therefore may not be accessible]

5 stars ⭑⭑⭑⭑⭑

The Standard’s Nick Curtis encapsulated the positive response: ‘Great theatre can be about many things: star quality, spectacle, the lightning-in-bottle capture of a moment, the alchemical power of song or speech on a bare stage. In this Evita, all those things come triumphantly together.’

Dominic Cavendish of the Telegraph was blown away. It was, he wrote, ‘a total triumph, dominated by a powerhouse, reputation-restoring performance from Zegler, 24, and stamina-testing choreography by Fabian Aloise (who deserves equal credit with Lloyd).’ He expanded on the qualities of the star: ‘Her talent demands our rapture; equally, her mass seduction of the audience feels carefully plotted, enhancing the show’s thematic thrust. Lloyd ensures the evening stokes a cult of personality – combining whistle-stop biography with a parable for our age of showbiz politics.’ Going against the conclusion of many of his peers, he noted: ‘Evita could easily be too cool for us to care about – yet the go-for-broke momentum reveals redeeming cracks of vulnerability. The demand to be adored eats Evita up, before cancer claims her.’

Sam Marlowe at The Stage referred to the first iteration of this production back in 2019 at the Regents Park Open Air Theatre: ‘it’s punchier, darker, more exhilaratingly dynamic and more brilliantly layered than ever. It is meta, without being arch, and while it has the raw energy and high-octane energy of a rock gig, it’s also full-bloodedly theatrical. It knocks the breath from your body and leaves you gasping, every moment taut and vibrating with passionate intensity.’ It is, she said, ‘unmissable’.

The i-paper’s Fiona Mountford called it ‘a thrilling shot in the arm for the much-loved musical with its divinely tuneful score…throbbing with sex and muscle, as never before has the transactional nature of Eva’s rise from rural poverty to the heights of Argentine society been so clearly delineated.’ She noted: ‘Lloyd is not a director inclined to bother with the faff of scenery, meaning that our attention here is rewardingly re-angled towards the words and music. There is a stage-spanning flight of steps, over which the ensemble pound in Fabian Aloise’s pulsating choreography.’

Sarah Crompton of WhatsOnStage said Zegler ‘really is superb, with a clear, strong voice and astonishing amounts of energy as she powers her way through the show.’ she also identified: ‘Lloyd’s quality as a director is that he generates huge momentum, but he also understands stillness and subtlety. He lets the acting breathe.’

Of the balcony scene, LondonTheatre’s Marianka Swain observed: ‘Having now seen it from inside the Palladium, I’m thrilled to report that it’s just as electrifying, if not more, as part of the show. On a giant screen we see, live, not just Eva but hundreds of watching people, camera phones raised aloft, transfixed by her – a jaw-dropping encapsulation of this timely tale of populist politics, showbiz, celebrity worship, and purposeful myth-making.’

Dominic Maxwell in The Sunday Times said: ‘That alfresco balcony scene is both an outlier and a hallmark of the boundary-pushing fun to be found throughout.’ He concluded that the production is ‘properly sensational, in that it hits the senses first, the brain second. Did I feel huge amounts for our morally ambiguous heroine? Not really. Did I care that I didn’t care? Not really. What a circus. What a parade.’

The Independent’s Alice Saville gave an analysis of its politics: ‘this gorgeous sensory overload of a show is its own comment on the rising tide of fascism. Populism is sexy, captivating, overpowering – a way for weary people to escape the dull realities of right and wrong. You know there’s something deeply twisted under that pretty shiny surface, but, like the audiences of Evita, you’re powerless to resist.’

4 stars ⭑⭑⭑⭑

‘This Evita is not without its flaws, it’s rushed, flashy, and sometimes narratively thin, but it’s also thrilling, stylish, and full of theatrical bravado,’ said Greg Stewart in his TheatreWeekly review.

Time Out’s Andrjez Lukowski declared: ‘Coherence isn’t this Evita’s strong suit. But there is so much that is good about it – from Zegler, to the choreography, to the timely antifascist sentiment, to That Scene – that I can look past a few negatives. It’s not just the London theatre event of the summer, but the London event of the summer full stop.’

3 stars ⭑⭑⭑

Adam Bloodworth for CityAM was impressed by the ‘utterly incredible choreography and the litany of musical numbers…It’s difficult to imagine that anything this stimulating has ever played in the West End before’ but found that ‘the show is hard to follow for people who don’t know the story well. It’s endless energy and high-octane choreo with very little time to actually sit with the characters and their feelings.’

The Guardian’s Arifa Akbar made a similar point: ‘There is an approximation to the characters as a whole, with very little focus on Perón’s interiority. Maybe that is not the point, but how then can the audience feel the tragedy of her untimely death – which takes up so much time in the second half of the musical – if they cannot connect with it emotionally?’ She did concede: ‘If a successful musical is simply about the singing, dancing and spectacle, this one soars. The choreography… is out-of-this-world imaginative. The ensemble mesmerise with their sexual energy and charismatic aggression.’

