A funny, sad take on a familiar story
Donmar Warehouse
⭑⭑⭑⭑

It’s said that conflict is an essential building brick of a good story. If that’s true, you could build a house with this play. you’ve got three sisters who are jealous and even contemptuous of each other but of course love each other as well. Then each sister has a tempestuous relationship with their partner. Those partners, being straight men in the 1990s are in various degrees of conflict with a gay friend of the family. And there’s a teenage boy in conflict with his father, and himself, over being gay.
The story, set in Ilford, East London, flits back and forth between 1980 and 1995- and incidentally the play is almost worth seeing just for the nostalgia, such is the detail and accuracy of references to the period. In 1980, the sisters are stroppy teenagers and their mum (Lindsay Coulson) is the benign matriarch. In 1995 mum- now known as Nan- is dead, the girls are all married and the oldest Tillie has a teenage son Ted. So what Danny Lee Wynter is bringing us in his play is not only the difficulty of being gay back then but also how behaviour and attitudes repeat through the generations, unless someone chooses to break the chain.
The sisters influenced by their mother are tolerant and caring towards their partners. Tillie, in an outstanding performance from Ria Zmitrowicz that throbs with life, cannot fully break free from her abusive partner Ken. Ann, played by Charlotte Jaconelli, loud and vulnerable, is in a coercive relationship with husband Raj. Jackie, played by Jodie McNee, seems to have her husband Trevor under her thumb.
The women dominate the play, as they so often dominate working class families. And the actors playing them stand out, emotions exploding like fireworks on bonfire night. and shooting out one liners with exquisite timing: my favourite being ‘you can’t turn a dog into a chair, and if you do it won’t be comfy’. All their relationships have sad secrets which are revealed in the course of the play.
The men are all messed up (show me a modern play when they aren’t). Ken, a boxer, was beaten by his father and saw his mother physically abused. Much as he may try to be a better husband and more sensitive father, he still seeks to prove his manhood through violence, philandering and an acquired homophobia against his gay friend. His relationship with his son Ted is subtle: the boy tries to ingratiate himself with his dad by taking up boxing and says bullying at school is about his mixed race, which his black father might sympathise with, rather than the truth that he is picked on for being gay. (As an aside, it’s interesting that race gets hardly a mention in a play that mixes white, brown and black working class characters.) Ken is torn between wanting his son to take after him, and wanting him to be himself. It’s a convincingly anguished performance from Gershwyn Eustache Jnr.
Aaron Gill invests Raj with a skin-crawling creepiness, as he quietly but firmly controls his wife. Cary Crankson as the sad-eyed, guileless Trevor slowly reveals the heartache behind his accession to Jackie’s henpecking.
Patrick the Pouf, as he continues to be known within the family from school days to the present, is given a moving portrayal by Craig Stein. As a gay black man, he presents Ted with a role model, both in how a gay man can expect to be treated, and how to rise above it. Patrick presents a confident face but hides his heartbreak at his ostracism and the scourge of AIDS. He also provides the standout moment of the entire evening when, at the encouragement of Ted, he dances to Don’t Rain On My Parade. So much joy is released as neon lights come on and he taps and jumps on and off the coffee table and all around the stage, inches from the audience.
This is the highpoint of a motif running through the play, namely the importance of theatre as art form based on empathy. Characters gay and straight alike love the torch songs and their singers, like Barbra Streisand, that put them in touch with their own and others’ feelings, and specifically enable the gay characters see their life in a positive way. The choice of Don’t Rain On My Parade, a song about being yourself and pursuing your dreams, is no accident.
Ted is further inspired to think it’s okay to love musical theatre by seeing a black man as a lead in a musical. In a wonderful meta way, it’s Adrian Lester in Company which actually performed at The Donmar back in 1996.
Being The Donmar, the audience is on three sides, so you are right there with the family joking and bickering. There is a visceral fight scene in act two. The most striking element of the set, designed by Peter McIntosh, is that you can see through to a staircase and upper landing at the back, giving characters somewhere to escape to while still in view.
The set leaves plenty of space for the actors to move around, and director Tim Sheader choreographs them beautifully. There are two prominent tables- a coffee table in the first act, a dining table in the second. Unfortunately, despite all the humour and sadness, Wynter doesn’t bring much that’s new to the table.
The trials of someone coming out as gay and all the characters surrounding him are familiar stereotypes from the play’s many theatrical and screen predecessors. Billy Elliott springs to mind, but also It’s A Sin, Fun Home, Everybody’s Talking About Jamie, and many more. The characters are interesting, and the acting is superb, and the dialogue is funny, but there is a lack of depth. Still, it may have the substance of a souffle, but like a souffle, it’s delicious while it lasts.
Ilford Boy can be seen at The Donmar Warehouse theatre until 28 November.
Paul paid for his ticket
Click here to watch this review on the YouTube channel Theatre Reviews With Paul Seven