Clive Davis of The Times complained: ‘(Zegler’s) voice is fine but it has to compete with the musical director Alan Williams’s wildly amplified orchestra. Too many songs whirl past in a semi-audible maelstrom.’ He commented: ‘I’d be genuinely surprised if newcomers to the show have a clue what is happening for much of the evening as this dressed-down, concert-style spectacle… rattled through Eva Peron’s journey…Call it TikTok musical theatre, if you like. Everything is radically compressed, and for all the verve of the ensemble dancing you’ve no time to tease out the meaning of a song before the next one crashes down upon you.’

2 stars ⭑⭑

Gary Naylor for BroadwayWorld was as ruthless as one of Peron’s assassins: ‘Out goes set design, out goes Argentina, out goes costuming and in comes lights (constellations of them), in comes Eurovisionish big, frenetic dance routines and in comes a Hollywood superstar. What emerges after all this reconceptualising is easier to define by saying what it isn’t rather than what it is – because it certainly isn’t musical theatre.’ Among the many targets of his vitriol were: ‘All (Zegler) has to work with are the songs and three costumes and she’s fighting music mixed far too loud far too often. She has no chance of ever developing a rounded, nuanced Eva.’ Although she ‘fares better than James Olivas as Perón, who gets no full fig military uniform and has to make do with an absurd short tie, like a rebellious Year 9 schoolboy’. And ‘Most egregious of all is the treatment of the beautiful lament, “Another Suitcase in Another Hall”. Bella Brown delivers a bravura performance of one of the show’s greatest numbers, but we hardly know that she was Perón’s mistress being ruthlessly shunted out of his life by Eva because there’s no backstory’.

Critics’ Average Rating 4.2⭑

Value rating 44 (Value rating is the Average Critic Rating divided by the typical ticket price.)

Evita can be seen at the London Palladium to 6 September 2025. Click here to buy tickets directly from the theatre 

If you’ve seen Evita, please add your review and rating below

Theatre reviews roundup: Intimate Apparel

A perfect production of a superb play

Donmar Warehouse
Samira Wiley in Intimate Apparel. Photo: Helen Murray

Lynette Lynton made her name as a director with her Donmar production of Lyn Nottage’s Sweat. She returns to the same venue and author with a revival of the modern classic Intimate Apparel. With the exception of LondonTheatre1, the critics loved everything about it- the dialogue, the acting (notably Samira Wiley), the direction and the story of a shy black seamstress, back in the 2020s, who lives through others’ romances until she falls for a pen pal.

[Links to full reviews are included but a number are behind paywalls and therefore may not be accessible]

5 stars ★★★★★

David Jays for The Guardian explained: The acting is incredibly fine: Linton’s great gift is to see people from every angle….This tremendous production and Wiley’s superb performance fill out a life unknown.

WhatsOnStage’s Sarah Crompton declared: ‘Wiley…holds the heart of the play, and she does so with remarkable subtlety…a great portrayal in a truly entrancing play.’

LondonTheatre‘s Marianka Swain called it: ‘utterly gorgeous gem of a play…so rich and compelling that you become invested, heart and soul, in the fates of its characters’. She concluded: ‘The production is riveting in its intimate study of the minutiae of women’s lives, and in exploring what constitutes value, self-worth, acceptance, family, and love, with various threads neatly tied up in a powerful second half. This is a perfectly crafted show: not a stitch wasted.’ She included a tantalising promise: ‘The play also has the hottest scene I’ve seen this year, and it simply involves two people running their fingers over silky material.’

Fiona Mountford, writing for the Telegraph, described it as a ‘devastatingly fine production, headed by a remarkable leading performance from Samira Wiley’.

TheatreWeekly’s Greg Stewart delivered another high scoring review: ‘This is storytelling at its finest. Intimate Apparel is a beautifully woven triumph; Nottage’s script is rich with nuance and compassion, and the Donmar’s production honours it with grace and intelligence. The ensemble cast, under Linton’s sensitive guidance, delivers performances that are deeply felt and beautifully judged.’

4 stars ★★★★

‘it’s an irresistibly charming story’ said Holly O’Mahony for The Stage . She praised director Linton: ‘In her care, the narrative unfolds to reveal a rich tapestry, each patch of which is neatly sewn into the next.’

The Standard’s Nick Curtis found: ‘The play is very funny and in some ways romantic but ultimately grounded in harsh reality. Linton’s production serves the material, and the cast, extremely well. And she gets a revelatory performance out of Samira Wiley.’

Alexander Cohen at BroadwayWorld noted that the play ‘gorgeously weaves a lyrical tapestry of a metropolitan urban melting pot, shedding light on the resilience of immigrant communities, their collective endurance, and their support for one another. A lesser playwright would brashly capitalise ideas, but Nottage cherishes quiet humanity first and foremost.’

3 stars ★★★

Chris Omaweng of LondonTheatre1 couldn’t see what all the other critics were raving about: ‘In the closing scenes, the narrative strands are tied up too neatly, which would be more forgivable if this were a Disney musical. It’s also a pity that the storyline proceeds at such a sluggish pace – I had trouble maintaining interest’.

Critics’ average rating 4.4★

Intimate Apparel is at Donmar Warehouse until  9 August 2025. Buy tickets from the theatre here.

If you’ve seen Intimate Apparel at Donmar Warehouse, please add your review and rating below

Theatre reviews roundup: A Moon For The Misbegotten

Ruth Wilson, Michael Shannon & David Threlfall triumph 

Ruth Wilson in Moon For The Misbegotten. Photo: Marc Brenner

Exciting director Rebecca Frecknall, having thrilled audiences with Cabaret, A Streetcar Named Desire and more, has turned her attention to Eugene O’Neill’s sequel to Long Day’s Journey Into Night. Some critics thought she could have done more to enliven a slow-moving three hour play, while others were mesmerised by her faithfulness to the unpeeling of layers of character.  All agreed on the high quality acting of Ruth Wilson, Michael Shannon and David Threlfall. The story concerns a 1920s farm, occupied by s father and daughter, which the owner proposes to sell  The daughter plans to seduce him in order to persuade him to change his mind. It’s a play full of self deception and revelation.

[Links to full reviews are included but a number are behind paywalls and therefore may not be accessible]

5 stars ⭑⭑⭑⭑⭑

Claire Allfree for the Telegraph declared: ‘It’s three hours long, and barely anything happens, yet Rebecca Frecknall’s production… is utterly spellbinding. It also contains some of the finest acting you are likely to see on a stage this year.’ Heaping praise on the director, she said: ‘Increasingly, she comes across as one of our most radical directors, staging old-fashioned plays that reveal human truths through character rather than through ideological messaging. These great mid-century American dramas, with their compassionate emphasis on human frailty, could so easily feel out-of-step with our shriller, narcissistic modern moment – but Frecknall makes them speak anew.’

4 stars ⭑⭑⭑⭑

In The Stage, Dave Fargnoli began: ‘Breathing fresh life and painfully relatable emotion into Eugene O’Neill’s tender, tawdry tragedy of missed connections and unconsummated longing, this riveting revival seethes with unspoken subtext.’

Alice Saville of The Independent was moonstruck: ‘Rebecca Frecknall’s latest gorgeous resurrection of a mid-century American gem makes spotlights orbit round her cast on rollercoaster-style rails, capturing every shifting phase of their sub-lunar interactions. It’s utterly luminous.’ She highlighted: ‘Wilson’s brilliant performance has an inherent dignity that means that the misogyny of the men around her is diminished, shown for what it is. Misery never shone so bright.’

3 stars ⭑⭑⭑

In his Time Out review, Tim Bano praised the play and its director: ‘every line is a punch or a jab or a dagger…Frecknall handles it brilliantly: she knows how to let the humour ebb away, how to let the anguish build…(she) turns the tilth on a half-buried play, and digs up something extraordinary.’

The Times’ Clive Davis said: ‘Rebecca Frecknall’s typically poetic revival unites three remarkable actors in Ruth Wilson, Michael Shannon and David Threlfall. Watching them bring O’Neill’s dialogue to life compensates for all the moments when the play starts to turn in circles.’

Theo Bosanquet for WhatsOnStage had mixed feelings: ‘Although the bagginess of the play remains a sticking point, this is a valuable chance to see it delivered with dynamism and no small amount of humour from an ensemble of the very highest quality.’

Holly O’Mahony of LondonTheatre found Frecknall’s direction a mixed blessing: (She) ‘takes an almost painstaking amount of care to infuse meaning into every word, glance and touch here…(but) Clarity loses a foothold in the play’s dense scheming and knotty double-crossing, meaning revelations of trickery don’t always smack as hard as they might.’ Thank goodness for the stars: ‘Ruth Wilson, Michael Shannon and David Threllfall, each of whom delivers a performance worthy of their reputation…Wilson is luminous as Josie…her early teeth-baring and puffed-up bravado dissolves into a heart-wrenching puddle of insecurity and maternal longing’

Alexander Cohen at BroadwayWorld called it ‘A strong production subdued by the limitations of the play.’

2 stars ⭑⭑

The Guardian’s Arifa Akbar complained: ‘Frecknall has stepped back to let the play do the speaking but this faithfulness lays bare the datedness of the drama, which creaks with age at times. The production itself seems imbalanced too: glacial in pace, it stretches across three hours, not gathering enough intensity and chugging anti-climactically to its end.’

Critics’ average rating 3.7

A Moon For The Misbegotten is at The Almeida until 16 August 2025. Buy tickets from the theatre here.

If you’ve seen A Moon For The Misbegotten at The Almeida, please add your review and rating below

×